Are you seriously calling this fascism?
"An inherent aspect of fascist economies was economic dirigisme, meaning an economy where the government exerts strong directive influence, and effectively controls production and allocation of resources. In general, apart from the nationalizations of some industries, fascist economies were based on private property and private initiative, but these were contingent upon service to the state."
At the next election, Obama can talk about how he gave $2B to politically correct businesses (though he won't use that term) and he'll have lots of "high tech" plants to tour where he can say "they said we couldn't, but I say we can, and we did, build this company! Making clean energy solar cells for the future!"
That's "contingent upon service to the state". He didn't say the "entire economy" was fascist, just that the fund was.
Fascism is telling Volkswagen to make tanks.
Maybe, but this isn't basic research.
> Fascism is telling Volkswagen to make tanks.
This is saying "we'll fund {you} to make {whatever}" when folks spending their own money don't believe in the combination of {you} and {whatever}.
Synfuels anyone?
Which reminds me, what fraction of the US govt-seeded/assisted solar biz haven't moved much of their operations to China?
The decision will be made on a political basis. That's how govt always works.
Fascism has a definition, and it involves getting all of the biggest corporations on the same page with the government to create a totalitarian state. (Communism differs in that the government is the whole deal).
We've been funding energy research for decades, and there are a lot of reasons for the government to try and kickstart green energy. This is an experiment with the funding mechanism, people complain about the grant system all the time, silicon valley works, so someone said hey let's give this a shot. It's not fucking fascism.
If it was under the DARPA line item would you be more ok with it?
Yes, but I didn't mention fascism. I merely described what the program in question is actually doing.
> We've been funding energy research for decades,
Yes we have. Is it unreasonable to ask whether said funding has been worth what it cost? Is it unreasonable to ask whether proposed funding will be worth what it costs?
Or, are you claiming that the decision to fund synfuels obligates us to fund every alt energy proposal?
> and there are a lot of reasons for the government to try and kickstart green energy.
Unless you think that said reasons justify any and all things that one can call "kickstart green energy", that statement isn't all that useful.
You don't get to assume "we're going to have good results" in the abstract. You need to show that the specific proposal is likely to work. Surely experience is relevant - if something has failed before, why will this time be different?
> silicon valley works
Actually, silicon valley doesn't work in the sense that is required by your argument.
The part of silicon valley that works is folks risking their own money and they don't agree on winners before the race. Govt programs lack both of those features.
Also, VC model actually doesn't work that well. The average is fairly low which means that the standout funds mask a lot of horrible performance by the vast majority. What are the odds that govt will be like Kleiner and not the typical fund?
> If it was under the DARPA line item would you be more ok with it?
No, but it's nice of you to try the ad hominem slam.
I'm happy to concede that I'm a bad person and you're a good person. However, that doesn't change the fact that these sorts of programs have been a disaster.
I suspect that you place a lot of weight on "good intentions". Are those intentions really all that good when they consistently have bad results?
The DARPA comment was serious. There's a huge military component to getting green energy moving.
The program in question isn't research. It's startup funding.
> Drawing a comparison to fascism, oblique or not, is ridiculous.
Surely you're not arguing that if it isn't fascism, it's good?
While you're vehemently insisting that it isn't fascism, you haven't responded to the fact that it is a close cousin, corporatism....
> The DARPA comment was serious. There's a huge military component to getting green energy moving.
So what? The military does lots of dumb spending. It also has different needs. So, even if green energy makes sense for certain military applications, that doesn't imply that funding it for general applications is a good idea.
We started a company in "a special development area" = 30 years of high unemployment since the shipyards closed and a civil war didn't help. Every government department was queuing up to give money to create new entrepreneurial industries.
Department 'A' required you to have less than 5 employees - no problem you just count the founders.
Then Dept 'B' had a grant if you had created 10 jobs - no problem you just count every web designer and contractor.
Dept 'C" gave you money if you worked in a green technology - no problem you just sign up another startup doing green stuff as a customer and do some work on their website.
It actually did a fantastic job of creating an unofficial network of startups who all borrowed staff off each other and discussed the latest tricks to get the latest grant.
Still cost less than having the army on the street,
Over 50 years ago an environment of heavy government regulation and anti-competitive legislation (as you describe in the first part of your post) was posited by Ayn Rand in Atlas Shrugged. The argument being that it is in politicians interest to make business hard so that businesses are beholden to politicians. She called it the "aristocracy of pull".
I like to point out that taking $2B out of the economy will prevent the creation of- in my estimation- 4,000,000 jobs over the next 10 years. The money must come from taxes or inflation, and that lowers the bottom line at the end of the year when business owners large and small are deciding whether to expand or not. The lack of expansion in the first year means the businesses lose out on the profits that would have come from it on the second year, and like compound growth the missed opportunity compounds as well.
Better to let people allocate their own resources and capital. Central planning doesn't work, and inevitably leads to the aristocracy of pull.
Not so fast. Borrowed money is money that is unavailable for other purposes. That happens immediately.
It's not like the borrowed money was under a mattress.
The payback is from taxes or inflation, and the latter works only if the inflation is a surprise to the lender. Expected inflation is factored into the interest rate.
Borrowing money is the mechanism by which the currency is inflated.
That's quite an estimate. I'm not quite sure how you got to this figure, but this seems to say that each $500 of additional taxes reduces job creation by one ($2B/4M). Inverting this logic would mean that the recent $120 billion reduction in payroll taxes, which was only part of the package extending the Bush tax cut, should allow for the creation of 240,000,000 jobs. Way to go Obama...although now we need to find a couple hundred million more Americans to fill all these awesome jobs you created!
I'm surprised there are such wild claims in such a highly rated post.
The feds can't even protect the border or catch Osama bin Laden and now they want to run some fascist incubator to give the political class even greater control over our society.
This is the first step of course. As the program grows, Congress will start creating demands like set-asides for racial groups or veterans, and it will just so happen that a phone call from a politician will seal the deal.