News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by Ozzie_osman on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:19AM (#22309454)
This sounds horrible and predatory, and it's even worse that occurs under the guise of "financial inclusion". Yes, having access to credit can be a good thing, but using big data to give loans to people who have often never been exposed to the compounding nature of high-interest loans, and who might be desperate sounds disastrous. They're not only use data to _price_ loans, but also to test messaging, timing, etc... same Silicon Valley playbook.

I grew up in a "developing" country at a time when banks started rolling out high-interest loans, and where defaulting on a loan would mean prison time. People would take out loans they knew they had no ability to repay. And sometimes it wasn't to put food on the table or pay for medical care—it was to help their kid get married, etc (it might sound silly, but sometimes upholding your family/kids honor or status can be as important as any living necessity).

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by bradleykingz on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:35AM (#22309611)
And you're completely right. As someone that lives in Kenya and has used these apps, I can count in one hand the number of apps that I consider 'ethical.' The kinds of interest rates they charge are seriously absurd and some go as far as charging 10% interest per day that you're late paying the loan :/

On the bright side, while there are over fifty of these shady apps, most loans (including on mobile) - something around 84% of them, if I remember correctly, are still issued by banks.

But overall, another issue it raises is the reason Kenya (I'm not sure about other African countries) is really slow in innovation in the software field. Tala was one of the first loan apps to be released and it remained like that barely for months. The next thing you know, there are over a dozen of them and new ones keep getting released every year! It's mad!

The same thing happened with SportPesa, a gambling platform that later quit the Kenyan market. Once people realized SportPesa was profitable, the number of copycats went through the roof. Competition isn't a bad thing, sure, but once they really hit the mainstream, it's insane how many people would rather copy something that works than try something new themselves.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by Ozzie_osman on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:04AM (#22309907)
I grew up in a North African country (and was part of and remain involed in the tech scene there till now), and Kenya is actually viewed pretty favorably on the tech/fintech side... I think in no small part due to M-Pesa's success.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by sosborn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:52AM (#22309801)
> it's insane how many people would rather copy something that works than try something new themselves.

Is it though? If an idea is proven to be profitable it seems to follow that the idea is worth pursuing.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by gruez on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:45PM (#22311488)
> The kinds of interest rates they charge are seriously absurd and some go as far as charging 10% interest per day that you're late paying the loan :/

Naive libertarian question: is this an issue when the rate is clearly conveyed to the consumer, and it's the rate needed to make a profit given the high default rate and/or overhead? That interest rate should be close to the market clearing rate (ie. minimal profit), assuming it's not too difficult to get into the lending space.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by saint_fiasco on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:11PM (#22313374)
The only time it makes sense to charge super high interest is if you expect lots of customers will default.

That means you already know your business will end up causing lots of people to be in debt forever. If you choose to go ahead anyway, obviously people are going to think you are evil.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by DuskStar on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:51PM (#22315189)
It also means that many people think that your loan is worth risking beimg forever in debt for.

If I offer you a loan and you need the money to pay for medicine for your child... Is that really a trade that no one would welcome with open arms?

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by vertex-four on Thursday February 13, 2020 @10:35PM (#22323782)
Generally speaking most reasonable people think basic healthcare should not put people in life-changing debt. They view any entity which puts people in such debt with serious suspicion, as being a clear part of that system.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by DuskStar on Friday February 14, 2020 @10:11AM (#22327179)
That's nice. But while places like Sweden or the US have the per-capita GDP to pay for universal health care, Kenya really doesn't. (The US has 40x the GDP per capita)

So would you rather that there wasn't even the option to go into life-changing debt, and instead death was the only outcome?

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by notahacker on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:48AM (#22310362)
there's also a lot of well-intentioned and even purely philanthropic microfinance initiatives that end up becoming a burden on a too-large proportion of recipients too. Tiny short term loans in remote locations create admin overheads which make the exorbitant interest rates difficult to avoid. Somewhere along the line the rationale switched from 'poor people with no access to credit just need one break so they can get the equipment they need to make a living' to 'actually, regular borrowers at 15%/month are good borrowers, not bad at budgeting within their already low incomes' though, and the marketing got more aggressive
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by ryandrake on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:38AM (#22310266)
I’ve always kind of had a problem with the whole idea of describing a loan as ”predatory”. I know it’s the accepted vernacular, but it’s really a loaded term. “Predatory” removes the borrower’s agency and reduces him to a helpless gazelle, walking around the savannah one day when all of a sudden a “predator” jumps out and suddenly he has a loan! Is this really how it works? You wake up one day to find a “predatory” loan preying on you? These loans aren’t walking around attacking the general public. Yes, they’re marketed unethically. Yes, they take advantage of the borrower’s lack of financial education. Yes their repayment terms are usury and unfair. But they don’t stalk people and force them to become borrowers. I think someone should come up with a less inflammatory word for these loans. Maybe “exploitative loans?”
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by jvolkman on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:54AM (#22310418)
Venus flytraps are predators too, but they don't stalk. They lure their victims with a seemingly good deal that ends up having huge consequences.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by ikeyany on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @05:08PM (#22313350)
Taking advantage of people's desperation is predatory.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:51AM (#22309795)
Nobody’s holding a gun to their heads. This is a voluntary transaction.

Even if we paternalistically shake our heads at the interest rates and the way these companies do business... they are giving people an option that did not exist before. Those people are strictly better off for the existence of that option, since they are free to turn it down.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by dvtrn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:57AM (#22309843)
It takes an unfathomably myopic worldview to read this article and just wave it off as “voluntary transactions” while conveniently ignoring the several disparities of exploitative economic power on display between the people making these apps, which are CLEARLY and blatantly taking advantage of people without the financial literacy of those raised in comparatively more developed economies and the people using them.

And yet I’m not at all surprised to see it.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by errantspark on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:04AM (#22309909)
> financial literacy of those raised in comparatively more developed economies

Wellll, we still have payday loans and the like so I wouldn't really put too much stock in the financial literacy of the developed world.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @12:48PM (#22310902)
That's a more recent phenomenon in the US, which had usury laws in place in most states to prevent predatory lending. Payday lending was the province of the mafia in my lifetime.

In 1980, congress passed a law that neutered state usury laws, and prompted banks to change their charters and re-domicile in places like Delaware, South Dakota and Utah, especially for credit cards. The supreme court further weakened state regulatory authority in the 90s by defining fees as interest, and thus outside of the scope of state authority.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by errantspark on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @02:09PM (#22311729)
Wow, I learned my really depressing fact for the day. My knee jerk reaction is that usury should be outlawed entirely, though I suspect that would be harmful in other deep ways. Writing good laws is like writing bug free code I guess.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by Spooky23 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:48PM (#22313169)
Even more depressing, credit card interest was deductible until 1986!
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by dvtrn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:06AM (#22309931)
I don't quite understand whatever counterpoint you're making, can you help me grok your response a bit better?
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by swagonomixxx on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:11AM (#22309980)
I think he's trying to say that even in the developed world there are people taking out loans with ridiculous interest rates, so that this phenomenon of taking out loans you can't pay isn't exclusively a "developing world" thing. Money Mart and the like come to mind, and I'm sure there are many other loan shark companies out there that do similar things.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by dvtrn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:13AM (#22310009)
Ah, okay. Thank you.

I guess I don't recall taking the position that predatory loans was an exclusively developing world thing, but if something I said gave that impression, it's on me to be more precise with how things are phrased next time.

Comparatively speaking, more people in comparatively more developed economies tend to have more resources available to them to make informed financial decisions as individuals. I call this financial literacy.

The comment previously made was not intended to suggest these more developed economies are uniquely affected or affected somehow differently than say, for example, African nations (like the one in the article) are from predatory lending programmes.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:11PM (#22312291)
But it is voluntary. The power disparity doesn’t force anyone to do anything.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by wmeredith on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:08AM (#22309962)
> Nobody’s holding a gun to their heads. This is a voluntary transaction.

By this logic would should allow heroin to be sold at 7-11's

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by matz1 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#22311179)
Of course, all drugs, including heroin should be allowed to be sold at 7-11s.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:12PM (#22312297)
I’d prefer that to the unwinnable war on drugs.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by mschuster91 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:18AM (#22310059)
> By this logic would should allow heroin to be sold at 7-11's

This would at least eliminate many overdoses due to incredibly varying strength or contaminations, especially fentanyl.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by sp332 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:22AM (#22310102)
That would only happen if there were regulation of the legalized drug. If we kept letting the same people make the same crap-quality drugs, people would keep dying.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by whatshisface on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:35AM (#22310243)
Bayer would probably put the Zetas, or whoever is making Heroin, out of business with their six-sigma warehouse controls, meetings, and use of powerpoint.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by catalogia on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @12:37PM (#22310804)
If Bayer weren't regulated, would you still trust their product?
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by whatshisface on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:01PM (#22311032)
It depends, does the society we're imagining have a working liability system, or does money always win in the courts? FDA regulations come along with protection from liability, so you could imagine two adjustment knobs: one setting Bayer's control over the FDA through regulatory capture, and the other setting Bayer's control over the courts, through procedural loopholes and lawyers outsmarting judges. If both knobs are turned up, drugs will poison you no matter what. If the courts are less controlled than the bureaucracy, then when the bureaucracy awards protection from liability it will be making the drugs more dangerous. If the bureaucracy is less controlled than the courts then you will depend on it to hold back against the companies who know that hurting people will be pure profit if they can sneak through the approval process. If both knobs are turned down, it doesn't matter who is protecting you because you'll be protected.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by jfk13 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:03AM (#22309899)
> Those people are strictly better off for the existence of that option...

Not if they lack the knowledge to make an informed decision regarding what is in their best interests.

(And let's not forget that they're individuals up against an industry that is happy to spend vast sums of money manipulating people's desires and perceptions, in order to grow -- or create -- its "market".)

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by vitro on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:56AM (#22309833)
So exploiting people's ignorance or lack of knowledge and/or experience is ok, you say?
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by duxup on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:10AM (#22309978)
It really doesn't sound like they're better off based on the interest rates.

Usury Laws and such came about because it is straight up bad to have people fall into these debt cycles.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:10PM (#22312284)
If they don’t like the interest rates, they’re free not to take out a loan. They’re strictly better off in the sense that they now have an option they didn’t have before, and they can choose whether or not to exercise the option.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by duxup on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:16PM (#22312331)
If it is a dead an option... that's not better.

It's just a bad option.

The impact of having folks in a debt cycle is obviously bad.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:36PM (#22313057)
The point is they’re not worse off for the existence of an option that they can choose not to exercise.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by duxup on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:56PM (#22313236)
They are if they choose it, and even if they don't friends and family choosing it they could be worse off...

People in a debit cycle don't only impact themselves.

Like I said Usury Laws exist for reasons.

Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @07:19PM (#22314234)
Yes, paternalism is a reason. It’s just not a very good reason.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by duxup on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @08:48PM (#22314649)
It's not paternalism, it's good economic policy to avoid letting whole groups of people fall into such situations that easily.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by egdod on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @10:10PM (#22315025)
... because you know better than they do what’s good for them. That’s definitional paternalism.
Re:Companies flooding Kenya with apps offering high-interest... by Ozzie_osman on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @11:00AM (#22309870)
I mean, that's a deep philosophical question that depends on how libertarian you lean, how rational you think we are as humans, and whether people have access to perfect information.

There are plenty of "voluntary transactions" that society has found necessary to either ban or at least regulate. High-interest loans are regulated in many countries, precisely because they can be predatory, but so are things like drugs. Even legal drugs are pretty heavily regulated for many reasons, including making sure consumers are aware of both the benefit and harm/side-effects that can occur.