News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by mrtksn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:33AM (#22306432)
Okay, I have been following this closely as I follow JS libraries and this is the headline: The virus seems to require intensive care to some subset of the infected people and deaths occur when that care is not given in timely manner. That means it's mortality rate increases dramatically when your patient care infrastructure gets saturated.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by beamatronic on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @01:47AM (#22306488)
Eloquently put. Agree 100%. The logical conclusion then is to ramp up your patient care infrastructure proactively: identity and clear the bottlenecks.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by sgift on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @02:57AM (#22306822)
This leads to situations a society has to be willing to accept without crying how much money is wasted - namely: You will have empty beds/hospital wings/hospitals most of the time. And people will sit around doing 'nothing' aka training for the day when they are needed.

I'm not convinced that the current political climate in either Europe or America is prepared to do that.

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by occamrazor on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:06AM (#22306865)
> And people will sit around doing 'nothing' aka training for the day when they are needed.

This is already an accurate description of most fire departments and militaries around the world. It shouldn’t be too hard to accept that a similar necessity of spare capacity occurs for healthcare.

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by donavanm on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:48AM (#22307093)
You are woefully underestimating the size of healthcare compares to emergency services. Neither emergency services nor the military are slack. They are both scaled for sustained operations; peak utilization is made up by volunteers or allied forces/departments.

BLS says there are 334K at firefighters at $49k/yr.

There are 240k NPs at $113k/ye, 3M RNs at $71k/yr, 728K licensed nurses at $46k/yr, 300K lab techs at $52k/yr, and 1.5M NAs at $28k/yr. Go ahead and double that coat when you include MDs and Admin.

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by joking on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:46AM (#22307086)
maybe the military, but a typical fire department is orders of magnitude smaller than current health workers force. At least where I live however, flu outbreaks are tipically worked by making the extra workers double their turns an paying them extra hours, as they have the effect of increasing pacients, but also making workers ill. A bit more of capacity would be appreciated, but tell people that you are going to increase taxes and you are going to loose the elections no matter what.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by iovrthoughtthis on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:07AM (#22306870)
Exactly. It’s like server analytics. Averages are less useful than percentiles.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by koheripbal on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @08:53AM (#22308794)
The bottleneck is the number of mechanical ventilators available.

Ideally we want someone on a ventilator to be in an ICU and under a doctor's supervision, but in a crisis you can put a ventilator anywhere. A patient with COVID-19, will likely spend about 2 weeks on a ventilator.

Unfortunately, there are only about 60-70,000 mechanical ventilators in the entire US (and maybe double that if you include older less automated ones), and about half of them are for neonatal wards. [source](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21149215).

10% of COVID-19 infections require mechanical ventilation. [source](https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/record/NCT04244591).

This means that if the US encountered an outbreak on the scale of what is happening in China, then we would also quickly run out of ventilators, and the mortality rate would be 2-4x what it would be otherwise, rather than the 1-2% mortality rate everyone is expecting.

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by DoctorOetker on Friday February 14, 2020 @02:52PM (#22329720)
Assuming non-containment (starting to look more and more likely), then an unknown fraction of the population will get sick.

The Diamond ~~Princess~~ Petri Dish Experiment, shows that at least 218 out of 3700 people are susceptible ( > 5.9% ).

If we knew how many of these would eventually need respirators then we could estimate a lower bound on respirators for a 330M population.

Working the other way around: 33000 respirators / 330M = 1 / 10 0000

so if 5.9% gets infected and we can only give 0.01% a respirator, then at most 0.17% of covid-positive people can be given a respirator.

This assumes they all need their respirators simultaneously (pessimistic) but also assumes the Petri Disk experiment stays at 5.9% (optimistic)

EDIT: what kind of query did you use to find the number of respirators in the US? How can I find similar numbers for European countries? How hard is it do DIY a respirator?

If we look at the international statistics for dead and serious / critical people per confirmed case, and interpret that as the fraction needing a respirator we get:

22 / 523 = 4.2% of covid-positives seem to need respirators

So we expect 4.2% * 5.9% = 0.25% of the population to neeed a respirator, while we only have enough for 0.01%, so assuming perfect triage of who needs it and who doesnt, 24 out of 25 who actually need one won't get one.

It seems like we really are heading to a CFR of 4.2% * 24 / 25 such that there will be at least > 5.9% * 4.2% * 24 / 25 deaths, where the 5.9% can only rise depending on Diamond Princess evolution...

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by DoctorOetker on Sunday February 16, 2020 @11:57AM (#22342411)
Currently 355 of 3700 Diamond Petri Dish confirmations, so replace 5.9% with 9.6%

so if containment fails it looks like 4.2% * 9.6% = ~ 0.4% of the population at large would die.

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by FPGAhacker on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @02:50AM (#22306781)
Agreed. It seems to me there are, in the main, two problems which include many other problems relating to the general problem.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by reagent_finder on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @02:24AM (#22306673)
Or just cut the budgets.
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by janpot on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:33AM (#22307020)
> I have been following this closely as I follow JS libraries

I feel like I'm missing something. What does this have to do with javascript libraries? Or does the JS stand for something else?

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by tommit on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @03:49AM (#22307094)
If I had to guess, they are just a JS-library-following nerd :) the extent of which they have been following this topic might resonate with more people here through this fun comparison.

It goes without saying, that this is meant without any offense whatsoever

Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by Nr7 on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:12AM (#22307226)
I think he meant to type "I have been following this as closely as I follow JS libraries".
Re:Coronavirus Mortality Rate by mrtksn on Wednesday February 12, 2020 @04:27AM (#22307309)
@tommit's explanation is correct but I see how my typo might have caused the confusion. I didn't notice it until @Nr7's comment.