>It's not clear at all that academic coaches provide value to students.
Whoa there, I need a citation for that, and I need a strong citation for that. It literally flies in the face of higher education research. Here's one study from the WWC, indicating strong evidence of effectiveness for coaching: https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/study/72030. And that was after 30 seconds of searching.
Actual professors provide value to upper-division students who (a) have a major already, (b) have study skills and other skills necessary for success, and (c) are at their terminal institution.
For the other (on my campus) 65% of students, coaches are more effective in terms of completion and spring to fall retention.
Hmm, was not aware of that. I was thinking of how I would have preferred a professor as a mentor, but maybe looking back from the perspective of someone who has already achieved a, b, and c.
It's not clear at all that academic coaches provide value to students.
Being advised by actual professors would provide far more value to students.