News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:52AM (#22287432)
> It is not uncommon for urban pedestrians in Germany to be more concerned with danger posed to them by cyclists than by cars.

As they should! Cyclists are often closer by and silent.

Add to the fact that many cyclists are using the bike for exercise and seem to want to keep pace at any cost.

But mostly - a car is made for running in to humans at relatively low speed, causing as little damage as possible.

Bikes not so much.

I’d much rather be hit by a car at 30km/h than a bike.

Come to think of it - drivers license for cars probably makes a difference as well.

Edit - anecdote:

A co-worker of mine got hit by a bike at a buss stop. Not really super fast, but oh my he got tangled. Punctured lung, ruptured spleen, broken ribs etc. He was off work for almost a year in total. A modern car would most likely not have caused him, or the rider the kind of damage they incurred.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by tda on Monday February 10, 2020 @03:59AM (#22287469)
No you wouldn't: a car-pedestrian accident at 30km/h gives you about a 5% chance to die. https://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/knowle...

With a bicycle I'm quite sure the odds of a fatality are <<1%

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:03AM (#22287495)
Ok, I’m prepared to stand corrected. 30km/h is probably a bit to high speed, although data vs bike is hard to find.

Getting hit by a bike a 30km/h might well get you killed though, judging from the state of my friend mentioned above.

A bike have no deformation zones and no slick surfaces to slide along.

Thank you for enlightening me with some numbers though.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by naniwaduni on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:20AM (#22287568)
While a bicycle probably isn't going to be going as fast as a car, at equal speeds bicycle collisions aren't going to be that much less dangerous than car impacts. 30 km/h is a quite attainable speed for a bicycle. I definitely wouldn't assume <<1%.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by Symbiote on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:35AM (#22287644)
"When considering the average length of hospital stay, the majority of pedestrians involved in collisions with cyclists were admitted for fewer than two days (53.1%), while only 7.7% required a hospital stay greater than 7 days. Compared to pedestrian collisions with motor vehicles, the duration of hospital stays were significantly shorter (χ2(1)=27.5, p < 0.01, φc=0.06), furthermore the severity of collisions were also significantly lower compared to collisions involving motor vehicles (χ2(1)=9.85, p < 0.01, φc=0.04)."

(But I don't know what the figures mean.)

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2018.10.018 at https://s23705.pcdn.co/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Pedestrian...

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by consp on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:28AM (#22287609)
You unfortunately miss the huge difference in mass and thus impact force. I guess it will make at least some difference.

A 100kg cyclist + bicycle vs a 1500kg car (+ driver)

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:44AM (#22287680)
I would take in to account the hard stop.

A modern car have deformation zones and angles for you to basically slide along - you will never get the impact of that full mass.

A bike, well, you will come to a hard stop and it’s got metal rods sticking out here and there.

Getting hit by a bicycle at high speed is worse than what you’d expect, at least according to my personal experiences.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by himinlomax on Monday February 10, 2020 @07:31AM (#22288520)
> A modern car have deformation zones and angles for you to basically slide along -

That protects the people in the car, not those outside. Being hit by those deformation zones _will_ hurt.

There is one thing that makes modern cars less dangerous to pedestrians, and it's that when someone is hit by a car they are more likely to roll over the hood than under the wheel. HOWEVER this is only the case for sedans, and definitely NOT for SUVs. Now look at the proportion of SUVs in your area.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by veddox on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:06AM (#22287782)
Deformation zones are designed to protect the car's occupants in the event of a collision with a tree. They are not designed to protect a pedestrian. (Although some modern cars are beginning to have proximity sensors that can launch an automatic emergency brake. That would help the pedestrian. The deformation zone certainly doesn't.)

None of which is meant to imply that being hit by a speeding bike is harmless, of course.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by lazyjones on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:25AM (#22287876)
> Deformation zones are designed to protect the car's occupants in the event of a collision with a tree. They are not designed to protect a pedestrian.

Nonsense, all modern cars have deformation zones specifically for protecting pedestrians during collisions. All modern crash tests by EuroNCAP etc. have tests for such impacts and current results speak volumes for the improvements in this area.

https://www.euroncap.com/en/vehicle-safety/the-ratings-expla...

Here's the ratings for the Tesla Model 3 vs. pedestrians for example: https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/54117/pedestriancrashimage.pn...

You can see clearly the impact of the very soft bumpers designed specifically for such crashes.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:26AM (#22287878)
I seem to find several papers and books discussing pedestrian saftey in regards to bumper, hood/bonnet design and crumple zones.

I’m no expert by any means, but I’m certain though that pedestrian safety is considered when it comes to car design.

Having a crumple zone that absorb energy seems like it would work in favor of someone getting hit as well?

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by adrianN on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:51AM (#22288002)
About 80% of the cyclist+bike combination is made of more or less squishy flesh.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by lazyjones on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:30AM (#22287910)
> No you wouldn't: a car-pedestrian accident at 30km/h gives you about a 5% chance to die.

That would be including the accidents where the car never stopped, e.g. backing out from a garage and running over a toddler the driver didn't see.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by nyordanov on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:30AM (#22288204)
So, your argument is that with the exception of cases where a car is more dangerous than a bike - both are equally dangerous. You don't say.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @06:55AM (#22288338)
The discussion started by referencing ~30km/h collisions.

Not someone slowly backed over by massive vehicle, which is most likely included in the death count.

Slow backing car vs slow bicycle? I take impact with slow bike every day.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by downerending on Monday February 10, 2020 @01:13PM (#22291634)
That's probably true, but death isn't the only negative outcome. I'm regularly buzzed from behind by bicyclists passing me at high speed on sidewalks. It's quite unnerving, since most of our local cyclists are idiots, generally untrained, unable to quick stop, and often riding without any brakes at all.

I've taken to carrying an umbrella everywhere, swinging it quite dramatically as I walk. This seems to be an effective way to cause cyclists to keep a safe distance.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:40AM (#22287946)
I’ve seen the result of a man getting hit by a bike at ~30km/h.

Just awful. He barely survived, being reasonably fit and not too old/weak.

If it was my choice - yes I would, assuming a somewhat modern car.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by Joe-Z on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:16AM (#22287549)
>Punctured lung, ruptured spleen, broken ribs etc.

What in the hell was going on there? I mean, I get GP's point about aggressive cyclists. I noticed them in Berlin especially (straight, wide roads on flat terrain), but even then people will usually try to brake before they run into you. This kind of damage sounds insane. Was the cyclist hitting him at full-speed? If so, how???

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @04:51AM (#22287713)
Yeah, so at places in Sweden we have the most stupid buss stops.

You have main road, then a curb followed by a bicycle lane followed by a buss stop with a pedestrian sidewalk behind it.

If you want to get to the buss you need to cross the cycle-lane.

If the cyclist is careless and speeding, and you maybe are not paying enough attention, bad stuff can and do happen.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:02AM (#22287758)
But this makes no sense. Whenever I see such bus stops I wonder who designed them in this way. It makes pedestrians and cyclist compete for the same area without any obvious sign. Pedestrians need to act quickly, otherwise they will miss the bus. Cyclists don't see any red light or other signal to stop from afar, and when they got closer and realize people start pouring from the bus stop to the road, they need to breake in the last moment. Sometimes you don't even realize what's going on as the bus is hidden from your view by trucks.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:30AM (#22287908)
This is why a call them “stupid”. They are obviously dangerous, still I have one just like it around the corner from my home.

Just the other week a guy got hit in the arm by a slow riding bike while waiting, which made him so pissed he grabbed the bike rider by the arm and kind of threw him to the ground.

People had to separate them from fist fighting.

Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by pastage on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:56PM (#22294323)
It's actually lots of regulation that states what is important in city planning, bicyclepaths are at the bottom of those list.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by Joe-Z on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:29AM (#22287901)
I've seen these kind of stops in the Netherlands and can totally understand your point. I am all for separate bike lanes but why you would do it in a way to have this separate "bus island" I couldn't see.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by rcxdude on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:00AM (#22287752)
Cyclist-pedestrian collision fatalities (or even serious injuries) are very rare. In the UK they make national news. This is far far less than motorist - anything else collisions.
Re:Some cities that took on a traffic safety challenge are s... by jordanbeiber on Monday February 10, 2020 @05:08AM (#22287788)
As are pedestrian deaths at < 30km/h according to statistics though.

At 30km/h you’ll have approx ~5 deaths of 100, by car.

I don’t think you’ll have much less by bike at those speeds but injuries might well be worse - see stats of hospital times car vs bicycle.