Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by dTal on Sunday February 09, 2020 @05:52PM
(#22284891)
I think the root of disagreement here is that to you, as a pilot, "speed" means airspeed. But to a layperson, "speed" means groundspeed. So saying that an airplane with a tailwind "must go faster to keep enough air going over the wings" reads very strangely to you, as (although it is technically correct) it belies a groundspeed-first type of thinking that is a poor intuition for staying alive in a plane.
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by pdonis on Sunday February 09, 2020 @06:08PM
(#22284967)
> The poster I replied to was implying that due to the strong tailwind, they had to maintain an increased airspeed.
No, he wasn't. He explicitly said the opposite:
"higher ground speed to keep the same relative air speed."
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by danaliv on Sunday February 09, 2020 @09:13PM
(#22285853)
I think the confusion here is stemming in part from the fact that "relative airspeed" isn't a well-defined term. In aviation airspeed means the speed of the airplane through the air (modulo specifiers for true vs. indicated vs. calibrated airspeed).
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by pdonis on Sunday February 09, 2020 @10:42PM
(#22286269)
> "relative airspeed" isn't a well-defined term
The original was "relative air speed", which I would simply take as the way a person not familiar with aviation terminology would say "airspeed"--speed relative to the air.
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by JshWright on Sunday February 09, 2020 @05:44PM
(#22284851)
I don't think anyone other than you interpreted the comment that way.
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by mritun on Sunday February 09, 2020 @07:05PM
(#22285272)
I did. Saying “everyone” when it’s just probably one person is not usually ok. It’s fine to say if you interpreted the comment in a certain way, and ok to be the outlier. But assuming your interpretation applies to others more broadly than it does, is counterproductive.
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by JshWright on Sunday February 09, 2020 @07:25PM
(#22285388)
Both comments were significantly downvoted at the time of my comment, which was what I was referring to. The original comment explicitly mentioned "relative airspeed", which I thought was pretty clear (it's the speed of the plane relative to the air that matters).
I think calling it a "common misconception" is also assuming a lot.
Re:Storm Ciara helps plane beat transatlantic flight record
by danaliv on Sunday February 09, 2020 @09:15PM
(#22285858)
I teach people how to fly. Trust me when I say that this is an extremely common misconception. It's one of the concepts students have the greatest difficulty wrapping their heads around.
The poster I replied to was implying that due to the strong tailwind, they had to maintain an increased airspeed. That is incorrect. The airplane has no idea it is in a tailwind, and airspeed will be unchanged.