Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A...
by sedachv on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @03:21PM
(#2228085)
Arguing the GPL is restricting your freedom to steal other's work is exactly the same as arguing that the 13th Amendment is restricting your freedom to own slaves.
Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A...
by chc on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @03:22PM
(#2228095)
The 13th amendment is restricting your freedom. It's called a tradeoff. That's my point.
Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A...
by cosgroveb on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @01:26PM
(#2227550)
I didn't say the GPL increased freedom. Only that it doesn't decrease it.
Re:Microsoft: No GPLv3 Software for Windows Phone and Xbox A...
by chc on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @01:43PM
(#2227645)
"Increase" and "decrease" are only meaningful in relation to some baseline. The GPL doesn't decrease freedom relative to nothing at all, and only a little bit relative to proprietary software. But relative to the BSD license, you have less freedom with the GPL. I'm using it in the sense that the FSF says proprietary software decreases freedom: It gives the people who receive it less freedom than it otherwise could.
Anyway, the question of freedom between GPL and BSD is this: Does freedom include the ability to place restrictions on other people? The GPL tries to maximize freedom for everyone at the expense of freedom for each individual (the range of things you can do with GPL software is less than with BSD), while BSD allows the licensee almost total freedom to do what he wants, but doesn't guarantee that the freedom will be spread to others. It's kind of a quantity vs. quality thing.