There could be other reasons for this, no? I mean, specifically in Japan's case, a huge cluster of that is from cruise ships. That seems more like a [bad] luck thing rather than the result of proactive action.
Also, I think we should make the distinction between "cases" and "confirmed cases". I'm in Singapore and one of the reasons given why Singapore has so many confirmed cases (3rd most) is that the Government is relentless about tracking infections.
Maybe that's just a positive spin. Either way, I think there's a lot of reasons to take these early numbers with a grain of salt.
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2020/01/28/national/japan-...
Taiwan blocked tour groups from Hubei on 1/24 and ordered to evict existing groups. There are two confirmed cases whom are WuHan tourists entered before 1/24. Fortunately they did not caused domestic transmission.
The case I referred on that evacuation plane is a confirmed case and there is still a chance there might be more cases from that plane since the on-plane protection is reported to be sloppy.
CNA (Chinese) https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cna.com.tw/amp/news/firstne...
Wow, that’s disgusting.
I do the same. If you can read Chinese, I strongly recommend you read Sina Weibo, a micro-blogging social media in China, or Toutiao. Read them quickly before posts are inevitably deleted by the censors. There are some truly harrowing stories of ordinary people being refused treatment and left to die at home.
I have closed friend work there and speak highly about the integrtity of their reporting and the content I am reading seems aligned to that.
It’s an account from a 23 year old healthy male who contracted the virus late December. He was hospitalized with fever and developed pneumonia. Within a week he was in critical condition with near fatally low blood oxygen (claimed 60%) and digestive issues. He would have died without medical treatment.
There are several stories like this shared on Chinese media but they’re not shared with the rest of the world.
I've had people try to tell me "You don't need to worry, the virus only affects elderly people, younger people who get it will be fine." (paraphrasing)
I respond with this datapoint to let people know the virus can be severe, requiring hospitalization, even for young people.
Also, do you have any opinion on this:
One general point so. That WHO has now a te dedicated to counter false rumours and theories on the internet is telling. And HN would be best served if we, educated, critical thinking people, would stick in that with the experts. Who are the WHO.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vMXSkKLg2I
The danger here is that the healthcare system gets overwhelmed by the high percentage of patients requiring intensive care.
Moreover, while many terrible rumors ostensibly from educated and/or directly witnessing sources from the dregs of the web have turned out to be true, these sources are even less reliable than the CCP, given the propensity of netizens for exaggerating and/or deliberately spreading falsehoods. Which is to say reports out of China may not be that much less reliable than much of what is floating around and at this point, as ridiculous as I know it sounds, I'm almost willing to relax my suspicion and cling to slivers of hope.
The undesputed facts so far are grim. 80-90% of the Chinese GDP has been shut down, we still don't know with certainty just how contagious or dangerous the virus actually is, but it is obviously more virulent than any of the previous viruses from the Corona family, and if for whatever reason containment fails for an extended period of time in a region, you can expect severe social hardship. How long can China continue to operate at 10% capacity?
It is only prudent in my opinion to make at least minimal preparations now with 1-2 months of food and water before panic potentially sets in and stores are emptied. There is still a high probability that the virus will be sufficiently contained and minimally deadly, but this also is shaping up to possibly be the biggest threat faced by civilization in centuries, exceeding the Spanish Flu of the early 1900s. I'm about halfway through Gallaher's report linked in these comments (very thankful for it) and I hope I'm wrong, but even his numbers are understandably prefaced with uncertainty.
I don't know who this guy is but he and his son are awesome.
In times of a crisis like this, some signal will get through.
Specifically in the category of news media companies.
There are many stories that they simply can not publish, being based out of Beijing. These stories, at best, will be published to social media by individuals in the thick of it.
Transparently dishonest minimization itself risks causing panic.
I don't believe anymore that they are trying to downplay it, or they are being really bad at it. We shall be approaching a hundred thousand confirmed cases within 10 days.
* A high percentage of asymptomatic carriers (WHO est. 82%), who have mild symptoms and no need to go to the hospital. These victims are still able to transmit the virus to others.
* Reporting the cause of death for suspected but not confirmed cases as "viral pneumonia". Doing so does not increase the coronavirus case count. https://www.wsj.com/articles/an-american-citizen-diagnosed-w...
* A lack of supply of testing kits. https://www.businessinsider.com/wuhan-coronavirus-china-shor...
* Turning away and not testing suspected patients due to lack of hospital beds. https://www.wsj.com/articles/united-american-airlines-suspen...
* A high false-negative rate on testing kits, estimated as high as 30-50%. https://www.caixinglobal.com/2020-02-08/key-diagnostic-test-...
Read that China and WHO are not "wrong" about the reported case numbers. They do not reflect how widespread the virus is. I've read reports that the true case count is 5-10x higher.
Also don't know what to make of your last sentence. Cultural differences being negative? What are you talking about?
This doctor is working on the absolute worst of cases and even they, it seems, have a high overall probability of survival. Also good to see some figures on the progression of the virus - 5-10 days of incubation, 1 week before symptoms either improve or worsen, then one more week before severe cases recover or die.
Regardless, we should all be paying attention to the quarantined cruise ships. In a few weeks or so we'll have much a more accurate mortality rate. I feel for those people but perhaps there is some comfort in knowing that their losses will not be without value.