Denying this reality will lower your risk profile but also lower your potential rewards. If you can’t control your spending and investing then don’t finance a car for 7 years.
But don’t pretend that economics and math are wrong.
The recognition that something -- like your case -- is an extreme exception proves the general validity of the rule. (Yes, I know there's a frequently misused version of the quote, but I use this modified, correct version.)
>That’s only true if you are already bad at personal finance.
That's kind of the point: you can't just assume away the case of "people making bad financial decisions", and that might be -- and probably is here -- the reason for the trend.
Nitpicking, but you didn't earn $30k from investing. You contributed $22,680, and ended up with $28,910, assuming dollar-cost averaging contributions monthly (bulk contributions at the beginning of the year would get you $31,223). So your total return, assuming 8% annual growth, is $6,230.
I didn’t even get into down payment or cash opportunity cost because just generally don’t even believe the basic examples.
Besides, as I've mentioned elsewhere, anyone offering a loan at 1.9% is aware that they are subsidising your purchase. You should be able to negotiate most of the difference into a decent cash deal.
Not to mention the non-trivial risk of being involved in an accident in a car which is worth less than is outstanding on it (which for a 7 year loan is probably 6+ years).
Your financing argument is actually flipped. You will get a better cash price if you finance because that is where dealers make money. Your best strategy if you want to pay cash is to finance the car and then pay off the loan immediately.
As far as being underwater is concerned... most dealers throw in GAP insurance these days. Removing GAP to lower the cost is counterproductive because the banks buying your loan want you to have GAP.
There really are just very few scenarios where paying cash at the dealer makes the most financial sense.
But yes most people don’t treat money this way.
But financing doesn’t make you an idiot.
Consider a $30,000 vehicle. I can finance it at 1.9% for 48 months or 84 months. The payment on the 48 month loan is $650/month (scenario 1) and the payment on the 84 month loan is $380/month (scenario 2).
In scenario 1 I invest $0/month for 48 months and then $650/month for 36 months. After 7 years I paid $31,178 for the car and earned ~$26,000 from investing (at 8%).
In scenario 2 I invest $270/month for 84 months. After 7 years I paid $32,062 for the car and earned ~$30,000 from investing (at 8%).
In scenario 2 I paid $884 more in interest but earned an extra $4,000 from investing.
There is a lot more that goes into this type of calculation but it is not nearly as cut and dry as "you're an idiot if you financed a car for 84 months."