Re:The Seven-Year Auto Loan (2019)
by hurricanetc on Friday February 07, 2020 @01:47PM
(#22269248)
I’m not. The premise here is that financing a car for 7 years makes you an idiot. That’s only true if you are already bad at personal finance.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Assume some charity here. Everyone was speaking in generalities about the trend. You can always find non-central, imperspicuous examples, but that's not really responsive. (Scott Adams has made the acronym BOCTAOE, but of course there are obvious exceptions, to head off such replies.)
The recognition that something -- like your case -- is an extreme exception proves the general validity of the rule. (Yes, I know there's a frequently misused version of the quote, but I use this modified, correct version.)
>That’s only true if you are already bad at personal finance.
That's kind of the point: you can't just assume away the case of "people making bad financial decisions", and that might be -- and probably is here -- the reason for the trend.