Edit: yes as people have pointed out I was thinking of the behringer crave not the neutron, whoops!
And oh boy, is there demand. I've been playing with VSTs for years but only recently started getting into hardware...and if it wasn't for Behringer and their clones, I'd be just dreaming.
Perhaps things are getting better now (because of Behringer's pricing) but taken from someone outside the "scene", the prices the traditional manufacturers charge just look insane. Are they worth it? Probably...I can appreciate good handiwork as much as anyone. But look at it from the point of view of someone who just thought "I'd like to make that sound, what do I need to do it?" and these clones are one of the few things that makes it possible for more people to get into the hobby.
I remember wanting a DevilFish modded 303 as a teenager in the 90s. Behringer's business model has me very conflicted.
Edit: this is odd to me because “murdered out” has been common parlance in the car scene for a good while now, and nobody seems to mind.
I'm sure there are plenty of electronic musicians who don't care. Behringer seems to know their audience, but I happen to think it's unnecessary and the wanton normalization of the idea of murder - particularly associated with music that generally appeals to younger people - is a bad choice.
When i think of murder in music, I think of the dramatic Jamaican slang term. It used to kind of bother me, too, bc I also think of my neighbor's family who was senselessly slain when I was 18 years old. so it's kind of upsetting, but I also own trying to get over it.
Perhaps some religious people are offended by Whittle's reference to "Devil"?
Aesthetically, I don't think it's very tasteful, although I'm based in favor of Whittle and against Behringer. It's just drama and more drama. Especially so, bc elecmusic is entering mainstream, so more parents will look at buying instruments like this for their kids and say, "wtf."
https://www.gearslutz.com/board/electronic-music-instruments...
My point was the complaint tacked on here about aesthetics seems not only unnecessary but in the context of 303 clones kind of, uh, tone-deaf.
To be honest, they're an incredible efficient company now and if you contrast that with their reputation for building unreliable junk it's a pretty impressive evolution.
Most of what they clone hasn't been in production in decades. Often the companies have changed hands or gone out of business. The clones are orders of magnitude cheaper than the real deal used and generally have more functionality (see: the new Poly D). In short, there's demand but not much realistic supply.
It's possible Devil Fish has some patentable novel concepts but the skeptic in me says probably not. He's trying to operate in a different business space than behringer is. That seems to be the dispute (beyond the very fair critique of the word murder and the color)