There has not, in fact, been a proliferation of nuclear weapons to non-state actors as people predicted might happen when the Soviet Union broke up. Because if you're a terrorist group with a nuclear weapon, why would you not use it as soon as possible, given that it's a large, hard to obfuscate item which you're otherwise likely to use (and would represent the most incredible asset you're ever going to have).
It almost happened, multiple times, due to mistakes.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls
If any nation was threatened by imminent nuclear attack they would expect their government to use whatever means it had available to prevent such an attack, including the use of nuclear weapons, were such available. It is unlikely they would be happy or cheering.
I am not a psychologist but it seems to me that being pleased about the use of a nuclear weapon would be aberrant behavior; far outside the normal range. Only a tiny number of people are likely to demonstrate this level of psychopathy.
They had also prepared all of mainland Japan to fight to the death, involving all aged men, women and children.
My grandfather was to be part of that invasion force. I likely wouldn't be here had the nukes not been used. Estimates of US losses in invading mainland Japan were over a million (sorry, I dont have a reference to quote, but it's a number I remember hearing from some random History channel episode a few decades ago). I'm not remise in the slightest. Around 300k lost their lives in the 2 strikes, yes, this is an awful loss of life, but in a time of war "us vs them" does play a rl. Over 450k lost their lives in the firebombing of Tokyo. A near similar number lost their lives in the firebombing of Nuremburg.
But, we dont talk about Tokyo and Nuremburg like we do Hiroshima and Nagasaki, just because of the nuclear element. Each city only had around ~50k dead, immediately more may have died due to radiation induced cancer, bit thats hard to prove.
Less damage was done in the nuclear cities, less people died, but we focus on them because of nuclear.
I expect to be downvoted, but my points hold.
I could see the argument about reducing barrier to use if this were a 1kt bunker buster but this nuke is still big enough to be treated the same as any other nuke in the fleet.
It's actually less than half (1/3rd in most cases). W76-2 warhead (what's on these missiles) contains 5-7kt[1] yield vs. Little Boy's 15kt[2], and Fat Man's 21kt[3]
But I do think your other point still stands - these are still pretty large - large enough to not just be launched for any reason, or small reasons.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W76
I mean, just thinking about it from my American point of view: If we get hit by a nuclear warhead, you can try to rationalize it away all you like by saying, "Now bilbo0s, don't get angry. It was only 5kt." Sorry, maybe I'm too vindictive, but I'm still gonna want the President to respond in kind. Immediately.
I think the only way you don't get a nuclear response, is that the country you hit is not capable of delivering a nuclear response. Even then, I mean, are the other countries with nuclear weapons just gonna wait for you to come after them? I don't think so. You just proved that you would use nuclear weapons. (Against people without nuclear armaments no less.) I just think that if, say, China or the US were to do that, it would alter the entire foreign policy environment in which they operate.
Again, maybe I'm just the type who holds too much of a grudge and most people wouldn't retaliate? But I wouldn't bet on it.
Probably shouldn't take it upon myself to speak for all humanity but I think that's a universal response. Everyone wants revenge. But are they going to get it immediately? No need to guess, we already know what the US government will do when a foreign actor commits mass murder on US soil.
"We will respond at a time, place and manner of our own choosing and not be forced into knee-jerk responses."
An attack will precipitate a meticulously planned response where the US has considered all the angles and stacked the deck to ensure that it achieves the best possible outcome. I don't think the mechanism used for the attack (nuclear) makes a difference.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_Who_Saved_the_World
One weapon is unlikely to trigger MAD, even after detonation.
It's an interesting book, but it did not age well. His predictions about alliances and spheres of influence were way off (he expected Sadat's Egypt to be the Mideast's Soviet bastion and the Shah's Iran to be the Allies' counter, for example).
But so far this never happened and never in it's history USA attacked a strong opponent. Military success looting small and powerless third world countries like Iraq and Libya doesn't mean much. Note that invasions failed in Vietnam, Afghanistan, Syria.
Even more: though Iran is a very lucrative target for looting (lots of oil and advantageous geographic location), US doesn't have the courage to invade and colonize it. Although Iran does not have nuclear weapons or any other kind of wmd.
Well, not after detonation. After detonation, all bets are off. You can't take out, say, Miami, and expect not to receive a nuclear response to that message. You're going to lose a city.
Now, if you launched the Miami strike by mistake, the loss of, say, Rostov-on-the-Don, should be the end of the matter. But you're definitely going to lose a city.
But one weapon, if it is shown not to be real, would not trigger a response at all if everyone acts in a professional manner. After all, no cities are lost on either side in such a scenario.
Matter settled?
Of course not. Now in addition to putting the criminals responsible on trial for the murder of the residents of Rostov-on-the-Don, I'm going to add charges for the murder of the residents of Miami. Might even invite Russian prosecutors over to get in on the trial? Who knows?
In any case, once the criminals are executed, the matter will be settled.
This type of weapon is essentially destabilizing, as the article said.
I agree with you on other weapons, the flight profile will be vastly different.
What sort of response would having low-yield nukes enable? Drop a 1-kiloton bomb on a Chechnyan neighborhood in Russia? That hardly seems less insane. What sort of problems can low-yield nukes address that cruise missiles or guided non-nuclear bombs couldn't?
EDIT:
> "A 5kt nuke that blows up a roughly 150m radius and causes negligible fallout could be used [...] without causing massive diplomatic problems."
I have serious doubts. Even a single atmospheric test of such a nuke in the middle of Nevada would probably cause a diplomatic incident. Why would using such a nuke on foreign soil cause any less trouble?
> Russia’s belief that limited nuclear first use, potentially including low-yield weapons, can provide such an advantage is based, in part, on Moscow’s perception that its greater number and variety of non-strategic nuclear systems provide a coercive advantage in crises and at lower levels of conflict. Recent Russian statements on this evolving nuclear weapons doctrine appear to lower the threshold for Moscow’s first-use of nuclear weapons. Russia demonstrates its perception of the advantage these systems provide through numerous exercises and statements. Correcting this mistaken Russian perception is a strategic imperative.
> To address these types of challenges and preserve deterrence stability, the United States will enhance the flexibility and range of its tailored deterrence options. To be clear, this is not intended to, nor does it enable, “nuclear war-fighting.” Expanding flexible U.S. nuclear options now, to include low-yield options, is important for the preservation of credible deterrence against regional aggression. It will raise the nuclear threshold and help ensure that potential adversaries perceive no possible advantage in limited nuclear escalation, making nuclear employment less likely.
https://media.defense.gov/2018/Feb/02/2001872886/-1/-1/1/201...
To say the purpose is tactical use in war is franking a baseless conspiracy theory, relying on flawed logic that can easily be debunked.
> What sort of problems can low-yield nukes address that cruise missiles or guided non-nuclear bombs couldn't?
Their sheer explosive power? It would take thousands of cruise missiles to destroy 1945 Hiroshima.
Isn’t this how WW1 started?
Hey your terrorists killed our Duke!!
Yeah so?
You gotta let us send in the army or at least the police!!
No thanks
aaaand alliances pulled everyone into a gruesome war
The point of having low-yield nukes is so you can do precision targeting. A 20mt nuke that blows up a whole city cannot be used if there's a danger that fallout might fall on friendly or neutral territory. A 5kt nuke that blows up a roughly 150m radius and causes negligible fallout could be used on a small training camp, or even a warehouse in a lightly-populated suburban area, without causing massive diplomatic problems.
People want certainty when it comes to nuclear weapons. The only way to get that is not to use them.
It's much more likely the "unwritten rule" you speak of would just shift, where nuclear weapons of a certain payload (probably equivalent to conventional weapons) would be acceptable for use. Government leaders, being acutely aware of MAD, would clearly communicate the new accepted boundaries and proceed from there.
For example, if you want a 1kt bunker buster using conventional explosives that's gonna be a heck of a bomb and therefore greatly limited in where/when/how it can be used. A 1kt nuke could fit in a JDAM sized form factor and be dropped by pretty much any military aircraft. Similarly, if you want to decimate a city with conventional bombs you'll need to deliver a heck of a lot of bombs. With nukes you only need one.
I think before we get to the nuclear winter stage we'll experience the effects of a dirty bomb somewhere. This is much easier to do for an isolated (non state actor) group and has the same effect. Statistically this is overdue and only a question of time IMO.
A dirty bomb is an act of terror and not much else. No, seriously. Likely builds aren't extremely dangerous, except to those constructing them. There's many ways that you could create these, including amassing fire alarms (there's issues with this).
So you make a pipe bomb with some nuclear material in it and there you go. You have cancer, and now your pipebomb sets off geiger counters. Added terror, but little added in terms of damage. The truth is that setting off a pipebomb in a NYC dumpster is going to cause relatively the same amount of terror as if that same pipebomb had radioactive material. Difference is your suitability and cost, so why do it?
We're not overdue. We've never seen one in use. We've only seen a handful constructed. It just doesn't make sense. Its added kill count is potentially +1 (you) and added terror is only slight. It is much cheaper and easier to just make a bunch of standard pipebombs and place them around a major city. But we aren't seeing that happen. Why? Because there just aren't that many terror attacks (sorry to those that supported the patriot act). [0]
So sorry, we aren't overdue. We haven't seen one because they are just a dumb idea that is expensive and difficult to execute.
[0] Between 9/11/01 and 10/15 there were 3066 Americans killed by terrorists. 2961 of those were on American soil. 2902 were on 9/11/01.
https://www.start.umd.edu/pubs/START_AmericanTerrorismDeaths...
That isn't a huge problem. I had my thyroid gland removed 30 years ago.
How? They give you a pill of radioactive iodine 131.
Nothing simple iodine pills won't solve. That's nothing even close to a nuclear weapon.
The unfortunate thing is that everyone saying that this dangerously lowers the threshold for use of nuclear weapons is right. Deterrence works when there's an oligopoly of nuclear powers. When nuclear weapons proliferate beyond a handful of powerful nation-states, into countries or groups with nothing to lose, there's nothing stopping them from using their nukes. It's like how in the tech patent world pre-2010, people described all these "defensive" patent portfolios as mutually assured destruction, "and then Nokia launched the missiles".
IMHO nuclear winter is a far more likely end of civilization than global warming is.