The ADA has dramatically improved accessibility for those with mobility impairments:
" When asked whether access to public facilities had improved, 75 percent or more of respondents in 1994, 1998, and 2000 reported that they had perceived improvement. Not surprisingly, the percentage of people with disabilities going out to restaurants regularly has increased from 34 percent in 1986 to 57 percent in 2004."[0]
[0]: https://ncd.gov/rawmedia_repository/f493e262_8a9e_49c8_ad84_... pg 45
If the goal was to increase access to this facility, it failed miserably.
If the position is that pre-ADA inaccessible buildings should just all be razed, well, that's a point of view I guess. But the plaintiff doesn't get to deny their culpability for shutting this place down. They are 100% responsible. But for their lawsuit, the place would still be open.
And if their goal was to make the place comply with the law, why did they ask for a $60k settlement? Did they somehow incur $60k in damages because their friend had to go in and pick up the coffee? It seems like if what they wanted was compliance with the law, they would have asked for that or nothing. Unless of course maybe, just maybe an easy payday was the point all along.
Where do you draw the line though? If accessibility is not a requirement of doing business, disabled people can't access a large proportion of places, either out of indifference (it's cheaper) or just not considering it.
Furthermore, the ADA (at 42 U.S.C. § 12182(b)(2)(A)(iv) - https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/12182) defines discrimination to include:
> a failure to remove architectural barriers, and communication barriers that are structural in nature, in existing facilities[...], where such removal is readily achievable
with readily achievable meaning:
> easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much difficulty or expense. In determining whether an action is readily achievable, factors to be considered include—
> (A) the nature and cost of the action needed under this chapter;
> (B) the overall financial resources of the facility or facilities involved in the action; the number of persons employed at such facility; the effect on expenses and resources, or the impact otherwise of such action upon the operation of the facility;
> (C) the overall financial resources of the covered entity; the overall size of the business of a covered entity with respect to the number of its employees; the number, type, and location of its facilities
In addition, for the complaint under 42 U.S.C. § 12183(a)(2) ("facilities altered [...] must be made readily accessible"), there is a requirement that "such alterations [...] are not disproportionate to the overall alterations in terms of cost and scope" (I'm unclear on the claim that "the Facility was designed and constructed (or both) after January 26, 1993" as this appears to contradict the article's claim that "her nearly 100 year-old building needed some upgrades").
There does not appear to be any intent to place any undue burden on a business.
One side is the ADA is from 1990, and 30 years is a long time to wait for public places of business to be accessible. It is compelling to say you must be open for business for all people, if you're open for business.
On the other side, sometimes the required renovations are expensive. Part of the problem is that building modifications may trigger compliance requirements, but many jurisdictions don't check for accessibility (or not properly) as part of a modification permit. It would be good for accessibility to be checked as part of occupancy permits as well.
Another part of the problem is that the enforcement structure of private lawsuits is by nature very adversarial. There's pros and cons, but it means business owners need to budget for renovation and legal fees in response to a complaint filed by lawsuit.
I wish there was a better way to acheive compliance, though. If you can't afford the renovations now, make the plan now, and a binding commitment to set aside funds for it, and make the renovations when funds are ready, or within the 18? months. And the commitment follows the occupancy of the building --- like a lien. If the renovation is not done as comitted, the premises are no longer a legal place of business until they are. This may help encourage landlords to participate in making their spaces accessible --- it will need to be done before they can rent to another business if the current business is forced to leave.
https://www.sanjoseinside.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Cre...
The message seems to be: this is a nice thing, I can't readily access it, so nobody should have it. Like the kid taking his ball away after losing at soccer. Except this is someone else's ball?
Open to changing my view