There was a “West Wing” episode where Air Force One’s landing gear wouldn’t come down; they talked about the possibility of a “hard landing” on a runway sprayed with (fire suppressing) foam, IIRC.
Edit: looks like the foam practice was discontinued in 2002: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foam_path
>And of course, it's Air Canada. I have had/heard of no end of maintenance issues with their planes.
Their safety record regarding maintenance is pretty good as far as I know.
I would imagine a water landing over still water would be best. Go as slow as you can while skimming over the water letting it slow you down and have emergency boats out there to quickly rescue passengers.
A plane that size probably can't slow down to the point that water provides any more cushion than asphalt, especially with less control due to a bum engine. Plus, its MUCH harder to rescue everyone over water than surrounded by the resources of a major airport.
Water doesn't provide cushioning at any speed. It is, for all intents and purposes, incompressible.
And of course, it's Air Canada. I have had/heard of no end of maintenance issues with their planes.
My heart goes out. I hope they can land this one safely.