Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by lonelappde on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:20AM
(#22202336)
As I see it, Gmane is a stateless website/nntp server, plus a data archive of public data (copyright law notwithstanding, since Lars never worried about it like Yahoo Groups/Oath apparently worries about now). I don't think Lars was protective of his server software IP, right? And he didn't sell Gmane for money, right?
Is there any reason there weren't 2 or 3 variations of it, run separately, as backups?
When Lars agreed to hand it over, why not put out a call to the public to clone it? Isn't the point of NNTP in the first place: a decentralized news archive?
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by numlock86 on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:14AM
(#22201365)
Anyone remember the discussion years ago when a lot of people on the web (including the early github community and alike) stood up against the "misuse" of TLDs like .io and .tv?
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by souterrain on Friday January 31, 2020 @08:24AM
(#22201438)
Or, in the case of .io, a colony/possession/militarybase that has been depopulated of its people. (No, it is not the only place that has been depopulated in the name of colonialism.)
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by netsharc on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:12AM
(#22201770)
To randomly philosophize (probably as many have done), segregating TLDs to political units seemed like an arbitrary choice anyway, there are companies not in the US with ".com", or ".net", and why should foreigners have multiple dots like ".co.uk" and be denied ".com". Or in Germany everyone just uses $DOMAIN.de, so you can't tell if it's a government or commercial institution.
The only segregation that made a lot of sense was ".gov" and ".mil", so users could tell they were the real deal.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by Meph504 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:18PM
(#22205856)
To me the only problem I have with the way they handled cctld, is the inconsistency which has let to a lot of confusion.
I think that cctld should be a sub off of the gltd. just take the gltds and append the country extension to them.
(so the UK for example would be .com.uk, .org.uk, etc..)
I don't know if it would be wiser (and necessary) to effectively leave the US with the gtld, or to try to transition all of them to a .us sub.
As it sites now, greed and stupidity have now pushed the number of gobal tlds to over a 1000, I would see that 99% of those should be removed, or them all fall back under the rules for the global tld issuance.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by Meph504 on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:20PM
(#22205875)
my point is about consistency of enforcement, not about the possibilities, instead of letting each ccltd make their own, they should come with the agreement of following the global tld standards is my point.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by Symbiote on Friday January 31, 2020 @09:06AM
(#22201724)
CCTLDs are useful for searching.
I fairly often add "site:dk" to my Google searches. I know I'm excluding Danish sites using generic TLDs, or using Danish domain hacks¹, but it's usually good enough to get past the irrelevant results I didn't want.
Search engines can also use the CCTLD as part of the signalling -- a .dk site is almost certainly related to Denmark.
That doesn't work for .to, .nu, .cc and so on. (.IO is unusual, the only genuinely linked site I can see is the government's, at https://biot.gov.io/ ) Google has a list of CCTLDs it considers "generic"², I don't know if they have workarounds for sites actually linked to these places.
¹ "A/S" is a type of company registration, so American Samoa ".as" is used, "nu" means "now" so there's some use of Niue ".nu".
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by Symbiote on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:50AM
(#22202601)
I use it when I want a recipe using local (Danish/European) measures and ingredients, or restaurants in this city, or a relevant government or official website.
Many of these have an English version in Denmark, which I understand much more easily.
Not-Denmark-but-English results are most of what I'm trying to exclude -- recipes full of sugar with measurements in Fahren-cups, restaurants in the three Copenhagens in North America, etc.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by agwa on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:13AM
(#22202788)
Yeah, ccTLDs are often poorly run and domain names can be seized for arbitrary political reasons. In contrast, gTLDs are regulated by ICANN and are required to uphold technical and policy standards.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by marvin on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:19AM
(#22202837)
This statement sounds rather ironic in a discussion that involves a .org domain. Although I'm sure country-TLDs can in principle do things that are much worse.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by agwa on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:33AM
(#22202978)
They absolutely can. Just one example of how ICAAN regulation helps: ICAAN requires that the .org registry let domain owners lock in their current price for 10 years if a price increase is announced, and prohibits different renewal prices for different domains. ccTLDs can just increase prices with no notice, or price gouge popular domains.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by bdcravens on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:45AM
(#22203092)
It may be questionable on value grounds, but I suspect it will be stable:
"ICB gets to run .io “more or less indefinitely, unless we make a technical mistake,” Kane told me. (ICB has so far run a stable .io namespace. It should be noted that Kane is a respected veteran of the infrastructure scene, and has been entrusted by ICANN with one of the 7 so-called “keys to the internet”.)"
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:16AM
(#22202306)
The site guidelines ask that we avoid doing this:
Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by dang on Friday January 31, 2020 @10:59AM
(#22202673)
That's a fine intention, but please achieve it by respectfully providing better information (for example, like thcz's sibling comment did). Don't do it by being rude and aggressive, which breaks the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) and contributes to damaging the container for everybody.
Re:News.gmane.org is now news.gmane.io
by snthd on Friday January 31, 2020 @04:38PM
(#22206068)
By making it possible to find, but not explicit it avoids low hanging outrage, which doesn't help anyone.
If anyone contacts this company they need to assume good faith and be understanding - it's possible there are good reasons (the individuals health?) for the non-resposiveness. It's not like they've repurposed the domain for financial gain.
I'm guessing C is cloudflare - in which case the situation is a bit ironic as the domain uses cloudflare DNS.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8587379
Is there any reason there weren't 2 or 3 variations of it, run separately, as backups?
When Lars agreed to hand it over, why not put out a call to the public to clone it? Isn't the point of NNTP in the first place: a decentralized news archive?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_the_Chagossians
The only segregation that made a lot of sense was ".gov" and ".mil", so users could tell they were the real deal.
One if generic, the other is country specific.
.com and .net are both gtld, thus good for the whole world.
.co.uk, .us and .io anre cctld, thus country specific.
Segregating TLD makes sense, they are meant to understood what's behind the website.
I think that cctld should be a sub off of the gltd. just take the gltds and append the country extension to them. (so the UK for example would be .com.uk, .org.uk, etc..)
I don't know if it would be wiser (and necessary) to effectively leave the US with the gtld, or to try to transition all of them to a .us sub.
As it sites now, greed and stupidity have now pushed the number of gobal tlds to over a 1000, I would see that 99% of those should be removed, or them all fall back under the rules for the global tld issuance.
I fairly often add "site:dk" to my Google searches. I know I'm excluding Danish sites using generic TLDs, or using Danish domain hacks¹, but it's usually good enough to get past the irrelevant results I didn't want.
Search engines can also use the CCTLD as part of the signalling -- a .dk site is almost certainly related to Denmark.
That doesn't work for .to, .nu, .cc and so on. (.IO is unusual, the only genuinely linked site I can see is the government's, at https://biot.gov.io/ ) Google has a list of CCTLDs it considers "generic"², I don't know if they have workarounds for sites actually linked to these places.
¹ "A/S" is a type of company registration, so American Samoa ".as" is used, "nu" means "now" so there's some use of Niue ".nu".
² https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/182192#generic-...
Many of these have an English version in Denmark, which I understand much more easily.
Not-Denmark-but-English results are most of what I'm trying to exclude -- recipes full of sugar with measurements in Fahren-cups, restaurants in the three Copenhagens in North America, etc.
https://techcrunch.com/2011/04/04/letter-ly-abrupt-ly-loses-...
And .io is certainly worse than .org will ever be - there have been numerous security outages of the .io name servers and one very bad security incident: https://thehackerblog.com/the-io-error-taking-control-of-all...
If people start using TLDs in a sense that differs from the original intent, are these people necessarily wrong?
I don't have much of an opinion one way or the other. Although, perhaps, I'd be willing to say: who am I to tell others they're wrong?
This tld is problematic and really, should not be used.
https://gigaom.com/2014/06/30/the-dark-side-of-io-how-the-u-...
"ICB gets to run .io “more or less indefinitely, unless we make a technical mistake,” Kane told me. (ICB has so far run a stable .io namespace. It should be noted that Kane is a respected veteran of the infrastructure scene, and has been entrusted by ICANN with one of the 7 so-called “keys to the internet”.)"
If migrating to .io is a change for the better, I do not know. Why not something more traditional like .com or .net?
Edit: Disregard completely.
The guy evidently lost the domain through some mild incompetence, and never managed to restore it. Boy, does that have to suck.
Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
If anyone contacts this company they need to assume good faith and be understanding - it's possible there are good reasons (the individuals health?) for the non-resposiveness. It's not like they've repurposed the domain for financial gain.
I'm guessing C is cloudflare - in which case the situation is a bit ironic as the domain uses cloudflare DNS.
Something like patreon at least to keep it going.
Hate to see a great resource with a "single point of success".