How would that even work? If I browse to any random public page of your website, it's served to me before you've even transmitted the terms of service. How could I be bound by those terms of service when I haven't even seen them?
I think these sorts of contracts are called Adhesion Contracts (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/adhesion-contract.asp) and we interact with them all the time. For example, if you valet your car, the valet will hand you a piece of paper with a number printed on it to retrieve your car. On that paper you will find an adhesion contract that is valid and real (although not as powerful as the types of contracts that you sign)
A paper served you by the valet is not an immediate contract as you can deny agreeing to it and service does not happen.
You cannot do that with a publicly visible website, unless you show ToS and require agreement before first use. If you allow a non-transferable license then said data cannot be used by a search engine. If it's transferable you just pushed the problem towards scraping a different bot. (Well, you could have a direct agreement with a few major search engines.)
Caveat emptor: not a lawyer.
Except it sounds like the owner doesn't. If the information is on the page made public, the owner of the page can't place terms on what is done with the data downstream. They'd have to implement some real binding system such as authentication where CFAA would apply. (IANAL)
And said ToS would have to force copyright reassignment rather than a general licence, making LinkedIn culpable for any unlawful content published by users of its site.
TOS are a lot like EULAs. If they look like contracts of adhesion, then they're going to get more scrutiny and skepticism. The TOS that you claim applies even to every single random visitor to your site where they do not in fact affirmatively agree to the terms is potentially going to look more like a contract of adhesion. That's a lot harder to enforce.
If they are used more for CYA so that you can ban undesirable accounts from your website which people explicitly agreed to when they signed up for it, or so that you can just up and alter your entire business model without having to give all of your customers refunds, then they're easier to defend.
Just my general opinion, of course. Every jurisdiction is different.
When you create an account, etc., you are agreeing to those terms. If I browse a public webpage that just has a terms of service link on the bottom of it, I've not agreed to anything.
Typically you'll see TOS say something along the lines of "by continuing to access this site you agree..." or "if you do not agree with these terms you may not access this site..."
Whether that's enough to create a binding contract depends on the jurisdiction and who you ask.
I don't think criminal law was ever part of this.
LinkedIn made threats accusing hiq of criminal behavior, but that doesn't mean there's any criminal precedent being set here, as far as I can tell. And no one was criminally charged.
Separately, part of the ruling states that for the purposes of authorization, defying a cease and desist letter does not constitute illegal access, which might have some criminal implications. They imply some sort of technical authorization system must be bypassed, which didn't happen, since the data is "public."
(Which doesn't square well, imho, with existing meatspace law. If a public serving business banned someone from their store, the door being unlocked isn't an excuse to ignore that ban and trespass. But I digress.)
With the overlapping areas of law, it's admittedly beyond my understanding. But the law is generally viewed, like dmca, as being overreaching, if not at least partly unconstitutional.
Reply All - #43 The Law That Sticks https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/rnhoxb
Are you sure about this? I am not a lawyer, but I believe that the Terms of Service applies to all users, not just those that explicitly set up a user account.
I have interpreted the LinkedIn ruling to mean that scraping public data is no longer criminal activity but it still leaves you open to civil lawsuits for violating the ToS of the website you are scraping.