No. Listen to the Talking Machines podcast with Nick Patterson (who was a senior VP in research at RennTech for a long time). To paraphrase he says that the vast majority of their strategies are no more than simple linear regression. The challenge is that even though regression is conceptually simple it still takes smart people to answer questions like "what should you be regressing", or "should you apply any transform" or "how should you clean your data" or "do you understand the process well enough to realize when results are obviously unrealistic".
The thing that makes a firm like Renaissance a league above a firm like Two Sigma is the same thing that makes Two Sigma a league above a firm like Winton. It's not mathematical gnosticism, it's plain old operational excellence. It's things like expansive reliable curated datasets, deep expertise on market structure, good execution systems, powerful research and backtesting software, good access to markets, economies of scale, talented practitioners, and excellent organizational management.
So I was talking about the "what should I be regressing" and "transformation" (you can use gauge theory to adjust for inflation and changes in exchange rate in non-obvious ways) part. There is no question that having access to enough data and operational excellent are a complementary component.
Building a workflow around simple concepts is where the engineering challenge lies.
you make the typical mistake of someone that knows a lot of math: you go up the ladder of abstraction from an example and think that the abstraction says something about the example. it doesn't - you've just hidden the simplicity of the example under the mathematical baggage.
I think other commenters are correct when they say HMMs and linear regression made them much of their money in the 90's. I wrote an article [0] summarizing this.
But it is always tempting to think they must be doing something esoteric and mystical at Medallion. A part of me thinks that when interviewed the employees of Medallion say they do whatever simple XYZ technique from quantopian.com/lectures just so that the reporter with a distant memory of HS math leaves them alone. Another part of me does believe that you can do simple things at scale and still make money.
[0]: https://medium.com/@ilyakavalerov/the-man-who-solved-the-mar...
I got this impressions from several of Simons interviews, and then the recent book has added more clues.
Note that the Baum-Welch algo is one of the leading algos used to solve the underlying model and Baum worked at Rentech.
Do you mean "The Man Who Solved the Market: How Jim Simons Launched the Quant Revolution" which I read, or another book?
okay now suppose you want to compare the wind at two points. you can't just take the vectors at those two points and take a dot product because they're not in the same vector space (each of them is in a vector space tangent to the point they're anchored at). to figure out the issue with doing this watch this video
https://youtu.be/p1tfZD2Bm0w?t=170
you have to perform parallel transport. one way to do this is to track how much moving the vector changes it (messes with its orientation). that's the connection and the covariant derivative. you can then take a look at how that connection itself changes over the surface of the earth. if it's curl free (recall curl free vector field from multivariable calculus) then you don't have eddies in your wind charts i.e. you can't get faster by going around in a loop.
absolutely none of this applies to currency or equities because the surface of the earth is smooth and curved. neither of this is true about equities or securities or currency.
We've had to ask you about this before, so could you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended? We'd appreciate it.
In currency trading example the curvature $F$ of the gauge connection $A$ vanishes precisely, when there is no arbitrage opportunity. Now what Chern and Simons discovered is a differential form K (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chern–Simons_form), which when taken as the action S(A) of a gauge field $A$, has a corresponding field equation $F = 0$ (i.e. in the finance case = no arbitrage). In these equations time does not enter, however there are several ways in which on can incorporate time into the picture (for a naive example see also the lecture notes). Assets in this framework live in associated vector bundles of the principal bundle defining exchange rates.
My speculative assertion is that it is possible to identify "topological invariants" which can be computed by sequences of trades, i.e. parallel transport along the gauge connection and that those can have provably positive expected return. The fact that the fund is limited to a small amount of invested capital might be related to the fact that the strategies require measurements, that would have self-interactions if they were too large.