Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by codingslave on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:30AM
(#22180220)
Investing is like tech, its winner take all. This is like being surprised that Google dominates search
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by sweeneyrod on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @12:07PM
(#22182929)
No, it's the exact opposite. The limit of how much money you can put through a given strategy mean there is an antieconomy of scale that encourages lots of small firms.
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by codingslave on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:34PM
(#22184176)
this is the complete opposite of true. I work in the industry, too busy to write up a response. But basically, the top five hedge funds are making most of the returns and are attracting most of the capital. the industry is consolidating
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by sweeneyrod on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:09PM
(#22185237)
It's certainly plausible that the few best funds are outliers in terms of return. And I'm sure they attract a lot of capital in the sense that a lot of people want to invest in them, but that doesn't mean they allow it. As far as I can tell, the top 5 hedge funds by AUM have around 10% of the whole sector's capital. In comparison, the top 5 tech companies in the S&P500 have market caps summing to around 10% of the whole index (not just the tech sector).
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by texasbigdata on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:50PM
(#22186851)
Dollar weighted? Real question. Take Bridgewater and a 5% return and that's billions in profit which likely represents a meaningful portion of the total profits made. Is that what you mean?
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by smabie on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:37AM
(#22180910)
No it’s not. The market return isn’t zero-sum. Everyone can acheive it (by definition). Moreover, there’s a lot of different kinds of alpha in the market and no one firm is going to be able to capture anymore than a small chunk.
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by endorphone on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:31AM
(#22180232)
Only it isn't like that at all.
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by codingslave on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:03AM
(#22180537)
areas like HFT are
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by smabie on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:41AM
(#22180951)
HFT isn’t investing. Moreover, RenTec isn’t a HFT firm. No one knows exactly what they do, but I suspect they are primarily a market neutral short-term factor model firm with a very very good execution and slippage model.
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by endorphone on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:41AM
(#22180959)
There are dozens of HFT players, all endlessly leap-frogging each other. Despite the fact that HFT is actually a relatively tiny market (the crumbs claimed by the HFT market account for at most a couple of billion a year), and is grossly overstated in significance.
In the broader market there are tens of thousands of major players, and millions of smaller participants. There is no network effect, and the market is so enormous that it doesn't concentrate.
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by codingslave on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:48AM
(#22182621)
Most HFT players are barely making money, theres a few that are actually highly profitable
People in this thread are confusing beta and alpha, alpha is limited and competed for
Re:Medallion Fund “Stretches Explanation to the Limit,” Prof...
by sjtindell on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:40AM
(#22182511)
Saying tech is winner take all, and investing is like that, seems wrong.
I like the Google search comparison though - a few academics found a novel approach, then hired only the best and brightest and used technological advantage to grow. The comparison is quite apt actually.