News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by luma on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:07AM (#22169454)
Win7 won't be open sourced for the same reason that makes nearly any large closed-source software project nearly impossible to re-license: it's packed full of licensed code and libraries that don't belong to MS.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:27AM (#22169616)
And I've little doubt that the FSF knows this. The demand smells of performance art to me.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TrickyRick on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:32AM (#22169663)
Of course it's a PR trick, anyone with even the slightest experience in software development can figure out that it's a lot of work to open-source a larger project. Also considering what's mentioned in the article, plenty of this code is probably still in use in later Windows versions which are still sold.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by hobs on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:46AM (#22169802)
If its a PR trick, its one that makes the FSF look stupid to anyone in the know, and a zealot to the rest of humanity. It's not a good call.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:09AM (#22170048)
I don't know about stupid, but perhaps woefully out of touch. In 2020, they're still trying to fight fights from the 1990s, using tactics that haven't really worked since the 1990s.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by squarefoot on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:33AM (#22170285)
Well, in 2020 people are more sensitive to privacy issues, malware and spyware are still much easier to hide in closed source software, and bugs are much easier to correct if one has the sources at hand, therefore I'd say the request would be even more legit today compared to the 90s.

I however agree that's is not going to happen both because of the nightmare of relicensing 3rd party code, and because an OSS Win7 release with community updates and security patches (no telemetry) would probably displace a good number of Windows 10 installs in short time.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:00AM (#22170538)
Absolutely. But, even if you frame it that way, asking Microsoft to open source Windows 7 feels like trying to take a 2020 concern and approach it as if we were still back in 1999.

If closed source software that talks to the Internet is an inherent privacy risk, let's maybe start by focusing on Google Chrome and Android, which have access to much bigger pots of honey than Windows itself does these days.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by zozbot234 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:02AM (#22170570)
Both Google Chrome and Android have open source releases.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:54AM (#22171183)
Their existence doesn't do much to alleviate privacy concerns circling the closed-source bits of the versions of those apps that basically everyone is using, though.

In short, this seems to be one of those spots where all the FSF has is a hammer.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Teever on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:44AM (#22171063)
Pish-Posh.

If Microsoft was as dedicated to open source as their recent PR pivot and thrust has lead us to think then they would have no problem taking on this monumental task.

this 'stupid' PR move from the FSF is only a response to a similiar PR move from MS.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Delmania on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:27PM (#22172453)
You miss the point where Microsoft would have to acquire those licenses or release a half finished system. What value proposition is there for them to do it?
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by unapologetic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:08PM (#22172933)
If Windows 10 is really evergreen then they could do it over the course of years.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by HeadsUpHigh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:10PM (#22171354)
About as stupid as microsoft "loving" linux.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TomMarius on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:28PM (#22171585)
What is stupid about Microsoft loving Linux? A large portion of their business offering is built on Linux.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by HeadsUpHigh on Friday January 31, 2020 @05:47AM (#22200639)
It's disingenuous. It's pure business made to be something more than that. Meanwhile they are still progressing as expected with invading privacy and taking away control on their consumer offerings.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by unapologetic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#22172951)
Seriously. You don't have to trust microsoft to realize that their linux interest is genuine. It's just smart business.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by chameleon_world on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:12PM (#22175683)
Yeah but I want to make fun of a huge corporation for fakely supporting something only a small minority of us computer elite use
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TomMarius on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:27AM (#22178811)
You mean the OS that powers most of servers and mobile phones in the world, which is the (very real and pragmatic) reason for Microsoft's support?
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by JoelTheSuperior on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:12AM (#22170686)
A few years ago I was considering open sourcing a small app I had developed a few years ago. Turns out it'd actually require a lot of work to remove dependencies on other libraries I'd used.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by timdiggerm on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:03AM (#22169983)
That would be very-FSF of them.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by benologist on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:06AM (#22170615)
How much software (and other IP) must we lose forever before open sourcing is seen as a reasonable demand?
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by sascha_sl on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:22PM (#22173654)
A demand is unreasonable if it is practically unfulfillable, ask for some libraries to improve wine/reactos, say it should've been really free software and move on.

This just looks silly.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by sascha_sl on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:21PM (#22173641)
should've just asked to open source a few core libraries for wine/reactos, but of course the FSF and famously RMS don't care about practical progress, only about being able to somehow (however inaccessible) use free software only and talk about how unethical everyone else is
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by neurobashing on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:16AM (#22169533)
I wish I could find the source, but I once read that people at Apple considered opening up Classic, but there was so much 3rd party code a releasable blob would take a ton of engineering hours to scrub it all, and couldn't justify the cost.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by zozbot234 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:05AM (#22170608)
Mozilla did it back in the day with their Netscape browser (now SeaMonkey). Sure, so much third-party code had to be stripped out that the code didn't even build to begin with, but those parts got rewritten and the problem was fixed.

Blender also used to be a wholly closed-source product; it was opened up after the source code was "liberated" via a Kickstarter-like crowdfunding initiative - and it's now a successful FLOSS project. It can happen.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by summerlight on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:07PM (#22172181)
The problem is its scale. Windows likely has ~100M lines of implementation, which needs to be fully audited in a legal way before open-sourcing. Maybe open-sourcing NT kernel is a more realistic and useful goal.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by cycloptic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:51PM (#22176390)
If there are any software companies on this planet that can afford to keep tabs on the legality of its own source code, I hope that Microsoft with their trillion-dollar market cap (and already very complex licensing situation) is one of them. It would be very sad for everyone in this whole industry if they weren't. It's honestly getting very tired to hear excuses about these F100 companies not being able to afford to do something. That isn't why they refuse to do it, and you know this.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by acdha on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:39AM (#22179480)
Remember: it’s not whether their code is legal to use but to redistribute in a new way. If they have a contract their existing usage is covered without needing to go through line by line checking who wrote the portions which are still in use. One you add redistribution they have to go through and assess what needs to be renegotiated to add those terms. Given the age of the codebase I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s not even clear who owns the rights given how many small companies sold code libraries back in the 80s and 90s before disappearing or being multiply acquired. That’s a non-trivial amount of new work which only has to be done to release the code.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by bangboombang on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:11AM (#22169490)
Exactly that. Bundled 3rd party software would probably be the easiest part to remove, but there is tons of supporting code, libraries and whatnot intermixed with core components that even if they wanted to, it would cost them a lot of resources to strip it clean of that stuff.

But just imagining that happening... Would be super crazy.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by chooseaname on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:59AM (#22169948)
Not only that, but their current product (Windows 10) probably uses 80% of the same code. You can't get a manager to sign off on releasing current code as open source.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:15PM (#22171422)
Also, from a legal liability standpoint, it's a near guarantee that SOME trivial quantity of open source code snuck in at some point in the last few decades. No matter how great your intentions are, somebody will have done it wrong, and the legal openings from "you used our copyrighted stuff to make Windows now pay us" is probably substantial.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by cr0sh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:14AM (#22170708)
That's pretty much also why they'll never open source VB6, despite a very large number of developers wanting it.

Instead, Microsoft has been virtually forced to continue to include the VB runtime DLL in every version of Windows since, because there are so many businesses out there that rely on software developed in VB6 that can't (easily or cheaply) switch to something else.

Windows 10, from what I understand, almost became the first version to ship without it, but Microsoft relented under the pressure (maybe I'm misinformed here, though).

VB.NET is sufficiently different enough that conversion either isn't possible, or due to the source code not being available (or the 3rd-party company that wrote it not existing any longer as an entity - or the source code assets not available or whatnot due to dissolution) - conversion becomes nearly impossible, short of a very expensive reverse-engineering effort by another 3rd party.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by robbyt on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:04AM (#22170598)
This is the same reason why it took Sun years to open source Solaris. There was still major parts of the OS they didn't release source for, because it had licensed code. The Open Solaris initiative was rewriting these parts to make the OS completely open.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by magnat on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:24PM (#22171535)
They did release Windows 2003 SP1 kernel source (named as "Windows Research Kernel") long time ago, along with re-licensing it for research use only. Not the whole OS and still not an open source, though.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by eikenberry on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:36PM (#22172566)
Having never worked on a large closed-source software project could you elaborate any on what libraries are used? What sort of functionality are they implementing with them? I've been in software development for 20+ years and I'm not sure if I could come up with one company that licenses out software libraries (adobe maybe?).
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tomphoolery on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:04AM (#22170595)
Also, probably a ton of unpatched vulnerabilities that nobody knows about, and still affect windows machines to this day.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tclancy on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:08AM (#22170643)
I think that's the idea.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TimTheTinker on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:23AM (#22170801)
They could omit those parts. Sure, it wouldn’t even build, but this wouldn’t be a “product” anyway.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by HeckFeck on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:21PM (#22171505)
Hypothetically, if this happened, I wonder how much the source of ReactOS could help fill in the blanks. Or at least give the new developers somewhere to start.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tenebrisalietum on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:50PM (#22173372)
Microsoft can open-source the parts that do belong to it and let the community replace the licensed code and libraries. If it's really in the business of selling cloudspace and not operating systems anymore, Microsoft shouldn't care.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by aidenn0 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:04PM (#22173499)
How many 100s of thousands of dollars to go through and determine which code is licensed and which isn't?
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tenebrisalietum on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:10AM (#22182051)
Zero. Microsoft should know this already.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by bilekas on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:08AM (#22169460)
This this this this. As nice as the idea is, it just wont happen.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by zerr on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:31AM (#22169657)
Yes, that's the common excuse/reason. But, why MS can't negotiate the move with those 3rd parties? That would be a good PR for them as well.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Zhyl on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:38AM (#22169721)
Probably because that wouldn't be straightforward. You'll have every situation from missing licences, licences for old companies that don't exist anymore but whose IP has been absorbed by a patent troll, companies who refuse to be negotiated with, companies who will take the opportunity to file suit to repay the incalculable harm to their bottom line (despite not knowing their software was in Windows for 20+ years), companies who would be up for negotiation but don't have the momentum or enough of a grip to see negotiations through without collapsing or trailing off.

And this is if Microsoft DID want to open source it, which if they were giving in to a demand from FSF, or trying to do it as part of a goodwill "Microsoft <3 Linux" initiative then you will quickly find that the costs far outweight the benefits.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by acidictadpole on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:34AM (#22169681)
Because it turns from "Microsoft has nothing to lose by doing this" to "Microsoft is going to lose a bunch of money spending time negotiating with and paying third parties to be allowed to release their libraries with windows' source code".

People's time isn't free.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by luma on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:38AM (#22169719)
And that's presuming that the entities that held the original license still exist today. It's a morass that can be nearly impossible to dig your way out of after 10+ years.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Lx1oG-AWb6h_ZG0 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:18AM (#22170133)
It’s actually 35+ years, Windows 1.0 was released in 1985, and I don’t doubt that some (much) older DOS code still exists in one form or the other in their repo.

The other problem is open sourcing the Windows code would be also involve open sourcing its crazy huge build system and tooling — it’s not a simple makefile — which is probably another level of impractical.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Someone1234 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:25AM (#22170198)
Likely true.

They were able to get rid of a lot of Windows 1.0/Dos back-compat junk with the release of x64 (due to loss of native 16 bit support). I'm sure there's still some though.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tjalfi on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:45AM (#22170394)
Windows 10 32bit is still around and supports 16bit applications.

My employer uses 32bit VDIs to run a few legacy applications.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Someone1234 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:52AM (#22170456)
I wonder how long they will support 32x Windows 10? I don't think they've announced an end-of-life, but it has to be at least on the books.

It must be pretty expensive to port/test all of their patches/updates on something few use [0.70% per [0]). They already killed it on their server line (although it was silly on there with the low memory limits). Nvidia has already announced they're ending support[1].

[0] https://www.pcbenchmarks.net/os-marketshare.html

[1] https://www.extremetech.com/computing/267180-nvidia-ends-sup...

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by cr0sh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:22AM (#22170785)
> I wonder how long they will support 32x Windows 10?

I noted in another comment that they have a similar problem with people wanting VB6 open sourced, because so many businesses rely on VB6 apps - some written internally or exclusively for their business.

Windows 10 (from what I remember) almost didn't support VB6, but in the end they included the runtime DLL to allow for the apps to work. I wonder if this is a part of the 32x thing? Seems a likely possibility...

VB6 and the companies relying on it might be an albatross around Microsoft's neck; for how much longer, I'm not sure.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by tjalfi on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:05PM (#22174014)
I don't think the numbers from PerformanceTest accurately reflect the usage of 32bit Windows 10.

I find it difficult to believe that Microsoft would keep Windows 10 x86 around if usage was really that low.

Backblaze found that about 4.5% of their customers use 32bit Windows in 2017[0].

[0] https://www.backblaze.com/blog/64-bit-os-vs-32-bit-os/

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by thrower123 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:46AM (#22169798)
I'm almost certain that it would drift into the same landmines of uncertain copyright and derelict ownership that plagues attempts to revive old abandonware games.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by scythe on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:35AM (#22169692)
Now, instead of paying engineers to write code, you can pay lawyers to have arguments.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by scarface74 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:49AM (#22169837)
Good PR how? Most of the world wouldn’t care either way.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by ryandrake on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:50AM (#22169841)
Or, why can't they just open source the pieces that they do own? When you open source something, it's nice if it compiles right away but not strictly required.

There are probably lots of other reasons that MS won't open source an older version of their flagship product, but this "OMG licensed 3rd party code" excuse is overplayed (by lots of other companies, too) and needs to die.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by UncleMeat on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:42AM (#22170367)
People would lose their shit if it was just an unbuildable pipe of code. “This doesn’t count”.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by unapologetic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:07PM (#22172924)
This is true, but they could start open sourcing components. It's a hard problem but one MS has dealt with before.
[dead]
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by jareds on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:41AM (#22171023)
Assuming there was an open source version of Windows 7 Microsoft would have to make Windows 10 much worse before I'd consider switching to it. WSL has bought me a lot of good will toward Microsoft. It probably helps that I'm blind so can't see any adds or crap ware installed on the start menu.