News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by hobs on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:46AM (#22169802)
If its a PR trick, its one that makes the FSF look stupid to anyone in the know, and a zealot to the rest of humanity. It's not a good call.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:09AM (#22170048)
I don't know about stupid, but perhaps woefully out of touch. In 2020, they're still trying to fight fights from the 1990s, using tactics that haven't really worked since the 1990s.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by squarefoot on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:33AM (#22170285)
Well, in 2020 people are more sensitive to privacy issues, malware and spyware are still much easier to hide in closed source software, and bugs are much easier to correct if one has the sources at hand, therefore I'd say the request would be even more legit today compared to the 90s.

I however agree that's is not going to happen both because of the nightmare of relicensing 3rd party code, and because an OSS Win7 release with community updates and security patches (no telemetry) would probably displace a good number of Windows 10 installs in short time.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:00AM (#22170538)
Absolutely. But, even if you frame it that way, asking Microsoft to open source Windows 7 feels like trying to take a 2020 concern and approach it as if we were still back in 1999.

If closed source software that talks to the Internet is an inherent privacy risk, let's maybe start by focusing on Google Chrome and Android, which have access to much bigger pots of honey than Windows itself does these days.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by zozbot234 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:02AM (#22170570)
Both Google Chrome and Android have open source releases.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by mumblemumble on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:54AM (#22171183)
Their existence doesn't do much to alleviate privacy concerns circling the closed-source bits of the versions of those apps that basically everyone is using, though.

In short, this seems to be one of those spots where all the FSF has is a hammer.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Teever on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:44AM (#22171063)
Pish-Posh.

If Microsoft was as dedicated to open source as their recent PR pivot and thrust has lead us to think then they would have no problem taking on this monumental task.

this 'stupid' PR move from the FSF is only a response to a similiar PR move from MS.

Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by Delmania on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:27PM (#22172453)
You miss the point where Microsoft would have to acquire those licenses or release a half finished system. What value proposition is there for them to do it?
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by unapologetic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:08PM (#22172933)
If Windows 10 is really evergreen then they could do it over the course of years.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by HeadsUpHigh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:10PM (#22171354)
About as stupid as microsoft "loving" linux.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TomMarius on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @12:28PM (#22171585)
What is stupid about Microsoft loving Linux? A large portion of their business offering is built on Linux.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by HeadsUpHigh on Friday January 31, 2020 @05:47AM (#22200639)
It's disingenuous. It's pure business made to be something more than that. Meanwhile they are still progressing as expected with invading privacy and taking away control on their consumer offerings.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by unapologetic on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#22172951)
Seriously. You don't have to trust microsoft to realize that their linux interest is genuine. It's just smart business.
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by chameleon_world on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:12PM (#22175683)
Yeah but I want to make fun of a huge corporation for fakely supporting something only a small minority of us computer elite use
Re:Microsoft urged: Open-source Windows 7 to 'undo past wrongs' by TomMarius on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:27AM (#22178811)
You mean the OS that powers most of servers and mobile phones in the world, which is the (very real and pragmatic) reason for Microsoft's support?