Therefore we shouldn’t look at the current customer mean profit to predict what would happen to profits if we doubled the customer base.
Even when comparing two different historical data sets you have to be careful: if you're doing anything that resembles hypothesis testing (i.e. trying to figure out if something you changed made a difference) you're not really comparing two historical data sets -- you're trying to compare the underlying distributions from which the historical data sets were drawn, but hoping that the historical data are representative samples from those.
Take Tesla, for example. Its first customers were enthusiasts, but the mean of that group is not the mean of all current Tesla customers - they would look very different, and had Tesla optimized for the latter we'd be looking at a very different outcome.