I suspect my rescue mutt has a lot of shepherd breed in him and he’s the same way. He gets extremely agitated if either my wife or I walk away from him. It’s almost impossible to get him to focus on any games, work, or even food if one of us has walked away. (He’s okay with one of us leaving him at home, but it triggers if one of us breaks off from him outside.
I suspect the herding behavior is probably bred/trained based on a highly overdeveloped impulse for wanting to keep the “clan” together.
Shepards aren't retrievers.
But they do like keeping track of things / people and keeping them "herded" and collected.
Not a failure of teaching, the breed just isn't programmed for it.
Yeah. Most "utility" dog breeds have been created simply by selecting for aptitude and propensity for a specific aspect of ancestral pack hunting behavior – tracking, stalking, pursuing, herding, catching, killing, or bringing kill back.
We were warned of this sort of demand / expectation of the breed and it hasn't bothered us. But it's funny that he knows so many commands (verbal and nonverbal) and we just failed to teach him how to fetch.