> Academics such as David Barash say that the term just-so story [...] is simply a derogatory term for a hypothesis.
I’m inclined to agree with Barash. Conjecture should not be confused for fact. However, conjecture is also necessary for discovery.
In contrast, a Just-So story will never be followed up on and simply exists to supply an easy to digest explaination for a phenomena. An explanatory meme so to speak. Hence their comparison to fairy tales via titles like "How the Tiger got it's Stripes"
(As far as why this specific example qualifies, it's basically impossible to falsify the story, yet it's badly out of sync with what we do know. "Wolves circling the campfire" show up in books and movies, not in real life; even absent modern tools, wolf attacks on humans are rare and reliably come from desperation attacks on isolated people, exactly the wrong circumstances for this story. Keeping predators at bay by offering food that won't sate them is the exact opposite of how things generally work; it's the equivalent of tossing out chum to stop sharks from attacking. And we have a pretty good model of how canine domestication in general began - it does involve bone and meat scraps, but scavenged from waste, and with wolves scaring away other predators, not spontaneous cooperation.)
I don't think it makes sense as a way of thinking about things. And I certainly won't stop commenting because some people find it disagreeable/distracting.
The article doesn't mention anything like a prey drive, and seems to assume fetching is just a way of playfully interacting with humans. Seems like an oversight.
So a ball or stick flying/rolling across the ground mostly immitates a small prey animal.
I believe that is what our training is nurturing.
I have a jack russel and she is genetically predisposed to hunting after small things.
I wouldn't be surprised if wolves that brought back food/bones thrown by humans were then given more food, making those wolves a bit better off, fostering that trait.
Maybe bringing the bones back was a way of "nicely" letting humans know that more bones would be appreciated/required to keep living.
You often see wolves circle around humans around a fire in movies and books.
Maybe it's a symbiotic relationship like a remora/shark, or even parasitic like an oxpicker/large mammal.
*edit - Some people are very liberal with downvotes, especially for lighthearted conjecture that is not obviously wrong or intellectually misleading. Got any better ideas?