Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by jbrennan on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:20PM
(#2214798)
"LATEST BUZZ
Of all the different bug trackers out there, this is definitely one of them."
Is that actually saying anything substantial? Maybe it's in jest, in which case I do find it humourous, but if not, it's not necessarily a compliment, is it?
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by rst on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:57PM
(#2214914)
Not humorous? I laughed out loud.
This is obviously work in progress, and presented as such. It's expected that some things will be dummied up, for all the usual reasons: the design is part of what's under evaluation, and text of some kind is better for that than a hole in the page. An actual launch with testimonials like these would be a mistake, but they're not going to do that.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by tlianza on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:35PM
(#2214840)
I got the joke immediately and thought it was funny. Reminded me of a comedic movie (who's name escapes me) who advertised the review "If you like movies like this, you'll love this movie."
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by jollyjerry on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:31PM
(#2214824)
This looks really slick. avk and I were were planning on building bug tracking features into Outspokes, but we've stopped work on that project. Our original goal was to have a JS widget for teams to collaborate on their sites. Hopefully you guys keep it up and build out what we didn't finish. Let me know if you guys want any feedback or any help.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mmilo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:38PM
(#2214851)
Yeah that's exactly what this is. We have a JS widget that let's you log and manage bugs right from your site so can do things like tagging and annotating dom nodes.
Also feedback is DEFINITELY appreciated, we'd love to hear anything you can throw our way. Also let me know if you want a beta account and I can email you a link.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by ctrager on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:59PM
(#2214920)
Since your tracker is oriented towards web development, you might want to take a look at my work here, a Firefox addon for taking screen captures of a web page, marking it up with arrows, highlights, and then posting them to the the bug tracker.
It was the first time I played with the firefox addon technology. I wouldn't recommend my technical approach, injecting a div into the page. If I were inspired to redo it, I would do something more XUL-ish. But I do think that making it fast and easy to capture/annotate/post screenshots is key to making it something people want to use.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mmilo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:21PM
(#2214966)
Yeah we really badly wanted to move away from using screenshots as a means of capturing bug data for a few different reasons (different browser renderings, needing to constantly capture new screens when layouts change, etc...)
Also we wanted to ensure that there were no dependencies on a particular browser or operating system so we decided the best route for us would be an embeddable widget.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mrphoebs on Sunday February 13, 2011 @09:54PM
(#2215037)
It's great, simple, elegant and gets the job done. The only issue I had was the missing pricing coupled with the 30 day trial thing. I think it would be great if you could mention somewhere that priced plans are coming soon.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mmilo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:39PM
(#2214855)
Well there's no client as such. Currently it's embedded into the site you're working on so there's no browser or OS requirements, you simply log and manage bugs right from within your site.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by justinxreese on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:32PM
(#2214829)
I love how this works. But I'm worried about most bugs not being trackable by which div they're in. This would work if you're developing flat files for a customer that had access to this tool. But I think most bugs arise from heavy use of a system by the end user.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by toast76 on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:42PM
(#2214863)
There is also a method for logging non-gui bugs. It's not visible in this release though. As a developer myself it is useful to not have to click, especially for db related issues.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by flyingyeti on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:44PM
(#2214868)
I understand that pricing is difficult to determine, but I think you'd have a lot more conversions/signups if you:
(a) had an idea what the monthly cost was going to be,
(b) advertise that beta users will get a special discount on the product, and/or
(c) didn't emphasize the fact that the trial is only 30 days.
I was going to sign up, but the wording you used made me think twice, look for a pricing page, and eventually decide it wasn't worth my time to start using until I knew the price.
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mmilo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:51PM
(#2214893)
Yeah at this stage we're not charging anything for it at all. Everyone that's in the beta is using it for free, mainly because it's an actual beta with bugs to iron out, and not pretend beta so we can jack up the prices later.
Once we do have pricing figured out we do intend on ensuring all the beta testers get a special deal (though we're doing a pretty crap job of explaining all that)
Awesome feedback though, we'll be adding additional info regarding the beta deal to the site today :)
Re:Show HN: Bug tracker I'm building for web devs & designers
by mmilo on Sunday February 13, 2011 @08:53PM
(#2214899)
We have done freemium route before and it's worked out great for us when freemium users contribute back in some way, rather than just being a demo account.
For this we're thinking letting people use it for 30 days free of charge, if it's worth their time and money awesome, if not there's no obligation to pay.
Is that actually saying anything substantial? Maybe it's in jest, in which case I do find it humourous, but if not, it's not necessarily a compliment, is it?
There's a few little random geek references I've thrown in on different pages just for fun :)
On a more helpful note: where are the screenshots?
This is obviously work in progress, and presented as such. It's expected that some things will be dummied up, for all the usual reasons: the design is part of what's under evaluation, and text of some kind is better for that than a hole in the page. An actual launch with testimonials like these would be a mistake, but they're not going to do that.
As for the screenshots: I much prefer them on the homepage instead of a video. Video takes time, screenshots don't. :)
Also feedback is DEFINITELY appreciated, we'd love to hear anything you can throw our way. Also let me know if you want a beta account and I can email you a link.
This is the addon, http://ifdefined.com/BugTracker.NET.xpi
And it works with BugTracker.NET http://ifdefined.com/bugtrackernet.html
It was the first time I played with the firefox addon technology. I wouldn't recommend my technical approach, injecting a div into the page. If I were inspired to redo it, I would do something more XUL-ish. But I do think that making it fast and easy to capture/annotate/post screenshots is key to making it something people want to use.
Also we wanted to ensure that there were no dependencies on a particular browser or operating system so we decided the best route for us would be an embeddable widget.
How many developers do you have working in it? Do you have a dedicated designer or did you design it yourself?
You can also blame me for the spelling mistakes :)
I've watched the intro video and you now have my interest, looks awesome :)
(a) had an idea what the monthly cost was going to be,
(b) advertise that beta users will get a special discount on the product, and/or
(c) didn't emphasize the fact that the trial is only 30 days.
I was going to sign up, but the wording you used made me think twice, look for a pricing page, and eventually decide it wasn't worth my time to start using until I knew the price.
Once we do have pricing figured out we do intend on ensuring all the beta testers get a special deal (though we're doing a pretty crap job of explaining all that)
Awesome feedback though, we'll be adding additional info regarding the beta deal to the site today :)
For this we're thinking letting people use it for 30 days free of charge, if it's worth their time and money awesome, if not there's no obligation to pay.