News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by Waterluvian on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:04AM (#22146808)
Don't we have that in the model that describes what the parts of the brain do?

Proven to be wrong when you watch people with serious brain injuries re learn skills, but shown to have value by how it can predict what tumors or injuries will do to someone's ability.

Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by conistonwater on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:32AM (#22146972)
Those models and explanations are not nearly as helpful as one might think. A lot of "neuroscience" explanations of everyday behaviour are mostly nonsense that sounds plausible and appealing (https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3817, https://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/jocn_a_0075...). In this context plausible doesn't even mean plausible to a neuroscientist, it means more like consistent with the nonsense a layperson has heard before.

What would be really helpful is a model that can add to things we already know. Saying "studying for an exam engages the X part of the brain and uses the Y neurotransmitter" adds literally nothing to your understanding of studying (you can find out much more about studying by talking to people that are good at it and who have done a lot of studying themselves), it's just taking an everyday activity and identifying the small but still vastly complex portion of the brain that is activated more than others. Imagine being told that a particular bug in a 1-billion-lines-of-code codebase is due to some code within a 10-million-lines-of-code portion of it: that's great but how helpful is it really?

Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by JackFr on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:42AM (#22147049)
In general I'm very skeptical of much neuroscience. (If an article ever says 'emerging neuroscience shows...' you can be assured what follows is almost certainly BS.) Yet I found the senior researcher in this article quite refreshing about the limitations of their research.
Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by dr_dshiv on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:14AM (#22146867)
I would argue not since it doesn't do much for explaining how it works. We know how computers process information. We don't really have a good story for how the brain does it.

We need a story that explains how the brain uses rhythms (oscillations) for computation.

Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by numpad0 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:23AM (#22146916)
We know how to wire FETs, we know this is an i5 and is fast, we also know how to solder thick wires or how to loosen large screws, but no one knows how to build even a Z80 out of some germanium is how neuroscience is understood in my understanding
Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by jagger27 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:09AM (#22146841)
I would equate our current understanding of the brain to the common knowledge that apples fall to the ground from trees; where else would they go? People knew that long before Newton.
Re:An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience by im3w1l on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:46AM (#22147080)
Almost 2000 years before Newton, Archimedes wrote "Any object, totally or partially immersed in a fluid or liquid, is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the fluid displaced by the object."

The ancients knew a fair bit.