News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by blackrock on Saturday January 25, 2020 @04:22AM (#22145530)
Can you also tell Google to fix the image search page? The new design is stupid. I prefer the previous design.

The new design splits the page vertically, when you click on a picture. And its purpose, which is quite confusing, is to follow a second track of searches related to that picture.

But that just makes the usage confusing. I want to click on the picture in order to see it in magnification mode, to have it fill the browser window. This was the prior design. It worked perfectly, and allowed me to quickly see the picture I want, in a magnified mode.

But instead, with the new design, it opens the picture on the 2nd split screen, but the picture is practically the same size.

And to make matters worse, some of the pictures, like if they are portrait mode, does not magnify, so it makes it very difficult to see the details of the picture. I’d have to open up the source picture in another tab.

Someone must’ve thought this was a good idea, but to be honest, it sucks.

And also, the split screens with dual scrolling behaviors, is incredibly frustrating to use. Half the time, I’m scrolling on the wrong half of the page.

The image search is now such a frustrating experience, that I try to use other search engines for a better experience.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by harshitaneja on Saturday January 25, 2020 @04:54AM (#22145623)
Google was sued by Getty and had to make the change. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/02/internet-rages-after...
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by capableweb on Saturday January 25, 2020 @05:17AM (#22145681)
The only thing they would have to change to make Getty happy is that when you click on the image, it takes you to the place where the image was used, instead of the direct url of the image.

All the rest of the design choices was Google's, and we rightly blame them for purposefully degrading the experience of using Google Image search.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by spiderfarmer on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:09AM (#22145810)
As website owner I vote for this solution. Right now many people don’t even know you can visit the source website.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by Ygg2 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:31AM (#22145859)
As an image search user. The number of times I went to the site only to find it either doesn't have the picture or requires a login would just make me mad.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by tudorw on Saturday January 25, 2020 @12:10PM (#22147230)
Looking at you Pinterest! Their search results are irritation incarnate!
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by neop1x on Sunday January 26, 2020 @06:40AM (#22151610)
Getty should sue Pinterest! Their whole business is based on sharing 3rd-party pictures. And forcing you to register in order to browse. I don't understand how they still can continue doing business...
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by spiderfarmer on Sunday January 26, 2020 @07:04AM (#22151677)
Why is Image Search OK, but Pinterest not?
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by hanniabu on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:57AM (#22147155)
Yup, the amount of times I've clicked on the image up follow through to the site hasn't changed between either version either. This just makes things more of a hassle.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by spiderfarmer on Sunday January 26, 2020 @07:03AM (#22151672)
That’s something Google should improve then. I think the argument can be made that Google caches that image illegally, if the owner decided to remove it from its site.

And Google could also decide to block websites, like Pinterest, that are gaming their search algorithms. That would be beneficial for everyone.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by capableweb on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:28AM (#22145854)
I agree, feels more fair towards site owners than hotlinking the image, which been frowned upon on the internet since... At least I started using the internet.

What is not fine, is to use that as a reason to completely screw up the rest of the design, when a small change could have been enough.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by herf on Saturday January 25, 2020 @08:31AM (#22146153)
And, if only it didn't make a new tab every time.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by anonytrary on Saturday January 25, 2020 @05:22AM (#22145701)
I remember that, and I am a still a tiny bit salty about how it impacted me as a user. Ever since, it has been so unnecessarily tedious get the raw image link from Google. Half the time, I end up with a data url, sometimes I get taken to the backing website, who usually don't know anything about accessibility, sometimes I get the image. It's all just so much worse now.

That said, it is absolutely theft for Google to source data from your site, then use that to add value to their site, without giving you any click-through traffic.

Tangentially, it would be great if Google sent like $1 (edit: or < $1; the amount isn't my point) per 1000 clicks out to websites whose search results get clicked. They already have an ad-engine that does all of this. This would mean that you would get paid to have good SEO, or to be a central hub. The websites that comprise the entire web should negotiate better terms with central data brokers like Google.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by labawi on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:53AM (#22145906)
> That said, it is absolutely theft for Google to source data from your site, then use that to add value to their site, without giving you any click-through traffic.

Would you be OK, if Google didn't show images from your site on their site? If so, I believe a simple robots.txt statement should be sufficient.

> This would mean that you would get paid to have good SEO, or to be a central hub. The websites that comprise the entire web should negotiate better terms with central data brokers like Google.

I don't really get the logic by which someone letting people find you, should pay for that privilege.

(have not used Google search in a long time)

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by lyjackal on Saturday January 25, 2020 @09:14AM (#22146309)
> I don't really get the logic by which someone letting people find you, should pay for that privilege. Images ends up being more of a media platform than search engine. I'm rarely looking for a site. Doesn't seem too weird that they could pay for some of the content
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by labawi on Saturday January 25, 2020 @01:17PM (#22147643)
I don't really understand. Are you saying Google is creating a media platform based on image search and they should somehow find a way to pay for the images in it?

If you want to use an image that is not free, you should go pay for it, no? You have a link for the site. You can even go visit the site as a courtesy for free images. Are you saying Google should be paying for the images?

If you want to be mad at someone, look at getty - they take² people's images and charge for them, even managing to file DMCA takedowns on the author[1]. As a consolation, at least they host the images themselves.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12180039

² Quick skim says they may merely let other people do the uploading of effectively stolen images.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by leereeves on Saturday January 25, 2020 @08:17AM (#22146117)
> Would you be OK, if Google didn't show images from your site on their site? If so, I believe a simple robots.txt statement should be sufficient.

Giving people a way to opt out doesn't absolve Google. They need to get permission to use the property of others, not default to using it unless told not to.

They're acting as if everything that isn't locked up, and doesn't have a note on it saying otherwise, is free for anyone to borrow.

> I don't really get the logic by which someone letting people find you, should pay for that privilege.

Google can let people find sites without copying the content of those sites.

In fact, when Google copies your content, people are less likely to go to your site, the very opposite of "letting people find you".

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by judge2020 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:06AM (#22146820)
Letting Google crawl your page and not telling it to stop via robots.txt is implied consent, and a german court case confirmed this[0].

0: https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/german-federal-court-rules...

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by leereeves on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:51AM (#22147109)
That's not what that article says. According to that article, that decision was based on the idea that a hyperlink cannot infringe copyright, not on implied consent:

> The court in Karlsruhe does not regard the display of the preview images as an act of making available a copyright work in the sense of the copyright law. ... Since the decision handed down in the “Svensson” case in 2014, it is common ground that, in principle, the use of a hyperlink is not a copyright-relevant act.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by judge2020 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @02:18PM (#22148031)
My bad - I was looking at a published book that referenced the case and wanted to link an article that was more easily available, but it was for the wrong case. My original comment is also uneditable now. The case I meant to reference is "Vorschaubilder I", see the press release[0]

> [translated] The plaintiff has made the content of its website accessible for search engines without making use of technical means to exclude the images of her works from the search and display by image search engines in the form of preview images.

0: http://juris.bundesgerichtshof.de/cgi-bin/rechtsprechung/doc...

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by stiray on Saturday January 25, 2020 @01:43PM (#22147820)
Offtopic:

I am using entry page that brute forces password for accessing other pages. It takes a 30 seconds max on phone, but will raise cpu to 100%. Later it is stored to cookie. I havent seen any crawler get past that.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by spiderfarmer on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:07AM (#22145805)
I have a website with over 1.000.000 pictures. I’m still a bit salty that my images get 1M monthly impressions in image search and just 15k visitors.

If I made a website like Image Search, hotlinked all the images and burried a visit website button somewhere as a ‘curtesy’, I’d be sued out of existence within a couple of weeks.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by hanniabu on Saturday January 25, 2020 @12:00PM (#22147174)
Do you think you'd get more than 15k visitors if the image wasn't on google images as all?
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by spiderfarmer on Sunday January 26, 2020 @06:58AM (#22151660)
No. But that’s a strawman argument. Their conduct is not suddenly OK if they’re tossing some visitors my way.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by dvdkon on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:00AM (#22145790)
$1 per 1000 clicks is ridiculous. Google make a lot of money, but that's because of their scale, not because they have somehow made search a miracle source of income. Would you also argue that, say, indexes of literature or libraries should pay the authors money per item viewed, because the data isn't "theirs"?

Paying websites with good SEO would make filtering out abusers of search engines (no meaningful content, scraping other websites and republishing, clickbait...) even harder, as there would now be a direct ROI on SEO.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by DailyHN on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:46AM (#22145889)
> Would you also argue that, say, indexes of literature or libraries should pay the authors money per item viewed, because the data isn't "theirs"?

At least someone has to pay for the book to be in a library.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by dvdkon on Saturday January 25, 2020 @09:52AM (#22146453)
Yes, because the author didn't make its contents available for free. Websites can do the same, and many do. They could even disallow other sites from crawling them and processing their contents through the (mostly) respected robots.txt. But publishing something for free, not forbidding crawling through well-understood mechanisms, and then demanding payment is ridiculous.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by Marsymars on Sunday January 26, 2020 @01:32PM (#22153727)
Libraries do have to get special non-consumer licenses for electronic books. Typically they pay several times more than a the retail ebook cost for a library license that lasts the lesser of two years or ~50 views before expiry.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by bobcostas55 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:26AM (#22145849)
There are browser extensions that add a link to the original image.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by fulldecent2 on Saturday January 25, 2020 @09:57AM (#22146470)
You think that's bad, see AMP
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by notyourday on Saturday January 25, 2020 @08:05AM (#22146077)
I'm not a fan of Google but the solution to the Getty problem for Google is to drop all links to Getty domains from the index. Getty is a relic of the past power that still has not adapted to the Internet.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by natch on Saturday January 25, 2020 @09:33AM (#22146383)
Just remove Getty or maybe all stock images from the index. There are too many watermarked images in search results anyway. These images could still be made searchable through some other dedicated search with a conforming UI for users who really want a cross-vendor stock images search.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by bufferoverflow on Saturday January 25, 2020 @04:47AM (#22145592)
What's much worse is they removed the precise and custom image size search. It's now impossible to search for a 32x32 icon or a 3200x1800 wallpaper. This dumbing down and feature removal is sad and silly.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by joedamore on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:16AM (#22145956)
I was also really frustrated when they removed the exact size filter under search tools.

You can add "imagesize:32x32" to your search query to only show images of a desired size, but I'd still rather see Google bring back the search tool option.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by DamnInteresting on Saturday January 25, 2020 @01:12PM (#22147614)
FYI you can still access these options (and more) with the Google Advanced Image Search: https://www.google.com/advanced_image_search

edit: Oh, it no longer has "custom" under the sizes. Hmm.

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by anonytrary on Saturday January 25, 2020 @05:24AM (#22145709)
I didn't notice that. I never used exact dimension searches because more often than not, they eliminate all of the interesting results which I would have been able to crop/resize to my desired dimensions manually. It's better to have some results you can transform than to have no results.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by bufferoverflow on Saturday January 25, 2020 @05:29AM (#22145724)
They also had very useful "larger than 4MP", "larger than 8MP", ... options. It was easy to find very high resolution images.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by anonytrary on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:18AM (#22145838)
Ah, yes, now I do remember those more useful options. I definitely recall using them once or twice. I can't say I missed it though (seeing as I clearly forgot about it). I guess someone who needs to do it on a daily basis would miss it more.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by papito on Saturday January 25, 2020 @08:31AM (#22146149)
Man, the old Internet was great, wasn't it.... Now we get no proper advanced image search, and a bunch of paid Russian trolls. Good trade.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by derda on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:35AM (#22146005)
There is a chrome extension that brings back the "view original image" fucntionality.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/view-image/jpcmhce...

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by hudvin on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:06AM (#22145935)
Small self-promotions: We are working on image search engine - https://khumbu.im, demo (MVP stage)https://app.khumbu.im/search/5dff72e66483e25b40e0222e . We use DL to understand content of images and provide better search results. Soon we are going to add face recognition, improve object detection and semantic analysis.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by simias on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:59AM (#22146054)
I feel your pain, I mostly use duckduckgo these days so I'm not exposed to this behaviour too often but sometimes I don't find what I'm looking for and check Google instead. It's really frustrating.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by buboard on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:57AM (#22145919)
yandex image search is way better anyway
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by buboard on Saturday January 25, 2020 @06:55AM (#22145915)
for every such blunder that a major company does, i want to know what promotion/bonus someone "earned". For example this recent redesign of paypal: https://i.imgur.com/T7Rj3Tq.png
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by chrisoverzero on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:22AM (#22145969)
Is this a joke? It’s not a redesign. You must be ad-blocking or otherwise failing to load the stylesheet.
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by cpcallen on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:11AM (#22145945)
Looks like the stylesheet failed to load. (On a lot of websites these days I actually find that improves user experience!)
Re:Google backtracks on search results design by buboard on Saturday January 25, 2020 @07:19AM (#22145962)
i have turned off blockers. every profile page is like that, and it says on the page that they ve "updated your settings and profile experience. let us know what you think". kind of agree with you about ux though

its probably a blunder that they ll fix soon, but one would expect much better from billion dollar companies

Re:Google backtracks on search results design by GhettoMaestro on Saturday January 25, 2020 @11:55AM (#22147137)
This issue is isolated to you. I use PayPal multiple times per day. It is working fine right now.