News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by bcardarella on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:34AM (#22138599)
If we're going to limit project names in that way we might as well randomly choose letters
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by busterarm on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:06PM (#22140153)
asdf-vm is the best-named project ever.
[dead]
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by loceng on Friday January 24, 2020 @10:34AM (#22139103)
Not really. It's called branding and because's limited words that naturally have meaning - and the best words are likely to be coopted for projects in similar fields - then it's not difficult for people to search "lumen elixir". Likewise if the site you're on is contextual to Elixir then just searching "lumen" will find the result you're looking for.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by kerkeslager on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:11AM (#22139467)
> It's called branding and because's limited words that naturally have meaning - and the best words are likely to be coopted for projects in similar fields

"best" based on what criteria? Searchability is certainly a factor, no? Branding is pretty useless if people can't find your product.

> then it's not difficult for people to search "lumen elixir". Likewise if the site you're on is contextual to Elixir then just searching "lumen" will find the result you're looking for.

Right... until someone else creates another Elixir project called Lumen.

I think at some point you have to agree that naming collisions are a problem. The question isn't whether naming collisions are a problem, it's how far we want to subdivide fields before we consider collision to be a problem.

I'd argue that you're drastically underestimating this effect: having to type "Elixir" is definitely going to prevent some people from finding this project. For example, if I'm working with Elixir, and I need to do some frontend work, and someone on the internet suggests Lumen: I'll search "lumen", find the PHP framework, and probably guess that the person on the internet didn't really understand what I was trying to do, which is not an unreasonable guess given the widely-varying quality of answers from randos on the internet. Sure, I could search "lumen elixir", but how would I know to do that if I didn't already know what it was?

Contrast this with other ways of measuring the value of a name. Lumen is a word related to BEAM? Why is that important? Sounds cool? Again, why is that important? Pronounceable/memorable? Okay, but actually there are thousands of words that are unused, that are both those things.

You can't trot out "it's called branding" as if that proves any of these things are important: highly successful brands like "Prozac" or "Kleenex" or "Clorox" show that even being a real word isn't important.

Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by loceng on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:32PM (#22140448)
"Right... until someone else creates another Elixir project called Lumen."

That's obviously a problem then - never argued it isn't ever a problem, your argument is a straw man whether you realize it or not.

Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by kerkeslager on Friday January 24, 2020 @02:50PM (#22141809)
Nope, I'm not accusing you of saying that isn't a problem. I'm merely demonstrating that a problem starts at some number of keywords. I understand that your argument is that the problem starts at two keywords (in this case) not one. Correct?

Would you care to respond to why you think users will know to type "exixir" when they search for "lumen", or why you think that "lumen" is a good marketing term? All you've done is misuderstood one small part of what I said: you haven't actually responded to the other 3/4 of what I said.

Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by loceng on Friday January 24, 2020 @04:10PM (#22142490)
Why is "Apple" a good brand name? A brand is what you make of it.

It makes no sense for users to hear about "Elixir Lumen" from outside the Elixir crowd - so if they search for "lumen" and don't see the result, if they're paying attention and have minimal competency using search engines, then they'd type in "lumen elixir" to find correct result.

Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by praveenperera on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:44AM (#22139869)
That’s a gigantic leap
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by kerkeslager on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:58AM (#22140058)
Making one obvious mistake is correlated with making other obvious mistakes.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by lawik on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:30AM (#22138551)
Haha! Oh dear.. I think adding "elixir" to any search is pretty much mandatory. Phoenix, Nerves, Scenic. All need some qualifiers. Ecto might stand on its own.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by dqv on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:37AM (#22138625)
Not sure who came up with it first, but there's also Laravel Elixir and Laravel Mix which caused some confusion for me when I first heard about Elixir but didn't know it was in the Erlang ecosystem.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by bitwalker on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:46AM (#22138698)
There is also a Python library called Elixir - naming is hard.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by conradfr on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:59AM (#22138795)
And a cryptocurrency, which makes for some fun questions sometimes on the elixir (lang) subreddit.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by mpolsz on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:01AM (#22139356)
And in Poland there is interbank money transfer system called elixir so good luck finding job with elixir (lang) in description.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by dasil003 on Friday January 24, 2020 @10:02AM (#22138822)
Better than Go!
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by rhlsthrm on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:03AM (#22139387)
Golang
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by dasil003 on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:23PM (#22140346)
Yes, I'm familiar with the hack that the community is expected to use every time they name the language in a searchable context. No better than prepending Elixir on a search if you ask me.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by fxleach on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:51AM (#22138737)
Yup. I've used Lumen a couple times over the past few years. Not sure why you would start a new project with that name, it's already well known and easily searchable.
Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by prophesi on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:21AM (#22139584)
Not sure why the OP's message was flagged, as it was a totally valid criticism...

But yeah, I just started a Lumen project last night for a quick API behind OAuth2. I sometimes have to append "php" or "laravel" to my queries, but that's to be expected considering I don't use Google.

I'm a big fan of Elixir and think Lumen's Elixir -> WebAssembly will be awesome, but I do wish they used another magic potion related name for it.

Re:Lumen – Elixir and Erlang in the Browser by dang on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:23PM (#22140357)
There have been many Lumens. Scott's and my hashmap-based Lisp was called that years earlier (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17962433). When I contacted the dev of a previous project to ask if he minded us using the name, he replied that there were so many that it didn't matter.

Lumens come and go.