News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by pferde on Friday January 24, 2020 @07:09AM (#22137367)
From TFA: "“This idea is laboratory testable in principle,” said Vopson. He suggests taking mass measurements of a digital data storage device when it has full memory. If it has more mass than when the device’s memory is cleared, then that would show the mass-energy-information equivalence is correct."

While the idea is interesting, the actual proposed experiment is laughable. It's like suggesting that a mechanical light switch should have different weight when switched on or off.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by ravenstine on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:51AM (#22138194)
It seems like a modern version of the early 20th century experiment to weigh the human soul.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_grams_experiment

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by mrfusion on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:03AM (#22138308)
Well if the brain holds a huge amount of information this could actually explain those experiments. weird to think about.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by dTal on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:24AM (#22138495)
Even funnier, the information lost when a human dies really is their soul!

The real question is, how many bits is a human soul?

(To be clear - this is definitely not the explanation for those experimental results. But it's fun to kid around!!)

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by Anon84 on Friday January 24, 2020 @07:20AM (#22137427)
> a mechanical light switch should have different weight when switched on or off.

Well, in principle it should have a different weight to account for the extra electrons moving around when it’s turned on. Every time you have a change in charge you have a corresponding mas change.

My problem with this idea is the fact that not all information is electronic in nature, in which case you would be arguing that the weight of a completed puzzle is different than the total weight of the individual pieces, for example.

In general, this would imply that changes in entropy would correspond to changes in mass...

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by bognition on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:15AM (#22137841)
It's more complicated than that. A single light switch stores exactly 1 bit of information. Its either on or off and both positions convey the exact same amount of information.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by _carl_jung on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:54AM (#22138227)
This raises what I view to be a falsification by counter-example of the original premise. If information (and not _the representation of_ information) has mass, then does a piece of uncompressed information weight the same amount as the compressed information?

Furthermore, information is related to interpretation. A string of bits may be an uncompressed text file, a set of numbers, a compressed image, etc. But it's always the same amount of bits. How can my interpretation of that set of bits affect its mass?

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by krastanov on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:13AM (#22138388)
There are measures that do not depend on interpretation. Entropy of the content for instance. This is what people usually refer to in this context and the ideas of the article have actually been known to physicists for decades.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by _carl_jung on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:20AM (#22138454)
I'm out of my depth here as I've never studied information theory. I suppose there's a larger gap between the theory and the practical aspect of the title of this article than I first imagined!
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by krastanov on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:22AM (#22138475)
Yeah, our everyday technology is maaaany orders of magnitude away from where this would be detectable. However, it is still important topic if we want to design extreme efficiency computing hardware (and already studied among researchers that want to make nanotech).
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by kijin on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:15AM (#22138407)
If the mass of information is strictly proportional to how many bits of entropy it contains, it follows that neither interpretation nor (lossless) compression can alter its mass.

There's quite a bit of difference between how we usually think about information and how information theory treats it. There it's all about entropy.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by _carl_jung on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:21AM (#22138464)
Doesn't the very definition of "lossless" depend on interpretation? If lossy compression alters its mass, but lossless doesn't, doesn't it depend on the interpretation of "lost" information?

As I said to the above poster I don't know much about this, so hope this isn't an off-base question.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by kijin on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:58AM (#22140054)
Lossless compression preserves entropy. Lossy doesn't.

The meaning of a certain sequence of bits depends on interpretation, of course. But nobody is talking about meaning here, only entropy. For our purpose it wouldn't matter if there were no sentient beings in the universe to attribute any meaning to anything.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by ryandvm on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:47AM (#22138153)
Same as an SSD. Regardless of whether you saved anything on it the individual bits are either set or unset. It always has information on it, it just might not be _your_ information.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by pferde on Friday January 24, 2020 @07:26AM (#22137459)
Yes, you summarized what I feel is wrong with the experiment perhaps even better than me. They are trying to weigh not the information itself, but medium used to convey the information.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by davedx on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:15AM (#22137845)
It that true, though? Does an electronic storage device with full storage have more electrons in it? I don't know enough about how modern memory works to say for sure.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by blattimwind on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:42AM (#22138094)
Electrons are used as the information storage mechanism in flash memory, but the data is whitened (50 % one bits on average independent of the data input) before being stored. Hence, "the number of electrons" would not vary between an SSD storing only zeroes, and one only storing ones.

But in any case, you would be measuring the mass of electrons and not the information they represent. This theory suggests that a storage device would have additional mass dependent on information content, so things like whitening / encryption would not matter.

However, here is a question that immediately occurs: If I have a message with "informational mass" x, and encrypt it, does the encrypted message has the same informational mass, or is the mass of the encrypted message the same as a random message of the same length?

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by consp on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:22AM (#22138470)
Since flash is based on a charge pump, doesn't it just move the electrons from the substrate or control gate to the floating gate? Or am I missing something here?

In that case you do not have to account for the electron mass at all.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by mpoloton on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:00AM (#22138272)
Electron rest mass is about 1E-31 Kg which is orders of magnitude more than the proposed estimated bit mass of 1E-38 Kg.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by pferde on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:32AM (#22138009)
That's not really the point. The point is, they would be measuring the weight of the electrons, in other words, the implementation-specific medium used to store the information. Not the information itself.

I can see this discussion go very far into metaphysical. :)

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by mathw on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:57AM (#22138248)
Well, what is information? Is it an abstract thing, or does it only exist in terms of the thing which is representing it?

I don't have a clue, I just think it's a relevant question at this point.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by undecisive on Friday January 24, 2020 @10:46AM (#22139214)
Surely not though - we're talking about information.

You don't need electricity flowing for the light switch to store information. In fact, the light switch could have no spring in it, allowing it to be in an infinity of different states.

So let's imagine a board with two such light switches. I set one to 0.9998128376666.. and the other to 0.26757328888... - out of the infinite number of possibilities, how do we quantify the information that I've just stored in these light switches, to determine how much their weight should have changed?

It's a silly question. It's a bit like saying "If a tree falls in the forest, do birds contain sodium?" Of course the two halves of the question are related tangentially, but putting them together like this is totally meaningless. Oooh... and nests are a thing, so, is it trees falling in the forest that causes nests? (dark matter)

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by m463 on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:21PM (#22144003)
Sort of reminds me of the question, "does a battery weigh the same when charged as when discharged?"

(on the other hand, I remember lead-acid car batteries are more prone to freezing when discharged)

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by radarsat1 on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:23AM (#22137906)
Weigh an SSD before and after storing data on it? That's so easy to do I have no idea why such an article would leave it as a theoretical.

edit: since I have been downvoted, perhaps someone would like to clarify how my description differs from, "taking mass measurements of a digital data storage device when it has full memory. If it has more mass than when the device’s memory is cleared, then that would show the mass-energy-information equivalence is correct."

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by Deukhoofd on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:54AM (#22138228)
> Unfortunately, taking the extremely small measurement needed to such precision may currently be unachievable. Vopson proposes the next step to getting answers could be developing a sensitive interferometer similar to LIGO or an ultra-sensitive Kibble balance.

The article explains why it's not testable.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by Brave-Steak on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:18AM (#22138437)
Or you could just store a crazy amount of information on one medium that's big enough. Can somebody calculate how much it would need to be before it's measurable with modern instruments?
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by Sean1708 on Friday January 24, 2020 @10:44AM (#22139193)
From the paper:

> For 1Tb device the estimated mass change is 2.5 × 10^-25 Kg.

I don't actually know how precise we're currently able to measure mass, though.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by trentlott on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:03PM (#22144580)
A proton weighs ~10^-27 kg, so that's about 100 protons. I sincerely doubt we have masses that are quite that good - especially that which can take a high mass item (harddrive) and detect an atomic-scale change without being hideously noisy
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by csunbird on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:20AM (#22138451)
it does not work that way because a SSD stores the information by capturing and binding electrons. Presence of an electron in the flip-flop (electric charge) is evaluated as 1 and non-existence of an electron is evaluated as zero.

A full SSD will be actually heavier :) but when you think about it the information amount is the same, a SSD with full zeroes and another one full with files have same amount of information equal to capacity of the SSD. Whether it is meaningful information or not is another discussion.

Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by pferde on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:54AM (#22138220)
The last paragraph of TFA explains why it is left theoretical. In short, lack of measuring accuracy.
Re:Testable theory suggests information has mass by jerf on Friday January 24, 2020 @09:32AM (#22138574)
"He suggests taking mass measurements of a digital data storage device when it has full memory."

I hope this is just fuzzification from the usual science journalism process, but I worry there may be some equivocation (in the logical sense) there. What the universe considers "information" and what we consider "information" do not have to be the same thing. They will certainly be related, and as human!information approaches universe!information density, they'd converge, but up here in the macroscopic world there's a lot of daylight between the two.

Consider a simplified cell we use to store a bit, which can either have electrons piled up on one side for a 0, or equally piled up on an equal side for a 1. We humans might consider a drive full of random numbers to be full of information while a drive full of zeros is highly, highly compressible and thus nearly empty of information, but from the universe's point of view, we have exactly the same amount of excess "information" about which electrons are confined where no matter what we humanly store on this drive. That "information" would also constitute far more universe!bits than we could ever dream of storing human!bits on the same drive, while at the same time, not even remotely approaching the level we could hope to measure as mass.

Human!information is a lower bound on universe!information, and not a particularly good one, either.

It seems to me we have a decent grasp on what may constitute a "qubit" and how that may be information, but I've not seen a very solid discussion of what the universe may consider "information" in the arrangement of those qubits. I phrase it as "I've not seen" on purpose, since I'm not in the field. I do know I've seen very far-out speculation like the possibility gravity is somehow related to mass blocking the information flow in the universe in an asymmetric way resulting in a force, but IIRC that still had no discussion on what the information may be, beyond a mere aggregation of qubits. It's obviously there, but we don't know what it is. (Now there's a sentence that makes it sound like dark matter....)

(Thinking about this simplified cell I gave above, my crazy thought would be, if "information" in the universe and "a configuration of mass-energy that maintains its state even though there's a field trying to push it out of the state" (such as the electrons staying in their trap even though they are electrostatically trying to push each other apart) were the same, then there would be a clean mechanism for "information" to "have mass", in the additional potential energies involved. A disorganized mass-energy system where everything is already at the lowest energy would have no information. But this is just crazy talk.)