News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by preommr on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:55PM (#22134255)
Wikipedia is the most incredible creation in modern times. Because it's not about some law of the universe that people have learned enough about to use to their advantage like electricity or nuclear physics. It's something inherent to us as a species that we came together to create a resource for everyone to access and that it has such a high level of quality. The culture around Wikipedia - the culmination of knowledge, the importance of said knowledge, the random curiosity of such a wide variety of topics and so much more, says so much about us as people.

If you had asked me half a century ago if something like this would ever work - I would've said absolutely not. And yet, there it is.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by Balgair on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:56PM (#22135504)
> It's something inherent to us as a species that we came together to create a resource for everyone to access and that it has such a high level of quality.

Oh man, if only it were true! If anything, wikipedia should be seen as an overcoming of our terrible human nature in making something good in the world, not as a property of humans. It is SO precious and fragile in our mortal hands.

The story of the Encyclopédie's origins is incredible and a great reminder that works like wikipedia are the exception, not the rule. The Philosophes worked very hard to get the volumes out and were under constant threat of censure. The very idea of the Encyclopédie was a direct threat to the Ancient Regime and it's publication was a direct cause (among many) of the French Revolution. A revolution whose effects we feel until this very day. The Encyclopédie was a lit cigarette in a powder cache. It's head editor, Diderot, is still a controversial person. If you can have haters and lovers nearly 250 years after you dance your last, well kiddo, you've done something right.

Even today wikipedia is vandalized by powerful interests and is routinely censored out of existence for many of the people of the world. Governments are still afraid of the free knowledge that wikipedia gives us. It is still a lit cigarette in a powder cache. But it is a fragile thing.

Cherish it: DONATE

https://donate.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Landi...

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by a-nikolaev on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:36AM (#22135895)
Recommending to donate is rather misleading.

Most of the work on Wikipedia is done by unpaid editors.

On the other hand, Wikimedia Foundation (the one that collects donations and manages the project) is accumulating donations and increasing spendings at ever-increasing rates, way above its maintenance and development needs. Just google a bit. Something like this: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/9qqds7Z3Ykd9Kdeay/... Their history of being wasteful and not transparent about their spending is rather long.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by phamilton on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:59AM (#22135759)
It's a great resource, but isn't it pretty well established that the foundation does not need more funding?

For anyone interested, take a read through https://foundation.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:FY17...

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by Razengan on Friday January 24, 2020 @02:36AM (#22136147)
> of our terrible human nature

The ability to learn and teach is the very core of human nature that sets us apart from other animals.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by 9dev on Friday January 24, 2020 @04:31AM (#22136680)
Does it set us apart, though? Crows, apes and dolphins have all been known to teach both their offspring and fellow animals.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by spdionis on Friday January 24, 2020 @05:22AM (#22136896)
We do it so much better that the quantitative difference becomes a qualitative difference.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by c3534l on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:07PM (#22134339)
I, like almost every person at the time, heard about wikipedia and scoffed at it. And, in the early days,the quality was atrocious and the scope seemingly insurmountable. But wikipedia almost ever gets better, not worse, and the limitation that the books have to sit on a shelf makes wikipedia far more than an encyclopedia. It has evolved, through time, to be something few people ever imagined it could be.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by Polylactic_acid on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:17PM (#22134401)
People tend to be super critical of wikipedia but I think it could have been a whole lot worse. We are incredibly lucky that wikipedia isn't owned by some tech megacorp, it isn't loaded with spyware JS bogging it down, and it doesn't require an account to use.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by O1111OOO on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:51PM (#22134630)
> We are incredibly lucky that wikipedia isn't owned by some tech megacorp, it isn't loaded with spyware JS bogging it down, and it doesn't require an account to use.

There was Google's attempt in 2007 wih knol(0) - which many called an attempt at a Wikipedia killer. Agreed... We dodged a bullet.

Authors could also choose to include ads from Google's AdSense on their pages ... All contributors to the Knol project had to sign in with a Google account ... authors were also able to choose the CC-BY-NC-3.0 license (which prohibits commercial reuse) or traditional copyright protection instead.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knol

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by Polylactic_acid on Thursday January 23, 2020 @09:16PM (#22134776)
I think the most fascinating thing is the bit about how people criticized google for placing knol results in more accessible spots on google search and the conflict of interest. This is exactly the same debate we are having over a decade later about AMP.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by 6510 on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:08AM (#22135795)
Their scheme is ranking by popular domain name. This, as a rule, makes shit content rise to the top. A debate about how bad this idea is shouldn't last long. That said, the question then becomes if google.com is worthy of this favoritism. It unquestionably qualifies here. So there is no-such-thing as placing knol in a more accessible spot. google.com is just a more popular website than wikipedia.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by brownbat on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:20PM (#22135107)
IMDb went through this, it was basically open and crowdsourced, then suddenly became much more commercial, which freaked out a lot of users.

And it's... fine. But it was really amazing in the beginning. Much less cruft, much more usable.

There was a lot of drama on the late 90s internet that now seems impossible to read about or search for.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by rapnie on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:51PM (#22135486)
On IMDb it is only the rating system that is totally gamed, very warped. I usually look at the distribution of the individual User Review ratings. If they are mostly 10's and 1's the movie is usually crap (a large chunk of Hollywood 'blockbusters' are here), even though the aggregate rating is an 8+. Fairer distributions with 6, 7's and 8's and this might be worth watching. There can be spoilers in the review titles, though.

One thing that is fun to do after watching a totally crap movie - to make up for 2 wasted hours of your life - is read the 1-rated reviews. There is usually some brilliant sarcastic analysis there to make you laugh out loud.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by thrwaway69 on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:15PM (#22135089)
> it isn't loaded with spyware JS bogging it down, and it doesn't require an account to use.

https://i.redd.it/y0oy7zsc72541.jpg

They were hijacking every link on mobile a while ago and messing with my browser so bad. Surely, there wasn't any "spyware js".

A small sticky donate button on bottom would have been better.

Wikipedia pages in general are fine because people constantly have to edit spammers out from them. They haven't done much to curb similar looking spam clearly distinct from content.

[Our super scale webhosting powers google services](superwebhosting.in) everywhere...I don't remember the times I had to remove it from the history of cloud providers, tech companies, web, https, etc.

Edit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:History/Google_data_...

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by baddox on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:16PM (#22135093)
Forget half a century ago! Even when I was in high school in 2005 (while I was getting a vastly better education from personal curiosity on Wikipedia than from public school) it was widely accepted that it would be ludicrous to believe anything in Wikipedia since anyone can edit it.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by StevePerkins on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:24PM (#22135129)
I remember an episode of "The Office" where Michael Scott states that Wikipedia is very accurate, "because anybody can edit it". And that was the joke. Michael Scott being naive and gullible enough to believe this ridiculous statement, while other characters made exasperated reaction shots for the camera.

A lot has changed since the mid-2000's. Wikipedia was so revolutionary at the time.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by spodek on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:16AM (#22135592)
I remember telling people in 2004 or so how it would take over and people thought I was crazy. There were something like 10,000 articles then. One coworker didn't believe anyone could edit it so he edited a page for the fun of it. A few hours later someone had reverted it, which led him to believe more in it.

As they say, Wikipedia doesn't work in theory, only in practice.

As longtime GNU/Linux user then, I viewed the GPL as the foundation to it. Encyclopedias seemed a niche where a GPL-based project could thrive, like in making an operating system or web server.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by anderspitman on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:16AM (#22135822)
> It's something inherent to us as a species that we came together to create a resource for everyone to access and that it has such a high level of quality

I like the explanation that Wikipedia is built on nerds' need to correct each other.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by gauravjain13 on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:02PM (#22135013)
Wikipedia is so incredible because it’s that sliver of intersection in a Venn diagram of what’s ideal and what’s real – a rare phenomenon.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by soheil on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:10PM (#22135332)
Please don't hate on my comment, all I can do is ask not to be downvoted, at least I tried. Here is my case against Wikipedia. In a capitalistic model it makes little sense why Wikipedia should thrive without enriching someone so massively in the process, therefore, it must be corrected. If we assume that line of thinking is valid (which I'm not saying we should or shouldn't) then it follows that an alternative Wikipedia riddled with ads would be a superior model, in terms of capitalism. It'd be much more similar to imdb perhaps, owned by Amazon. Wikipedia (in the film category) provides information in a much effective way and can stay on top of change by issuing revisions way better than imdb can ever do.

If we jump to the most logical conclusion of the set of assumptions made above I think it then follows that readily accessible knowledge cannot necessarily be a good thing, otherwise, the market would have rewarded that. But we see in the case of imdb market did not reward it enough for it to achieve the same pedigree as Wikipedia.

It's not good for people to learn facts that easily. There should be a higher cost associated with that. This is of course a ridiculous conclusion but I think it could make sense why it would be true. It is a whole other post for why it would be true but I will only give an example or two.

One example is if knowledge is that easily accessible then anyone could achieve it without necessarily having enough desire to achieve said knowledge, and since we have limited capacity for knowledge acquisition and retainment we are most likely sacrificing knowledge that we are truly passionate about.

Second example is maybe it isn't good for people to know so much anyway. After all there are many things that due to the laws of nature we are inherently incapable of ever knowing such as what is beyond knowable universe (nothing can travel faster than speed of light so we cannot learn about it since the knowledge or light from stuff beyond the knowable universe won't have enough time to ever reach us.)

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by xmprt on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:49AM (#22135728)
I don't think people are downvoting you for your opinion. The comment as it stands however is completely incomprehensible.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by soheil on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:07AM (#22135791)
Ha, I don't actually think people are downvoting me as much as I expected. Also you seem to be confusing cause and effect. The 1st sentence of my post was asking not to be downvoted, even if people did downvote later on I had no way of knowing that when I wrote that comment.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by bawolff on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:23AM (#22135621)
> In a capitalistic model it makes little sense why Wikipedia should thrive without enriching someone so massively in the process, therefore, it must be corrected

Err what? If a model of reality is incorrect you throw out the model, you dont try to modify reality to fit the model.

This is akin to saying something like: Solar panels* dont work in classical physics therefore coal is better.

* iana physicist. I assume they have something to do with quantum physics but dont really know

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by soheil on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:31AM (#22135650)
> you dont try to modify reality to fit the model

Well sometimes you do, McDonald's exists not because the food they provide is perfectly nutritious and what a human body needs to remedy hunger. I already concede that capitalism does distort reality.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by bawolff on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:43AM (#22135918)
This makes no sense.

I dont even know what you are trying to claim. Is one of your premises that capitalism predicts the highest quality product wins at the marketplace? Because that's not what capitalism is. If it was we would all be eating at 5 star resturants all the time as they have the highest quality product when you ignore price.

Are you trying to claim that part of the reason mcdonald's is succesful is because they have a lot of money to spend on advertising and inertia? If so you are misunderstanding my point (or its just a non sequitor). The fact that gaining a lot of capital allows you an (arguably unfair, especially relative to idealized capitalism) advantage in the market place has nothing to do with my criticism that you are fallaciously finding evidence that contradicts your simplified model and then concluding that reality is wrong instead of your model.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by asdfasgasdgasdg on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:16PM (#22135363)
You're glossing over that Wikipedia would not be feasible if you had to pay people to do it, and if it were not free, you'd have to pay people to do it. Your "capitalistic model" likely does not correspond sufficiently to reality to be useful. And why did you write this comment? There is no need for a "case against Wikipedia."
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by jacobwilliamroy on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:34AM (#22135665)
>why did you write this?

It looks like satire to me. If soheil is serious, I don't know what to say.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by soheil on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:20PM (#22135376)
I am saying that it would not be feasible, we're actually in agreement on that point.

> And why did you write this comment?

I feel like you want comments to always have a political motive.

> There is no need for a "case against Wikipedia."

It's an intellectual exercise.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by rapnie on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:25AM (#22135626)
I agree with asdfasgasdgasdg, and don't understand your reasoning.

Imho the fact that Wikipedia is not commercially marketized is inherent to its success. Feels like a breath of fresh air to have such a rich source of open access information, to search for e.g. medical info rather than trusting Google with it.

If anything, Wikipedia shows to me that people have a longing for more initiatives like that, and they will then reject commercial alternatives that exist.

Gives me glimmers of hope for the future.

Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by jacobwilliamroy on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:37AM (#22135686)
Did you copypaste that guy's name, or did you type the whole thing out? Did you have his comment out in a second window so you could look back and forth to check your spelling?
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by soheil on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:46AM (#22135715)
The real question is did you copy and paste and searched for it to see if it is actually the same username or did you just guess that they're the same spelling?
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by jacobwilliamroy on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:49AM (#22135730)
I opened two tabs and looked back and forth.
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by rapnie on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:43AM (#22135704)
I copypasted first, then started writing :)
Re:Wikipedia now has more than 6M articles in English by AYBABTME on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:55AM (#22135746)
You can only reach these sort of conclusions if you put capitalism on a stand, like a god from which everything true clearly must derive. Like an axiom. If that's what you believe, then so be it. But otherwise what you're saying seems to be nothing more than a random walk.