News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by chongli on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @09:43AM (#22117899)
I think democracy was always problematic. Its original form, direct democracy, was vulnerable to the tyranny of the masses.

Representative democracy, long described as the solution, really isn’t. Representatives are self-interested, just like everyone else, and so we cannot expect them to be purely faithful executors of their respective mandates.

What we did not expect, and perhaps are now beginning to, is that human beings are endlessly resourceful when personally motivated. Laws, norms, and institutions are static structures, simple obstacles for people to overcome when they really want to. It has always been far more difficult to build defences than it has been to build new weapons to overcome them. This is the great challenge for lawmakers, judiciary, law enforcement, and anyone who is interested in the preservation of a free and open society.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by 0xB31B1B on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:34AM (#22118982)
To be fair, this issue was much debated at the creation of democratic rule in Greece. Their solution to the problem of ambition and resource guarding is “sortition”, which is a lottery in which a large fraction of the democratic body is chosen by chance rather than by popular election, skill or ambition. This was meant to be a check on the development of the type of permanent ruling oligarchy we see developing in the US.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by samename on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @01:06PM (#22120186)
Is the sortition method effective at combating this problem?
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by chongli on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @01:46PM (#22120620)
I have heard about sortition and its supposed benefits but I have never read anything about it used in a real life context. However, perhaps something related to sortition is the concept of visibly random groups [1], which is being tested and used in classroom settings. The paper goes into a lot more detail, but the essential benefit is that the usual cliques and friend groups get disrupted and everyone feels way more comfortable working together with all of their classmates.

[1] http://www.peterliljedahl.com/wp-content/uploads/Visibly-Ran...

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by cameldrv on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:34PM (#22121143)
South Korea had a very interesting experiment last year. They randomly selected about 500 people to decide what to do about nuclear power in South Korea. They were drafted to spend several months learning about the pros and cons of nuclear power and then voted on what the country should do. This is an extremely interesting model to me.

https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/NP-South-Korean-president...

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by techslave on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @10:05AM (#22118096)
> Representative democracy, long described as the solution, really isn’t. Representatives are self-interested, just like everyone else, and so we cannot expect them to be purely faithful executors of their respective mandates.

That’s irrelevant isn’t it? You elect based on your own self-interest and expect your candidate to follow theirs. There isn’t a single “what’s best for society” anyway so the pull between competing ideas means the most popular ones win. With a tempering effect from the courts.

What we did not expect was political parties. These are in effect conjoining at least the legislative and executive branches.

Also the electoral college ruined things. Not for the trivial reason you may think but by eliminating runoff elections.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by SamBam on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22118808)
I think the parties part is the key, especially how it has infected the judicial branch as well.

Madison claimed that the defense against the tyranny of the majority was that

"...the society itself will be broken into so many parts, interests, and classes of citizens, that the rights of individuals, or of the minority, will be in little danger from interested combinations of the majority.

In a free government the security for civil rights [...] consists in the one case in the multiplicity of interests, and in the other in the multiplicity of sects. The degree of security in both cases will depend on the number of interests and sects."

It seems that parties, and particularly blind obedience to the head of the party (whether the president, the speaker, etc), has diminished the "number of interests and sects."

(Note, this is my understanding of Madison, but not as a scholar of US history.)

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by peterwwillis on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:37AM (#22119014)
> What we did not expect was political parties

The founding fathers did. They saw how political factions brought about the bloody English civil wars, and many feared they'd tear the new nation apart. But some people like Jefferson saw them as a part of human nature, a necessary evil.

As of our second president (1797) we had a two-party system. But by 1812, the Democratic-Republican party gained control of both Congress and the presidency, and effectively destroyed the Federalist party, giving us effectively one party control of government (the "Era of Good Feelings" in which nationalism flourished in the afterglow of the war of 1812). But in 1830 the new Democratic Party gained control, and we've had two since then.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by chongli on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:22AM (#22118862)
There isn’t a single “what’s best for society” anyway

A lot of people believe that though. They see democracy as the key to discovering this idea and bringing everyone on board with it. I’ve heard this position described as “mistake theory,” in contrast to conflict theory [1]. In other words, for some people the goal of government is to find the right balance of incentives and disincentives.

For others, government will always be a power struggle between mutually incompatible interests. Democracy makes little sense in such a situation.

[1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/24/conflict-vs-mistake/

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by jdkee on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @06:52PM (#22123345)
In the U.S. we can trace a lot of the damage back to Citizen's United v F.E.C.

See https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/08-205.ZS.html

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by DuskStar on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @08:22PM (#22123944)
The problem is that without Citizens United, all that kept the FEC from banning reporting on political candidates was that the law didn't extend there yet. Because what is a front-page article on a candidate if not an in-kind contribution? Why should the Wall Street Journal be allowed to run an article praising the most recent Republican candidate, if the Sierra Club can't publish a documentary condemning their policies?

People throw a lot of hate towards Citizens United. But the alternative was worse.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by jdkee on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @08:42PM (#22124047)
There are reasonable solutions to that problem such as extending the FCCs fairness doctrine to print media, etc.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by DuskStar on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @09:16PM (#22124215)
Which was also ruled unconstitutional. And probably still wouldn't fix the Sierra Club documentary issue.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by the8472 on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:05PM (#22120812)
> What we did not expect, and perhaps are now beginning to, is that human beings are endlessly resourceful when personally motivated. Laws, norms, and institutions are static structures, simple obstacles for people to overcome when they really want to.

I wonder whether the staffers of politicians engage in game theoretic modeling, have red teams etc. to try to anticipate these kinds of exploits.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by dehrmann on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:42AM (#22119072)
> tyranny of the masses

Seeing California's proposition process, I agree. It also shows how disfunctional representative democracy is.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by 0xB31B1B on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:49AM (#22119183)
Interestingly, the ballot prop exists in its current form today because in the early 1900s the southern pacific railroad basically controlled the entire state government. The ballot prop was used to solve the problem of capture of the government by a group of unaccountable elites.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by DuskStar on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @08:34PM (#22123999)
Which works until the 'unaccountable elites' decide that the proposition is unconstitutional. Like Prop 187 [0], a (successful, at ~60% in favor) 1994 proposal to limit services provided by the state to legal residents only. (Agree or disagree with the proposal, "no your constitutional amendment is unconstitutional" leaves a bad taste in my mouth. And yes, this was federal court, but the incoming California governor aborted the appeal)

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1994_California_Proposition_18...

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by greglindahl on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:24PM (#22121040)
While the California proposition process has had some terrible outcomes, it has also been a way for the people to force the legislature to do popular things that career politicians hesitate to do, like prison reform and legalizing weed.

And that's a good thing.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by coldtea on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:10AM (#22118742)
>I think democracy was always problematic. Its original form, direct democracy, was vulnerable to the tyranny of the masses.

Who deemed that a problem? The elites wanting specific decisions out of the masses.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by unishark on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:26AM (#22118904)
Rule by elites is a problem for 99 percent or the people (though presumably when things get too lopsided, the masses rise up, so elites still need to keep a decent percentage in their favor).

Democracy is a problem for 49 percent of people.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by munk-a on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @04:11PM (#22122083)
Only if a problem is reduced to a binary state. A lot of folks here on HN work with computers where true is true and false is false and there is nothing in the middle - but that's not how the world works, nearly everything we deal with is non-binary in nature, both SF and Houston have housing regulations, but those regulations are vastly different and if you tried to group housing regulations by severity you'd have to be extremely reductionist to end up with two categories.

This isn't actually unique to democracy and might be less achievable in a democratic system but all of politics is supposed to be about compromise, those housing regulations might get loosened up, but that might lower land values and decrease the amount of spending allocated to law enforcement or park maintenance or a wide array of things.

I'd prefer a short summary of democracy to read closer to:

> Democracy, some people win, some people lose, most people grump.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#22119039)
Questionable. After all, it's often the elites whipping said masses up to fury, a trend which continues today in more systematic fashion.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:38PM (#22121181)
They have to do that to build a voting bloc: Feign alignment with the disenfranchised masses to win elections. Then enact policies that reinforce their rancor.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by jakeogh on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @05:28PM (#22122753)
The "well fare" system, AKA putting people on the take, and it's latest iteration "universal free money" are exceptionally powerful control structures.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by pinkfoot on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22118800)
Or vulnerable minorities who make nice scapegoats. See Indonesia, Malaysia, Zimbabwe, Myanmar, etc…

Surely you could have figured this one out?

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by coldtea on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @12:17PM (#22119597)
All those countries had either dictatorships or representative democracies, and masses that give representative a "blank cheque" to do as they please for N years, and where elites lord over those people.

The very opposite of a direct democracy.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by peterwwillis on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:14AM (#22118788)
I'm pretty sure the Jews have something valuable to say about tyranny of the masses.
Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by coldtea on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @12:16PM (#22119575)
Exactly the opposite!

For one, Germany too had a representative system and elites governing. So what happened there wasn't some issue with "direct democracy" and tyrannical masses that a representative democracy would stop.

Second, even within Germany's non-direct-democracy system, the masses last voted for the various parties in 1933 in iirc, the Holocaust started much later, almost 8 years later. In fact, masses wise, Hitler didn't even democratically won 1933 elections. The last time the public had a chance to say anything, was a referendum in 1938, which wasn't on that matter at all (and which result was tampered by the party anyway -- there was "widespread intimidation of voters").

Hitler's Germany is hardly a case against direct democracy and the "tyranny of the masses". If anything, if people voted directly, Hitler might not have even gotten in power -- and his actions would be much more controlled and constrain, as in a direct democracy (ancient Athenian style) people decide for all matters, and can vote someone out of office at anytime, they don't give a blank check to some "representative".

And of course, the same horrible crimes could happen in the total opposite of a direct democracy, a downright dictatorship. And indeed, they did in Stalinist USSR or Maoist China.

So, thus far, we've ruled out representative democracy (Hitler), and dictatorship (Stalin).

Maybe direct democracy looks better now?

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by peterwwillis on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @03:41PM (#22121770)
You're right, that was a bad example.

So let's look at Athenian-style direct democracy. You have the ecclesia, an assembly where any male citizen can vote on proposals and elections (like a more ad-hoc city council meeting and election in one). You have a bureaucracy of 500 randomly selected men who run the city government. Once a year, you can vote to exile any leader for 10 years. Slavery was big business and women had no rights. There were very few elected officials and they were chosen randomly for the highest offices. Think of random people with conflicting, crazy ideas being voted in and out regularly, as judges, as bureaucrats, as heads of state. There was uneven representation because you had to show up regularly to voice your concern, only about a quarter of the people had this time/convenience luxury, and of course most people weren't very educated, so their opinions and positions were often.... dumb. But anyone who was a male citizen could show up and vote on just about anything, and simple majority was the winnter. The assemblies weren't held accountable to themselves, and could vote to break their own laws. Trials lasted one day; arguments were given, and then an immediate vote by the jurors. Out of 1100 citizens chosen by lot to (effectively) govern, 100 were elected. There were age restrictions and short term limits.

It changed over time. Over 300 years they went from having a king to having 3 Presidents who were aristocrats elected every 10 years, to elected every 1 year, to literally assigning the Presidency to a random citizen by lot, with the military overseen by 10 elected generals with varying degrees of social/political power in addition to total military command. If the people didn't like the job they were doing, they'd be voted out, fined, possibly executed. Originally the 500 civil servants were chosen by class, with the highest class (richest) getting the top positions, and the poorest class couldn't be selected; but later they could be selected and even got paid (partly because the "random selection" just happened to represent a lot of rich dudes). Eventually laws were not just things decided by assemblies, but small pools of lot-assigned citizens who decided what the law would be.

Some researchers have suggested that direct democracy like this wouldn't work over a very large area. It can work in towns and cities, and small city-states, but there's just too many factors for it to be practical in a large scale diverse modern nation.

Re:U.S. drinking water widely contaminated with 'forever che... by coldtea on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @07:28PM (#22123610)
>Slavery was big business and women had no rights

That was the norm of the era and much much later. Democracy is not supposed to change the norms of its times, it's supposed to assist those who participate to represent themselves better.

Women didn't have a vote well into the 20th century, the poor non land owning people couldn't vote in the US until the 19th century, and slavery was a thing for almost 2 and a half millennia after ancient Athenian democracy, even in much more "enlightened" and "christian love morals" nations. Even representative democracy gurus like the "Founding Fathers" had no qualms with owning slaves. So hardly a thing to blame ancient Athenian democracy for not solving 2.5 millennia in advance.

We should focus on what innovative (or worse) it did bring to the table, not whether in other ways it was compatible with a baseline that held for 2.5 millennia more.

>There were very few elected officials and they were chosen randomly for the highest offices. Think of random people with conflicting, crazy ideas being voted in and out regularly, as judges, as bureaucrats, as heads of state.

That was not a problem, as it is in the modern world. First, life was much more public oriented, so the crazy ideas where tamed by interaction with others (and of course, knowning that you will randomly be replaced in the next term).

>The assemblies weren't held accountable to themselves, and could vote to break their own laws.

That's the whole point, isn't it? That you're not iron-bound to some law you've passed, if you decide it doesn't work.

Even worse, being iron-bound to some law a policitian you've voted for for different reasons (say, because they promised tax breaks), passed on another matter, but you can't do anything, because you only get to vote wholesale (their whole platform, take it or leave it, even if you just strongly like 1-2 parts of it), and can't change anything for 4 years.

>It changed over time.

Again, that's a plus - people can change the system directly, they're not thrown into a rigid system they have no power on.

The rest, it not being perfect, the rich having increased influence (e.g. class playing a role), etc, were artefacts of the power balances of the era. That was the case everywhere, and is still now.

>Some researchers have suggested that direct democracy like this wouldn't work over a very large area. It can work in towns and cities, and small city-states, but there's just too many factors for it to be practical in a large scale diverse modern nation.

Doesn't need to be an exact replica. It could be multi-level (e.g. direct voting at the city/small district level), with national referendums on any major law, etc. Today we also have the option to vote online with crypto etc.