But considering the whole competitive ecosystem, and indirect effects over time, nasty SEO can help make Google money. Consider these mechanisms:
• when the natural results get polluted, the vetted AdWords placements become relatively more attractive to clickers and advertisers.
• Google' self-image requires they reserve some ostensibly 'non-paid' slots on the front-page. If in practice these all still have a high cash cost, even though paid to third parties, then everyone needs to open their wallets, rather than just do pure-of-heart helpful info-design, to appear on the front-page. That is, amounts paid to third parties serve as a short of shadow bid, placing a rising floor on the value of AdWords placements.
• SEO tactics that mildly or temporarily fool Google, but that Google then overcomes, provide a dynamic, ever-growing barrier-to-entry to other later-entrant search engines. Competitors don't have to do as well on the same web Google first mastered; they have to do as well on the web mutated by Google's economic incentives and iterated cat-and-mouse game.