But considering the whole competitive ecosystem, and indirect effects over time, nasty SEO can help make Google money. Consider these mechanisms:
• when the natural results get polluted, the vetted AdWords placements become relatively more attractive to clickers and advertisers.
• Google' self-image requires they reserve some ostensibly 'non-paid' slots on the front-page. If in practice these all still have a high cash cost, even though paid to third parties, then everyone needs to open their wallets, rather than just do pure-of-heart helpful info-design, to appear on the front-page. That is, amounts paid to third parties serve as a short of shadow bid, placing a rising floor on the value of AdWords placements.
• SEO tactics that mildly or temporarily fool Google, but that Google then overcomes, provide a dynamic, ever-growing barrier-to-entry to other later-entrant search engines. Competitors don't have to do as well on the same web Google first mastered; they have to do as well on the web mutated by Google's economic incentives and iterated cat-and-mouse game.
http://www.google.com/search?q=flowers
http://www.google.com/search?q=ipad
http://www.google.com/search?q=ghc+syntax
There used to be "More/fewer shopping results" in the left nav as well, but these seem to have been unlaunched.
But that is more or less the case now - the top commercial results are paid for (you need to pay for SEO). If you will pay Google directly for that, who would use Adwords then?
Google could implement this by showing more paid results for commercially-motivated searches – while allowing users to dial this back down if desired. (They do this a little with the varying number of AdWords units above natural results.)
Pretending the top results are not going to the largest budget, simply because they're the result of massive investment in gray SEO rather than direct payments to Google, is in some ways the worst approach. It enriches some shady operators, and has negative externalities polluting the rest of the web.
At one point years ago someone – I think it was Yahoo – experimented with a slider atop results that let you bias your results in a more- or less-commercially-oriented direction. It might be time to try similar experiments again, with a new UI and the now-more-sophisticated searchers of today.