News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by seibelj on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:27PM (#22082260)
There is a popular argument being made that any amount of inequality is evil and must be stamped out. I’ve asked several people to define in logical terms the line beneath which someone is not evil, and above which they are an evil rich person taking too many resources.

There is no logical explanation for such a line, it’s always an emotion against people who have more than them. Everyone always compares themselves to someone richer, whether they make 15k, 150k, or 1.5m. If you keep voting for such policies, you will eventually outlaw anyone for trying to do anything but living on government dole. It’s a sad future some people want. Venezuela collapsed rather quickly.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by ummonk on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:53PM (#22082371)
I mean if you take the income inequality argument and apply it to the world it is clear that pretty much every person in a developed country is an evil rich person taking too many resources.
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by seibelj on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:54PM (#22082377)
A valid point. Every American should feel bad about the fact they were born in America, if you follow that logic.
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by AngryData on Saturday January 18, 2020 @02:19AM (#22082930)
You gotta factor in cost of living though too. Someone in a crappy part of the world might live on $2 a day, but regardless of where or how you live in the US that would never keep you alive or a roof over your head where there it might, even if it is crappy.
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by Mirioron on Saturday January 18, 2020 @04:15AM (#22083358)
Why not? Is it impossible to survive in a forest in the US through hunting and gathering? Because that's exactly how our ancestors lived long ago. The people living on $2 a day in the poorest parts of the world are essentially living on that level of wealth. They don't buy most of their goods, they make them.

Go check out primitive technology on YouTube and see the stuff he does in a forest. That kind of stuff is available almost anywhere with a temperate forest.

The cost of living is higher in the US because people expect better stuff and they've put a limit on how low the quality can go. Eg building permits and other housing regulations. All of that significantly increases the cost of housing, but it also makes your minimum housing much better than in poor parts of the world.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by ummonk on Saturday January 18, 2020 @02:58PM (#22086711)
Yeah, but the same could be said for domestic income inequality. Hard to live in Old Greenwich, Connecticut, on an average American income...
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by tasogare on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:44PM (#22082334)
> outlaw anyone for trying to do anything

Are you saying that people who don’t earn few millions a year are doing nothing? Mind you, the majority of people are in this situation and contribute a lot to the society (teachers, doctors, researchers, any workers really). I’m not a leftist but I recognize the concentration of money in a few hands is probablematic, and a lot of business models to get to this point are harmful to the society at large.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by rayiner on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:29AM (#22083180)
But is it problematic? A teacher or doctor in America is better off than almost anywhere else in the world, including western european countries: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/gov_glance-2017-35-e... (See 3.27)

The countries with higher teacher salaries, like Canada, or in our general vicinity all have low corporate taxes.

There are things we need to fix in the US, like people who don’t have healthcare, and the housing market. (All the losses in the share of GDP of labor since the 1980s went to landlords, not capital owners.) But it’s not clear to me that income inequality is in and of itself something worth fixing, at the risk of novel measures that could give other countries a competitor advantage over us.

[dead]
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by hijinx on Saturday January 18, 2020 @12:14AM (#22082453)
Emotion has nothing to do with it. A strong, functional middle class is critical for the economic health of the nation, as will as it's ability to survive as a Democracy. With very, very few exceptions - wealth disparity is inversely related to the health, stability, and happiness of a populace. Nations with greater wealth disparity generally have less freedom, choice and social mobility. This was recognized multiple times in the nation's history, and upon action, economic growth was spurred. These are not emotions, these are facts that I won't even cite because a simple google search results in many scientific studies backing them.

On a slightly more emotional side:

With individual productivity increasing annually, it's a shame that individuals are not seeing proportional wage increases in return.

And none of that even touches upon the reality that those making the billions are rarely those with exceptional talent or skill. It's those who had the connections and financial wherewithall to build networks that are unreachable for those born into lower socioeconomic circumstances. No, I don't have data for that, but a simple unscientific survey of Execs making hundreds or thousands of times more than their employees are rarely from anything less than middle-upper class backgrounds, and most often have family money that allowed them opportunities never imaginable to lower rungs of society.

I do not like the idea of paying higher taxes, but I also recognize that individuals and companies are sitting on trillions upon trillions of dollars because they are making so much money that they can't spend it all. Just ask Bill Gates or Warren Buffet, both who agree with this and argue for higher taxes.

But emotions aside, it's simple economics. When social mobility is poor and inequality high, there simply aren't enough consumers to support the level needed for a country to remain 'first world'.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by seibelj on Saturday January 18, 2020 @12:21AM (#22082483)
The rate of wage increase for the lowest earners in America is higher than for the highest earners. Unemployment is lower than ever. I won’t even cite because you can prove this with a simple google search.

The fact remains that you think it’s morally correct to take money from people simply because they have it. To me, that’s theft. What is the salary at which we should seize money? You still haven’t answered this original question.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by tasogare on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:18AM (#22083145)
I didn't say money had to be taken from people. Actually I think it should be taken where it is: at the big company level. Except a few exceptions (Japan, South Korea) most of the taxation is on the shoulders of individuals and small/medium enterprises. Huge corporations such as Total has super low taxation rate, and others (GAFAM) avoid almost entirely taxation with taxes evasion schemes despite making billions from Europeans.

Then, besides taxes, companies should also fulfil their role in society by employing "useless" or low productivity people to a certain extend (this is already done a little In France for instance with law imposing a quota of disabled people). I saw it all the time where I live (Japan): people with useless jobs that have been completely removed by automation in Europe.

And finally, limiting the coefficient of the highest paid executive (let's say 100x) in comparison to the lowest paid on is no theft either, because the money didn't came in their pocket in the first place.

The idea at large is not the "rob" the C-execs of their money but to put more responsibilities on companies, which have acquired a disproportionate power in the last few centuries.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by joshuamorton on Saturday January 18, 2020 @12:03AM (#22082411)
Depends on your ethical framework. A utilitarian could claim that after the point where the marginal value of the dollar to the rich person is so low that seizing it results in higher global utility, even taking into account the angst and disincentives on the rich as a result.

Is society better off if you take 100 mil in income from Larry Ellison and Sundar pichai and build a few hundred units of low income housing? Even if it pisses off ellison and Google pays pichai less the next year?

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by drstewart on Saturday January 18, 2020 @12:35AM (#22082549)
> A utilitarian could claim that after the point where the marginal value of the dollar to the rich person is so low that seizing it results in higher global utility, even taking into account the angst and disincentives on the rich as a result.

A utilitarian could (and has) claimed that this marginal dollar occurs at the point where you have the bare minimum to survive: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/Y4Adk743X2ZoMBSBi/does-utili...

>"For example, utilitarianism apparently endorses killing a single innocent person and harvesting their organs if it will save five other people. It also appears to imply that donating all your money to charity beyond what you need to survive isn’t just admirable but morally obligatory. "

So I don't think a strictly utilitarian argument is sufficient.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by joshuamorton on Saturday January 18, 2020 @01:48AM (#22082825)
> A utilitarian could (and has) claimed that this marginal dollar occurs at the point where you have the bare minimum to survive

There's a few problems with this line of reasoning:

1. Its not clear to me that this argument is being made by a utilitarian, as you claim

2. You at least appear to show a misunderstanding of what "the marginal dollar" is. Every dollar is the marginal dollar. Its just that the relative value of dollar 1 (which you need to survive) is greater than the relative value of dollar 1 Billion, which you use to, uhhh, buy an island. I think what you're saying is that there is a point where the marginal value of your dollars is low enough that you are ethically obligated to donate them is at or around subsistence level, and that might be true, but it leads to the third problem:

3. Even for a strict utilitarian, if you take into account externalities, the right thing to do might not be to take all the money away from people. If you're optimizing for something like reducing death, reducing everyone in the US to subsistence level probably isn't the best solution: you'll likely do something unwarranted like cause a revolt. This has two major net negatives: a bunch of people die in the revolt, and you end up losing a lot of your money, either because you spend it to put down the revolt or because you don't and you lose and people take it back.

4. While improving the life of those in absolute poverty is a laudable goal, it's not clear that it makes sense for a government to do that, except when it ends up being beneficial to the government or its people. In other words, a government's moral imperative probably doesn't extend (far) beyond its borders.

> So I don't think a strictly utilitarian argument is sufficient.

People often forget about externalities.

On the other hand, if you think of the supply of billionaires as a revenue source, and then you think of there being decreasing demand for being a billionaire as taxes go up, but increased revenue per billionaire as taxes go up, you can draw up supply and demand curves and optimize to maximize revenue from billionaires (or people in general really, its just that the marginal rates can likely be higher on billionaires and they're the talking point of the day). If there are 100 billionaires, and you tax 2% more, and 1 billionaire moves away, you're still up on revenue. I often hear people arguing that we should operate our government more like a business.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by Mirioron on Saturday January 18, 2020 @04:08AM (#22083325)
>If there are 100 billionaires, and you tax 2% more, and 1 billionaire moves away, you're still up on revenue.

But that's not the only thing that happens though.

A prospective billionaire that is not yet a billionaire might think "there's little point in putting in all this work on this new project, because the government will take more of my money".

Another thing that can happen is that a foreign company decides to invest somewhere else because of that tax. They might look at the tax and expect it to discourage investment internally and look for potentially better prospects.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by speedplane on Saturday January 18, 2020 @02:08AM (#22082887)
> If there are 100 billionaires, and you tax 2% more, and 1 billionaire moves away, you're still up on revenue. I often hear people arguing that we should operate our government more like a business.

This is actually one of the standard strategies for taxation: we should setup a tax system that optimizes for the maximum total tax receipts. When you tax too much, incentives go down and you actually lower your total tax receipts. In principle, there is an optimal taxation amount.

The problem with this approach is that we don't have good enough data. No one really knows how many fewer billionaires there would be if we increased their taxes, and biased interests each have plenty of conjured data to make their argument.

There are other tax strategies as well: trickle down economics (a favorite of the right, also based on suspect data); and guaranteeing living wage (a favorite of the left). One advantage of the latter is that the argument is not based on numbers or data, but on morality.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by seibelj on Saturday January 18, 2020 @12:13AM (#22082442)
I see the wealthy person as someone who is clever and disciplined. The government is neither clever nor disciplined. I believe letting the billionaire keep his or her money is more likely to increase world utility.

Elon and Bezos send people to space with the wealth they fairly gained. The government prints trillions of dollars every year to fund their deficits and wars. If the government needs another billion dollars, it’s quite easy for them to create it.

Why seize money from the rare person who is talented enough to make so much of it?

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by pmoriarty on Saturday January 18, 2020 @01:21AM (#22082723)
Let's say some incredibly talented person "fairly" comes to own all the water in the world. All the rest of us would depend on this person to live, and he/she could choose which of us lives or dies simply by not selling us any water.

Would you want to live in such a world? Or do you think maybe the rest of us deserve to have some of that water, even if we're not as clever and we didn't "fairly" earn it?

Dialing back to the real world, all these billionaires and other elites are having very real outsize impacts on the lives of the less wealthy -- from whether/where/how they work, to how they and their children get educated, to what information we have access to, to who goes to jail and who goes free, who goes to war and against whom, and who lives or dies.

Incredible wealth gives people incredible power, and the concentration of this incredible power in the hands of a small minority is distorting the world in ways those not in this minority are having trouble swallowing, no matter whether this concentration of wealth and power was "fairly" arrived at or not.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by bluecalm on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:32AM (#22083195)
If you are concerned about that focus on anti monopoly laws not taxes. If one person owns all the water so you prefer a solution that forces them to give % of income derived from it to others or do you prefer a solution that prevents them from owning all the water?
Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by pmoriarty on Saturday January 18, 2020 @06:24AM (#22083818)
Anti-monopoly laws are not enough (even if we ignore the problems of regulatory capture). If all the water was owned by three people instead of one person, or even by five people, or a thousand, there'd still be the other seven billion of us which would die of thirst if these thousand commanded.

But, yes, giving up some of what they own is one way of dealing with it... though one could argue that by the time they have control of all that water or wealth, it's too late, because by then they have so much power that they, not you, get to call the shots.

Another way is to change the system so that they don't gain so much control in the first place, and so that water (or wealth) is distributed more equitably among all seven billion of us instead of just a tiny few.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by TFYS on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:33AM (#22083199)
The government sent people to space decades ago. Elon and Bezos would be nowhere near sending people to space without the work government has done.

The government spends trillions on wars exactly because of the power concentration you are defending. It's not the common man that decides to go to war, it's the network of wealthy people who benefit from it.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2020 @07:10AM (#22083977)
You could make a similar argument about pollution. A certain amount of it is necessary, it’s not possible to have a society, especially a developed one, that doesn’t pollute at all. So where do you draw the line?

It’s arbitrary, and yet saying that means we should just let people pollute endlessly doesn’t make sense either.

Re:California wants to tax companies for executive pay ratio by m_ke on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:45PM (#22082336)
Income inequality becomes an issue for the rich in cities like SF and NYC when costs of living rise faster than wages for the lower class and you end up with a rising homeless population.