News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by keiferski on Thursday January 16, 2020 @05:24PM (#22069670)
Maybe I’m misunderstanding it, but the Fermi Paradox always seemed hopelessly naive and myopic to me. We understand such a small percentage of reality, but more importantly, everything we learn and observe is through our human perspective.

It seems more logical to assume that the universe appears empty to us because we are the only organisms like ourselves, and that other life forms exist in ways that are simply incomprehensible to us at the current level of scientific understanding.

Edit: To use a metaphor I’ve just thought of (and think works): many people assume that meeting extraterrestrial life will be akin to Europeans landing in the New World. It’s more likely that it will be akin to the discovery of the atom.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by Voloskaya on Thursday January 16, 2020 @05:53PM (#22069939)
That doesn't really change anything though.

Even if we assume that the vast majority of life forms are undetectable/incomprehensible, there is still no good explanation for why Earth would be the only place suitable for life forms similar to us.

Among the many steps necessary to evolve life as we know it, which one could only happen here?

So the paradox is still there.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by krapp on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:00PM (#22069997)
There are billions of stars in a galaxy, and billions of galaxies in the known universe. There could be more worlds with life similar to ours than there are grains of sand on Earth's beaches, and drops of water in its oceans, and we could still never even be aware of them simply because the universe is that vast.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by Voloskaya on Thursday January 16, 2020 @11:42PM (#22071914)
Precisely the opposite. There are so many possible world that match all the criteria (that we know of) for life just within our galaxy, that we should detect some of them. Our solar system is pretty young compared to the age of the galaxy (4B years old vs 13B years old). Imagine a civilization identical to ours, but that would have appeared a mere 1 billion years before us, not only radio signals should be detectable (because the galaxy is just 100k light years across), but a civilization similar to ours, with 1B more year to develop technologically should have easily been able to send probes, at the very least, all over the galaxy (see von neuman probes) so we should also see that, and yet we don't.

And this just assuming a single civilization, while as you said: there could be more worlds with life similar to ours that there are grains of sand on Earth. So where is everyone?

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by harshalizee on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:31AM (#22076082)
Detect with what? We've had radio signals for about a century or so and our signals have barely made out of the solar system at which point it's just background noise. We just barely can detect planets and only in optimal conditions. Our tech for all extra terrestrial purposes is laughably primitive.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by Voloskaya on Friday January 17, 2020 @02:37PM (#22078335)
You greatly overestimate the size of the solar system. Our solar system is a mere ~20 light hours in radius. We even have two man made objects out of the solar system (Voyager 1 and 2). In a century, our signals already made it past ~15 thousands star systems.

So now imagine a civilization similar to us but slightly older, not only would this civilization's signals have reached all parts of our galaxy, but those signals would likely be much stronger than we have produced in the last 100 years. It would also be possible for a civilization a few hundred millions years older than us to send probes to every star of the galaxy by now.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by BerislavLopac on Friday January 17, 2020 @05:12AM (#22073422)
"there is still no good explanation for why Earth would be the only place suitable for life forms similar to us"

1. There is still no good explanation _that we know of_. We don't even know if we are the only life forms in existence or not: none of the observations made so far support the latter, but do not disprove it either. So we can't prove or disprove _any_ hypothesis about extraterrestrial life.

2. "Suitable for life similar to us" and "suitable for life to spontaneously appear" are two very different things. And we still don't know enough about either.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by brutt on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:13PM (#22070099)
Maybe because worlds are continuously created and destroyed, so they have no time to create life and then develop technological civilization. We are just lucky to fit tight limit.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by Voloskaya on Thursday January 16, 2020 @11:32PM (#22071878)
That is pretty much the 'great filter' solution to Fermi paradox: there exist some kind of filter that prevents most life forms from being galaxy-spanning where they would be easily detectable.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by jcranmer on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:54PM (#22070404)
The biggest issue I've had with the Fermi Paradox is why should we expect to have seen evidence of alien life by now? At our current level of technology, we can only say with confidence that there is no alien life of about our complexity in our solar system since the last glacial maximum or so. We can't detect life as close to us as the nearest star, let alone anywhere else in the galaxy.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by jbattle on Thursday January 16, 2020 @05:39PM (#22069796)
I mean sorta. But think about the incredible variety of life on Earth. Read some science fiction. I'm not saying our search space / our expectations are perfectly broad enough.

But I've never seen any sign the people involved in SETI are doing this with blinders trying to find bipedal creatures with a mouth that breathes oxygen and are about 1-2 meters tall.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by keiferski on Thursday January 16, 2020 @05:42PM (#22069821)
But is it actually that varied when compared to the infinity of the universe? All life on Earth is carbon-based, to start with.

The assumption always seems to be that experience as we perceive it now is some sort of default, objective one. It’s far more likely that we are simply locked into a very narrow viewpoint. The scales are simply so large that we are unable to comprehend them in any meaningful way.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_chauvinism

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by unionpivo on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:52PM (#22070384)
i mean there is a reason to believe that if there is other life in universe its going to also be carbon based.

Carbon can form more molecules than all the other elements combined, so it makes sense that complex chemical "elements" are heavily based on it.

In fact if you compare most common elements in universe[1] and most common elements in human body[2] they are mostly the same (different order)

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_the_chemical_elem... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composition_of_the_human_body

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by jcranmer on Thursday January 16, 2020 @07:03PM (#22070471)
Carl Sagan, who coined the term, has admitted that he is a carbon chauvinist. And I suspect most biochemists are as well; there are decent chemical reasons to disfavor any other system.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by chopin on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:45AM (#22074112)
On the other hand carbon chemistry is the center of expertise for biochemists. They hardly know anything else.

As well, carbon chemistry is rich under earth conditions (temperature and pressure wise). We simply don't know for others.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by gooseus on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:17PM (#22070127)
I agree if you're speaking about "life", but if we're talking about self-aware intelligence then I believe that once they discover their analog to the Second Law, they would have to (eventually) realize that their survival depends on extra-planetary expansion.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday January 16, 2020 @05:30PM (#22069726)
Agreed. Assuming we avoid extinction, it's not obvious we'll be able to recognise ourselves a few hundred years from now, never mind a few thousand. And a gulf of a few million years would be utterly incomprehensible.

In fact I'd be very suspicious if recognisable alien life appeared and knocked on our door, because it would literally be so astronomically unlikely I'd be skeptical about taking it at face value.

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by blacksmith_tb on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:21PM (#22070164)
Well, yes and no - plenty of terrestrial organisms that haven't shared a common ancestor with us for hundreds of millions of years can recognize us (like, say, crows). But I agree that easily recognizable sentient aliens visiting us in person is very unlikely, due to the scale of the universe.