Even if we assume that the vast majority of life forms are undetectable/incomprehensible, there is still no good explanation for why Earth would be the only place suitable for life forms similar to us.
Among the many steps necessary to evolve life as we know it, which one could only happen here?
So the paradox is still there.
And this just assuming a single civilization, while as you said: there could be more worlds with life similar to ours that there are grains of sand on Earth. So where is everyone?
So now imagine a civilization similar to us but slightly older, not only would this civilization's signals have reached all parts of our galaxy, but those signals would likely be much stronger than we have produced in the last 100 years. It would also be possible for a civilization a few hundred millions years older than us to send probes to every star of the galaxy by now.
1. There is still no good explanation _that we know of_. We don't even know if we are the only life forms in existence or not: none of the observations made so far support the latter, but do not disprove it either. So we can't prove or disprove _any_ hypothesis about extraterrestrial life.
2. "Suitable for life similar to us" and "suitable for life to spontaneously appear" are two very different things. And we still don't know enough about either.
But I've never seen any sign the people involved in SETI are doing this with blinders trying to find bipedal creatures with a mouth that breathes oxygen and are about 1-2 meters tall.
The assumption always seems to be that experience as we perceive it now is some sort of default, objective one. It’s far more likely that we are simply locked into a very narrow viewpoint. The scales are simply so large that we are unable to comprehend them in any meaningful way.
Carbon can form more molecules than all the other elements combined, so it makes sense that complex chemical "elements" are heavily based on it.
In fact if you compare most common elements in universe[1] and most common elements in human body[2] they are mostly the same (different order)
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abundance_of_the_chemical_elem... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composition_of_the_human_body
As well, carbon chemistry is rich under earth conditions (temperature and pressure wise). We simply don't know for others.
In fact I'd be very suspicious if recognisable alien life appeared and knocked on our door, because it would literally be so astronomically unlikely I'd be skeptical about taking it at face value.
It seems more logical to assume that the universe appears empty to us because we are the only organisms like ourselves, and that other life forms exist in ways that are simply incomprehensible to us at the current level of scientific understanding.
Edit: To use a metaphor I’ve just thought of (and think works): many people assume that meeting extraterrestrial life will be akin to Europeans landing in the New World. It’s more likely that it will be akin to the discovery of the atom.