Re:Christopher Tolkien has died
by ska on Thursday January 16, 2020 @04:10PM
(#22068973)
As I understand it a lot of the heavy lifting on that (the Silmarillion) was done by a young Guy Gavriel Kay. But neither of them have been very forthcoming about the collaboration.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Christopher Tolkien has died
by Mediterraneo10 on Thursday January 16, 2020 @09:27PM
(#22071311)
It has been years since I read about Kay's role, but IIRC he wrote only a few very brief passages and the pair were open about their roles. I remember being surprised at how little new material had to be written to make J.R.R. Tolkien's own texts coherent.
Christopher has also publicly expressed regret at how quickly he assembled the published Silmarillion, I wonder if that's related.
Was he thinking about a re-edited edition of The Silmarillion? With significant changes?
My understanding is that The Silmarilion was originally conceived as wrapped in Bilbo's Translations ftom the Elvish*. Christopher Tolkien said that he regretted not having that in the published version.
But there was never any talk of a new edition.