Re:Mozilla lays off 70
by madeofpalk on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @05:37PM
(#22059585)
I think that alert's design is actually a _feature_. Safari made a similar change a while back not make the alerts look like system UI, to prevent phishing and similar attacks.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mozilla lays off 70
by reaperducer on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @05:47PM
(#22059672)
Ah, I wondered why that was done. Thanks for the light bulb.
That and I believe the new modal prevents locking up the entire browser.
My point is not that it doesn't look native... It's a neglected part of the UI.
The person you responded to specifically explained that. It's made to look non-native on purpose so that users don't think a pop-up, phishing, asking for their password, is a native system prompt. Safari did the same thing. It's not that it's neglected, quite the opposite, actually.
The Safari alert doesn't look native and yet it looks polished.
Personally, I don't think the Firefox version looks any worse than the Safari version, they're just different. It comes down to preference. Just like you saying it's the ugliest tab bar which I very much disagree with.
Sure, aesthetics is ultimately a subjective thing, but that's not what I'm saying.
It's not? That's exactly how I've been interpreting it. Objectively, how is the Safari version better? Other than subjective design.
When I say polished I don't mean a polished visual style in an aesthetic sense. What I mean is that a designer has put some work on a UI element and after some iterations there has been a conscious decision over why an element looks the way it looks.
For example, one of the major considerations when doing UI design is creating elements that have a cohesive style (regardless of which aesthetic style that is).
None of that happened on that god forgotten alert. It's probably the first thing that someone came up with in a rush, in a style that no other UI element of FF shares, and it has stayed like this probably because nobody cares.