News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by lmm on Monday January 13, 2020 @09:06PM (#22041141)
> 1. I originally thought the Heisenberg Uncertainty principle was a natural consequence of using particles (photos) for measurement. Instead however it seems to be a fundamental property of the universe, which I only learned after finding out most of the mass of hadrons comes from the relativistic motion of quarks and it explains why hadrons don't collapse to a point.

> 2. What does it even mean to create more space? The universe is expanding. Ok, I can accept that. But what does it mean?

IME both QM and Relativity are much more easily understood if you start from the actual equations and/or an undergrad textbook. I don't think physics is - yet - beyond the technical and scientific minded amateur who is willing to read and understand some equations. But it's probably gone beyond the ability of any science journalist to render into prose.

> 3. I find the models for dark matter and dark energy to be... unsatisfying. I realize there's experimental evidence for unobservable mass but it feels like a fudge.

I think working scientists would agree with you at least as far as dark energy goes. Dark matter is pretty indisputably just some kind of matter that we can't see (see e.g. the Bullet Cluster) - there's still something to be solved in terms of figuring out what it actually is, but I don't expect that to be major new physics. But as to dark energy: yeah, it's a fudge. Everyone knows it's a fudge. But it's still our best description of reality. Even if you knew there was something wrong with epicycles, they were still the best way to calculate planetary orbits at the time.

> I could go on. I don't for a second mean to suggest any of these notions are wrong. It's just that the models have gotten so complex (it seems?) that it just feels like something huge is missing, something that will eventually seem obvious in hindsight. Or am I just a lemur trying to figure out how an airplane works?

I think models aren't complex so much as unfamiliar. We're getting further and further away from everyday experience, and so more and more of the fundamentals of reality have to be understood from mathematical first principles rather than everyday intuition.

The models are actually really good though. Certainly once I understood QM it seemed so clear and simple that it couldn't possibly not be true.

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by goatlover on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @01:09AM (#22042285)
> We're getting further and further away from everyday experience, and so more and more of the fundamentals of reality have to be understood from mathematical first principles rather than everyday intuition.

How much of that is an insistence on thinking of things in terms of fundamental particles and definitive properties instead of fields and packets of energy? I guess the question is that what the mathematical models are really about, and whether we're just having a hard time shrugging off Greek atomism and 19th century materialism when it comes to intuition?

Intuition could be built on top of a solid understanding of fields, backed by the math. The difficult part is connecting that to the classical world of our size that we experience.

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by lmm on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @02:07AM (#22042535)
> How much of that is an insistence on thinking of things in terms of fundamental particles and definitive properties instead of fields and packets of energy? I guess the question is that what the mathematical models are really about, and whether we're just having a hard time shrugging off Greek atomism and 19th century materialism when it comes to intuition?

I don't think it's "Greek atomism and 19th century materialism" to imagine a world made of persistent physical objects in well-defined positions. That's the entirety of everyday life.

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by goatlover on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @06:35PM (#22050348)
Consider the competing ontological views: everything is made up of water, the five elements, everything is a sphere, the world is a simulation, everything is ideas being perceived by the mind, the world is matter formed by the ideal forms, etc.

Those views were prominent among certain intellectuals at different times which go against the grain of everyday experience. Since physicists are trying to understand the fundamental nature of the world, I take it they're used to not accepting appearance as a guide, and are rather operating under whatever philosophical intuition is dominant at the time. Since 19th century physics confirmed the existence of atoms, and the periodic able of ordinary matter is made up of atomic bonds, then it makes since that physicists have been influenced by that guiding intuition.

Regardless, fields are probably a better building block for intuition than particles.