News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy by arethuza on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:01PM (#2202614)
I think anyone who has worked in the field of AI would admit there are a lot of philosophical questions around the definition of intelligence and it's relationship to algorithmic problem solving.

One of my favourite thought experiments in the area being Searle's Chinese Room:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy by kls on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:15PM (#2202691)
Sure, intelligence is much like religion or faith, what it is is a very personal matter as well a philosophical matter to each observer. To me if a machine can make a logical decision that it arrives at via it's own conclusion independent of human involvement (after the initial construction). It can be said to be intelligent. I personally think we have already achieved intelligent machines. Granted not intelligent in the traditional biological sense but intelligent in their own right. I do believe that we are close to hyper-intelligent machines than many think we are. I personally think it will be the next big step. I also believe that it will fundamentally and irrevocably change humanity. It is a Pandora's box that we will not know the ramifications of until we pass that event horizon, it is much like Schrodinger cat, full of possibilities but until we experience the event we will not know how it affects humanity.
Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy by Qz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @03:46PM (#2203640)
If you read further on Searle and the Chinese Room, you'll find that most of his argument has been debunked and what remains is an Appeal to Common Sense. "The man in the room can't really understand Chinese--right guys?"
Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy by natural219 on Thursday February 10, 2011 @02:31PM (#2203327)
How is this anything but pure semantics? I still don't know the conceptual difference between Searle's strong AI and weak AI, other a single word change in the definition.
Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy by blauwbilgorgel on Thursday February 10, 2011 @03:39PM (#2203616)
It's all about semantics with philosophers ;)

Searle claims through this experiment that strong AI does not exist. The robot in the room doesn't know how to talk Chinese, it just matches up symbols by using an elaborate dictionary.

Turing defined intelligence by the appearance of intelligence. If the Chinese room can make you think it houses someone that speaks Chinese, than that means the person in the room is intelligent.

To Searle everything is weak AI. Just calculation, without knowing what they really calculate. Intelligence is more than appearance, like a hologram of someone, is not that person self.

Pragmatists and functionalists play around Searle's conclusion. For them it is about the behavior, not the system itself. In Searle's vision something like the China Brain (every person in China uses a radio to act as a neuron) is ridiculous. In the functionalist view the China Brain is intelligent and self-aware.