Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by madcaptenor on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:02PM
(#2202920)
But who cares about P(PhD|jobless)? P(jobless|PhD) is important; it's a measure of how much job security a PhD leads to. But P(PhD|jobless) is only important if you're a jobless PhD and you want to know what your chances of finding someone else who's survived grad school in the unemployment line. I wouldn't know how to interpret "1 out of every n jobless people has a PhD"; the first thing I'd ask is "what proportion of all people have a PhD", and then essentially run things through a crude mental version of Bayes' theorem.
(I have a PhD. In probability.)
Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by btilly on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:08PM
(#2202953)
P(jobless|PhD) is important; it's a measure of how much job security a PhD leads to.
No, it is a measure of how much job security a PhD is correlated with. I believe that the qualities that lead to one being able to complete a PhD are positively correlated with being able to get and hold a job. Therefore you need to restrict to just those people you think could get a PhD to figure out how much the PhD helps or hurts you.
Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by madcaptenor on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:10PM
(#2202962)
I stand corrected. This is exactly what I'd tell my students if they had made the mistake I made.
Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by psyklic on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:39PM
(#2203085)
Despite it's practicality, I for one enjoyed the statistic.
Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by hyperbovine on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:14PM
(#2202978)
But then you wouldn't get to use Bayes' theorem in a public setting.
Re:Science PhDs Have Very Low Jobless Rates
by grn on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:23PM
(#2202730)
Bayes' theorem states that P(A|B) = P(B|A) * P(A) / P(B), so in this case it says P(PhD|jobless) = P(jobless|PhD) * P(PhD) / P(jobless). It seems that you stated it incorrectly but used the correct version in the computation (the incorrect gives 0.2244).
According to Baye's Theorem, the P(PhD|jobless) = P(jobless|PhD)*P(PhD)/P(jobless)
Where according to [1], P(PhD) = 0.01 (for all PhDs) so assuming roughly half are science, P(PhD) = 0.005, and we get
P(PhD|jobless) = 0.0013, or 0.13%, which means that roughly 1 out of every 1000 jobless people has a PhD.
[1]http://factfinder.census.gov/servlet/QTTable?_bm=y&-geo_...