Edit: changed, from "pedestrian way" to "pedestrian crossing."
They don't have many nice things to say about it.
Also, the very first Brazilian constitution had an article about moving the capital to a more geographically centered place, a plan that was developed while Brazil was an empire [2]. One could argue that the move was simply a matter of fulfilling this constitution article.
Another reason could be that the Rio and São Paulo areas are full of mountain chains and make the task of building a new city quite difficult.
Yet another reason is that building the capital in the São Paulo state or Minas Gerais state would bring back old political rivalries (Brazil was controlled by politicians by these states for decades [3]). Same for the surrounding states. Hence, moving it to a more neutral area.
Anyway, hard to pinpoint one specific reason. The city is interesting, though, with nice people trying to define their own cultural aspects. Unfortunately, most Brazilians have never visited it.
[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/79/Esplanad...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bras%C3%ADlia#Background
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caf%C3%A9_com_leite_politics
[1] https://g1.globo.com/df/distrito-federal/noticia/2019/06/04/... (Portuguese only)
[2] https://www.dronebrasilia.com/assets/img/portfolio/agosto201...
So it's succeeding in spite of its faults? Or would it be growing even faster if it were set up better?
However, the designed neighborhoods are currently noble areas where only rich people can afford renting/buying apartments. Poor families are forced to live far from the city center (think 2-3 hours by bus) in dangerous places controlled by organized crime. For instance, Sol Nascente will most likely become the largest favela in Brazil (even larger than the ones in Rio since it can grow without being limited by surrounding mountains).
[1] https://epoca.globo.com/sol-nascente-favela-de-brasilia-que-... (Portuguese only)
With that sort of boost, any city would trive.
Probably, the older cities, such as Boston and even downtown NYC are quite different from what I was used to in Brasília. There is less urban planning and more organic growth.
It is easy to cross the city from east-west but quite painful to do so north-south. Things are quite far from each other, so it isn't common to simply walk: you either drive or take a bus (and the public transportation system is awful) even for the most mundane things. Retail suffers a lot because there is simply not enough people walking close to stores. No day-to-day coffee shop survives because people don't take their cars for a regular coffee (only gourmet ones thrive). Even worse, the city is more or less sectorized (hospitals, government buildings, hotels, industry etc are clustered in specific zones), which drives up the number of cars in these areas.
Also, the city was planned for ~500k people, up to 1M. The metro area currently has 3.5M inhabitants and is one of the fastest growing metro areas in Brazil. Since the airplane sector cannot be modified, most people end up living in dorm-cities around Brasília even though 95% of them work in the airplane. A commute of 20-50km is pretty standard, so the traffic during rush hours is horrific.
At the end of the day, in my opinion, the design really influences how people behave in the city for the worse. Since I left Brasília to live in "normal" cities, both in Brazil and abroad, I came to the conclusion that Brasília became a failed experiment of the Brazilian modern architecture and urbanism.
Feel free to ask me anything about my hometown or even disagree with me if you also lived in Brasília!