News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by theonething on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:10PM (#22016611)
The answer is no, but is it more secure than no 2FA?

Of course there are much better 2FA options, but for the general public, they are probably too complicated to use.

Everyone understands SMS.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by Kalium on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:56PM (#22016861)
Have you seen the prompt system, as used by Google, Micosoft, Okta, et al.?

In my strictly personal opinion, responding to a notification that asks if a login attempt is you is clear enough that people need minimal training to make use of it. This might just be me, though.

In my career, I've definitely seen people actively choose SMS over other factors on offer. It was easier for them, and in many cases shouldn't have been offered. Your point about SMS being better than nothing is wise and true and insightful, but it's perhaps not always the question as faced in practice.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by sfifs on Friday January 10, 2020 @08:25PM (#22017365)
They (and similar corporate 2FA solutions like PingID and similar systems used by banks) basically assume uninterrupted access to the internet which is generally a poor assumption. It often breaks down when you're traveling either due to network or roaming issues just when you desperately need access.

In all these situations, I've found companies which offer a back up SMS option very valuable since it usually gets delivered.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by wwwigham on Friday January 10, 2020 @10:27PM (#22017910)
I'm pretty sure the Microsoft authenticator has a backup TOTP token you can have it display if you have issues receiving the notification. It is quite a user friendly auth scheme, at least I've never had to resort to any kind of SMS backed auth.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by Kalium on Monday January 13, 2020 @10:47AM (#22035439)
In my opinion, that sounds like precisely the sort of system that should not offer an SMS fallback unless the goal is to create a false sense of security in the user. But YMMV, I don't generally need to access my online banking applications when I don't have useful internet access.

I tend to use TOTP for systems where I'm concerned about offline usage. But again, YMMV.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by davchana on Friday January 10, 2020 @09:17PM (#22017605)
Yeah, and my local walmart has a section where there is no network coverage; I was browsing the store and wanted to check something on my bank app; it prompted me for SMS code, which I didn't receive because of no network; & I would not have received the Google prompt if I needed one for the same reason.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by DaiPlusPlus on Friday January 10, 2020 @09:13PM (#22017586)
HOTP-based 2FA systems (like Google Authenticator) do not require internet connections.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by lol768 on Saturday January 11, 2020 @05:04PM (#22022668)
Don't most folks uses TOTP-based schemes with Google Authenticator?

Unless you're using HOTP to mean HOTP and all extending schemes.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by gowld on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:59PM (#22016894)
The problem there is that it's not very clear that you didn't trigger the login yourself.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by Kalium on Friday January 10, 2020 @07:01PM (#22016909)
It's been my experience that it's often reasonably clear to users that they did perform a login themselves in the past few seconds. Adding an approximate location and a short verification token to the prompt generally helps.

Your experience and standards of clarity may be different from mine, obviously.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by rocqua on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:33PM (#22016755)
I think at some point goolge used SMS 2FA as a sole factor in account recovery. So there, you really were worse off with SMS 2FA enabled.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by robbya on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:39PM (#22016787)
This is really a criticism that Google called their system 2FA but actually was using it as a sole factor. That's bad security and bad naming. Had they actually used it as a second factor, then you would have seen a security benefit.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by KingMachiavelli on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:34PM (#22016760)
Well if that's the case they could still offer true MFA. Make at least SMS 2FA mandatory but offer OTP/token based MFA.

Obviously banks are a place with a lot of low-value targets and a few very high-value targets, but the cost to implement MFA is the same so they might as well do it.

Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by jeltz on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:51PM (#22016846)
Yeah, the by far biggest cost of 2FA is the recovery process which you need anyway, not actual 2FA implementation.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by minimaxir on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:18PM (#22016664)
Awareness may make providers more willing to switch to a better 2FA, such as TOTP.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by 0xffff2 on Friday January 10, 2020 @07:55PM (#22017214)
Sadly, providers seem to be going the other way. I had a service try to bully me into disabling TOTP in favor of SMS 2FA this week.
Re:SMS is not 2FA-secure by 1996 on Friday January 10, 2020 @08:45PM (#22017463)
Because they want your phone number. They are more and more used to link to identities, as people tend to keep (and port) their phone number

Hint: if a store ask for a phone number to get a discount, try the local areacode then 634 5789. This is from an old song, and many people seem to have created "anonymous" account with it!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/634-5789_(Soulsville,_U.S.A.)