News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by PaulHoule on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:21PM (#22012640)
It is not hard if you are stressed.

A U.S. Navy ship, the Vincennes shot down an Iranian airliner in 1988 by accident.

Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by simonh on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:33PM (#22012785)
Exactly, Iran had just launched attacks on several US air force bases in Iraq hours previously and their air defences would have been on high alert for any possible counter-attacks.

In the Vincennes incident the AEGIS tracking software at the time reused tracking IDs for targets, and re-assigned a tracking ID from the airliner to a fighter jet 110 miles away, leading to mistaken information being relayed about the flight's activities.

This goes to show until and unless we know what information the missile system operators had, and what orders they were under, we can't really say what happened and why.

Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by eloff on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:31PM (#22012760)
My dad was telling me this story last night. I'm surprised I wasn't aware of it.

In many ways it's a more surprising accident since in those days the U.S. was not expecting an Iranian attack, but Iran has good reason to be on high alert and expect US warplanes now.

The US did eventually acknowledge the incident and pay reparations to Iran. What are the odds Iran does that to Canada now? Approximately zero. I'd be surprised if they even admit it, even while cornered. A number of Iranians here in Canada think it was the US that shot down the airliner. Pretty ridiculous, but if westernized Iranians living in the free world can think that, imagine what people in Iran would be willing to believe when lied to by their government.

Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by mytailorisrich on Friday January 10, 2020 @02:22PM (#22014318)
> What are the odds Iran does that to Canada now? Approximately zero.

Not now but this will become another bargaining chip and one day they may agree to pay compensation in the context of wider negotiations.

Libya agreed to pay compensations for Lockerbie 20 years later as part of wider negotiations and it is unclear whether they were involved at all...

Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:56PM (#22013025)
The US was absolutely expecting an Iranian attack on the Vincennes. Maybe not as "probably right now" as Iran was, but it was definitely a realistic, expected, on-guard-against scenario.
Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by eloff on Friday January 10, 2020 @01:08PM (#22013181)
Maybe I'm still missing some backstory there of the context in the Gulf in 1988. The Captain of the Vincennes was acting very aggressively on that day, and shooting down the airliner was the sad end result of that.
Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by PaulHoule on Friday January 10, 2020 @01:30PM (#22013562)
Iraqis hit the USA Stark with air to sea.missile not long before and there was extensive low-level surface conflict in the gulf at.That time.
Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by panarky on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:40PM (#22012840)
Doesn't the system display aircraft types and friendly / enemy / unknown status?

Something like this -> https://imgur.com/a/kOkRAhd

Friendly aircraft have transponders to identify them. And even without a transponder, certainly a large, slow airliner looks very different on radar than a small, fast fighter or missile.

Seems like the system would require some kind of override to fire at a friendly target.

Re:Ask HN: How surface-to-air missile can be fired unintenti... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 10, 2020 @12:55PM (#22013010)
Stressed, as in, fearful of attack. A surface-to-air missile site (or command and control center) would be one of the first places attacked. That is, the person is under the stress that, if it's a real attack and he doesn't pull the trigger, he may die. (The Vincennes had the same stress.)