There's not a compressor. Well, there might be one in the refrigerator that "freezes" the air, but the air that is being used for energy storage is not, itself compressed.
In any case, as with any other energy storage, I don't think they're claiming it's lossless, but rather that the liquid nitrogen has a much higher energy density than compressed air. It sounds plausible, given that the gaseous to liquid volume ratio for nitrogen is something like 600:1, but I don't actually know. Might still have very high losses, I guess.
That is, increasing temperature is equivalent to increasing pressure, and vice versa: decreasing either is equivalent.
The problem with liquifying -- cooling -- a gas, is that:
1. You're removing thermal energy. Which itself cannot be usefully stored. So you're losing that unless it can be applied to some local low-quality heat process.
2. Re-gassifying the liquified air requires energy. If you've managed to store (some of) the removed heat, you can apply that. Otherwise, whatever you're using to introduce heat to the liquified air will itself get very* cold, very quickly, and eventually reach thermal equilibrium. Alternatively, you could apply a fuel-based heat source sufficient to boil off the liquid, but that's going to cost you energy.
Depending on the temperature of the freshly-generated gas, you're also going to be chilling whatever generating process you've got (probably gas turbine), which means both metal embrittlement and potential for frosting if there's any degree of water vapour in the air.
The more usual form of air-based energy storage, compressed air energy storage (CAES) likewise has problems with both heat loss and chilling on expansion. Compressing a gas heats it, and that heat will tend to escape to the environment, similarly to the case for chilling. On the energy-recovery side, expanding the gas to run a turbine will cool it (and the turbine) rapidly. Many CAES designs incorporate natural gas simply as a heating function to heat the freshly-expanded gas, meaning the storage system is not a no-fuel system, though it requires far less fuel than a conventional natural-gas generating plant.
The biggest issue I have with the system as described is that the re-expansion of liquified nitrogen isn't free, and requires a source of external heat. Given the phenomenally cold temperature of liquid nitrogen, any passive heating design will rapidly approach thermal equilibrium with the stored medium, limiting the rate of net energy release.
Condensation of the (now gaseous) nitrogen within the turbine would all but certainly result in significant cavitation effects, as well as create a very low-pressure zone on the exhaust side of the turbine, which would probably not be conducive to normal operation.
Heat of vapourisation is not free, and would have to be supplied, somehow.
https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Carnot_efficiency.
He essentiallt states that you can only get a certain maximum % out of exnapsnio engines if you expand them to absolute zero in a vacuum. Since you expand to room temperature and pressure, the equation determines that efficiency. That is why car engines are 35% or efficient. Specialized constant speed diesels a bit better and turbines close to 60%
I'd be super interested to see an efficiency comparison between the frozen air approach and the "concrete (or any other cheap, heavy thing) battery approach" For the uninitiated: the process of using excess energy to drive motors to lift/stack heavy objects tethered to a pulley. Consuming that energy is by slowly lowering them down as they drive an engine/turbine.
As a rider, I'd be equally interested in the realistic energy density between the two methods: how many MWH can you store per acre.
Thirdly, I would guess the concrete battery would require less maintenance--but I'd love to see a comparison of that too.
Thank you for your comment and getting me thinking about this.
There are offerings and deployed energy-storage systems based upon flywheels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flywheel_energy_storage
So overall the lift approach must be pretty efficient, even when we subtract losses for friction in the rope and of the air.
The energy density isn't great, though, you need really much mass, and large elevations, to store anything interesting.
Pumping large amounts of water uphill is more feasible, even if less efficient, and is actually done.
BTW one solution is to use existing hydro dams as partners to wind/solar, add extra generation capacity to the dams, share the transmission infrastructure between the wind/solar/hydro and simply let the dams fill when the wind blows/sun shines. That's more efficient than pumped storage
A compressor is not the reverse of a IC engine.
IC engine is a heat engine, and the reverse of that is a heat pump (not a compressor).
Furthermore, Carnot efficiency refers to heat engine efficiency.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_cycle
The Carnot cycle is a theoretical ideal thermodynamic cycle proposed by French physicist Sadi Carnot in 1824 and expanded upon by others in the 1830s and 1840s. read the wiki for more
How do you mean a Carnot cycle isn't reversible? You can run the cycle in either direction. That's not the same as saying is has 100% efficiency.
>In isolation the process is only 25% efficient, but this is greatly increased (to around 50%) when used with a low-grade cold store, such as a large gravel bed, to capture the cold generated by evaporating the cryogen. The cold is re-used during the next refrigeration cycle.[8]
>Efficiency is further increased when used in conjunction with a power plant or other source of low-grade heat that would otherwise be lost to the atmosphere. Highview Power claims an AC to AC round-trip efficiency of 70%, by using an otherwise waste heat source at 115 °C.
AFAIK there are three main technologies in use today: gas, battery, and plug-in electric.
Assuming that gas is on the way out, chemical batteries have contamination/recycling issues, and plug-in electric isn't appropriate for all use cases (definitely less convenient).
I can't think of anything other than those technologies which comes remotely close to power a small engine for ~30 minutes at a time, once a week.
Will we ever get to "nuclear-powered" weed-whackers?
Wouldn't it be Great(tm) if there were the equivalent of AA/AAA rechargeable batteries but for larger devices? Maybe the 6-cell laptop format is the winner (but look at the variation in that use-case)...
Pollution and smog, otoh, two strokes are notorious for polluting.
I wanted to say "probably not", but I looked some stuff up and now I'm unsure. Essentially all small scale "nuclear power" uses a Radioisotope Thermal Generator. You essentially have a radioactive rock that generates heat and the heat difference is used to generate electricity through the Seebeck effect. The fuel that's typically used for this is Plutonium-238, because it almost exclusively decays as alpha particles (helium-4 nuclei), it has a half life of 87 years while being the most (of the long half life ones) energy dense at around 0.57 W/g. This is what's used in space flight missions and has actually been used to power pacemakers in the past with essentially no ill effect on the patient.
Pu-238 is still too heavy for the amount of power it generates for a weed-whacker. What changed my mind though is that apparently Polonium-210 also almost exclusively decays as alpha particles, but it has an incredible 140 W/g power density. The problem is that it has a half life that's only about a third of the year. It still could technically be used for a weed whacker though.
From a practical standpoint though, small scale "nuclear power", through RTGs, is way too inefficient for it to be used by regular people. Even if you eliminated all the risk of contamination, it would still only make sense for things that need to be running 24/7 that you couldn't swap out the battery on. Fission and fusion, so far, require a far larger plant to generate power.
Another way is to use waste heat from an industrial process to evaporate the liquid air.
It is also possible to use the cold to increase the efficiency of a combustion carnot process such as a natural gas turbine.
Maybe a two tiered approach combined with capacitors for fine tuning?
Lifting weights for energy storage is not really very conceptually different from pumped hydro (both store gravitational potential energy), water just happens to be vastly cheaper per ton than pretty much anything else. Concrete is something like $50 per ton and water is more like $0.50.
On a more general note, I think the issue with these novel storage methods is that even their more optimistic $/kWh targets are barely competitive with existing battery prices. And due to manufacturing scale, battery prices are expected to continue to decline. A similar thing happened in the solar market. Prices were really high, which led to a bunch of startups attempting to bring novel technologies to market (Solyndra was one of them), but once China started flexing its manufacturing muscle, PV prices dropped and the novel technologies had no hope of competing.
Although I suspect for the quantities involved, it still may be impractical.
Favorable geography ON RIVERS is limited. Off rivers, the possibilities are enormous and largely unexploited.
https://qz.com/1355672/stacking-concrete-blocks-is-a-surpris...
Side note, the article has a comment about peak summer power usage that made me laugh out loud:
> For example, Mumbai hits peak consumption in the summer when air conditioners are on full blast, whereas London peaks in winters because of household heating. Ideally, energy captured in one season could be stored for months during low-use seasons, and then deployed later in the high-use seasons.
It seems hilarious to talk about storing power to run AC in order to solve an excess of heat problem. I honestly feel bad for people who die in heat waves in large cities, but it seems pretty absurd that we’re not already running AC cooling on solar like everywhere.
So 10-20% for the compressor.
Then the expansion:- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pneumatic_motor
sir motors are in the 60-65% efficiency range. Then the electric motor to drive the generator is about 93% efficient (some as high as 95%)
This string of 10-20% plus 60-65% plus 93.95%
Gives a net range of 5.58% efficient all at low end of range to about 12.35% at the high end. At best you lose 87% and at worst you lose 94.5%
But this is wasted energy anyway, but it has to pay for manitanance and staff etc, so in the worst case it is terrible and the best case is sub-marinal. Looks like a free energy racket to me?