News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by sbussard on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:08PM (#21993350)
The code might be brilliant but the biggest obstacle to adoption is probably the name and the logo.

All I can think is "beef begins to smell after a couple of weeks" and it's hard to overlook that mental imagery when evaluating the vast array of good options in the programming language space.

It may also be considered culturally insensitive to a noticeable percentage of software engineers, which could hurt the adoption rate.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by GordonS on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:31PM (#21994305)
I'm a huge fan of C#, so this really caught my attention!

But I also have to say that the name logo are... offputting. I don't know why exactly; I'm not a vegetarian or religious or anything like that, and the name doesn't bring anything negative in particular to mind (hell, I love eating beef!), but it just feels... wrong somehow.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by somebodythere on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @04:19PM (#21995908)
It makes me feel like I should wash my hands with soap and water after handling.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by skohan on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:27PM (#21994827)
I am a carnivore, but the name rings pretty well for me. Beef is a simple food: it's not fancy and it doesn't need to be dressed up to be enjoyed. It's also enjoyable on a visceral level, and can hurt you if you're not careful with it. If this language lives up to promise it seems like it fits.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by GordonS on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:33PM (#21994871)
Not sure where you live, but in Europe beef is expensive, certainly "simple food" is not the first thing that springs to mind! I'm sure I've read somewhere it's one of the more expensive meats to produce, per kg, especially compared to chicken and pigs.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by skohan on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:38PM (#21994928)
Sure it's expensive, but by simple I mean it's probably one of the things a 5 year old could list if you asked them what kind of foods there are.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by koboll on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:54PM (#21993898)
Just append " lang" when you Google it. And I'm pretty sure religious food prohibitions don't generally extend to using software that happens to share a name with the prohibited food.

This complaint makes the top 3 comments on every post about a new programming language. It's tiresome.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by downtide on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:43PM (#21994421)
Just rename it to Boof!
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by mouldysammich on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:44PM (#21993798)
I dont think "beef begins to smell" really matters all that much. CockroachDB has built its self a sizeable fortune, and its name is cockroach.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by dmux on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:04PM (#21993993)
Cockroaches are said to be able to survive a nuclear holocaust. I think it's a fitting name for something that's meant to be persistent.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by teach on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:15PM (#21994128)
It's a bit more than that. I'm a vegetarian, so obviously I have a bias, but I think it's objectively true that the beef industry in America is in a pretty bad place. I consider it "horrific", personally, though reasonable people disagree.

Would "veal" be an acceptable name?

When I think of eating beef in 2020, I think of a person whose freedom to eat whatever pleases them is more important than human health, suffering of intelligent animals and the environment.

Allow me a bad analogy. If I interviewed someone for a senior engineering role but they went out of their way to mention that they had named one of their children "Stalin" -- that would be kind of a red flag for me.

So to me, naming your pet project "Beef" is kind-of tone deaf at best.

And at worst, it's thumbing your nose at political correctness: "Haha I named my project Beef because beef is great and fine and if you disagree you're thin-skinned and blindly following the crowd."

I think the issue is a lot more complicated than that.

Just my admittedly-biased two cents.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Accacin on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:30PM (#21994294)
(Mostly pointless comment to add some balance)

I'm Vegan and the name doesn't bother me at all to be honest. I do not agree with the downvoting of parent though, as his reasoning is er.. reasonable.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by kgwgk on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:59PM (#21994578)
> his reasoning is er.. reasonable

Is it? Was the question about how acceptable would "veal" be as a name implying that it would not be acceptable at all? What about “lamb”? Or “pork”? (PORK is the long-awaited Well-Done BEEF, according to https://www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs/project/ozone/www/object-syste...)

By the way, there is also https://beefproject.com/

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by kgwgk on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:24PM (#21994234)
There is a Scheme implementation called Stalin. And another one called Chicken, which you may find even more disturbing than Beef.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by downtide on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:40PM (#21994390)
There's Java and Javascript, heck, there is far worse out there.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by wishinghand on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:14PM (#21994706)
> All I can think is "beef begins to smell after a couple of weeks"

I really don't think that many people would make that connection.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Fellshard on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:50PM (#21993863)
The phrase that comes to mind for me is 'show me the beef', which could actually play in its favor.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by hak8or on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:02PM (#21993975)
Emphasis on notable percentage. That percentage is likely so small that it is easily enough to ignore. It is also not close enough to a "protected class" under USA law (and I assume many other countries too), that is totally fine in the legal sense to ignore those people for the purpose of programming language awareness.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by reaperducer on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:15PM (#21994715)
It may also be considered culturally insensitive

Is C# culturally insensitive to deaf programmers?

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by phyrex on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:21PM (#21994766)
I’m nearsighted and feel offended by “see sharp”! /s
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by yters on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:23PM (#21994230)
OTOH, its culturally inappropriate name might motivate adoption by the non-PC crowd...
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by zem on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @07:23PM (#21997275)
if it's a gamedev language their primary audience is the PC crowd!
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:30PM (#21993636)
> It may also be considered culturally insensitive

Everyone has their opinion; If the author does not consider it culturally insensitive, then there is no problem.

I think there may be a hidden benefit in pre-filtering the community for "developers who flip their shit over naming"..

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by jedberg on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:44PM (#21993799)
> If the author does not consider it culturally insensitive, then there is no problem.

The author can do what he wants, but if he wants adoption, then it would behoove him to consider cultural sensitivity, especially if it is offensive to enough people to stifle adoption.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by blackearl on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:56PM (#21994542)
Catering to people that have those complaints sounds like a Sisyphean trek through hell
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:46PM (#21993812)
In which case see paragraph 2
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by jedberg on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:49PM (#21995047)
I would say that paragraph 2 is completely wrong. Why would you want to filter out people who are culturally sensitive from your community? Because you don't want to have to consider alternate viewpoints?
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @06:34PM (#21996960)
You're putting words in my mouth, I didn't say "people who are culturally sensitive" - that wasn't my euphemism.

Arguing over meat-related naming is exactly the kind of "alternative viewpoint" I have no time for, i.e I would say it's completely wrong.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by zozbot234 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @06:52PM (#21997064)
"Culturally sensitive" often turns into culturally oversensitive...
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Fellshard on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:50PM (#21993854)
It would behoove the above poster to consider cultural sensitivity in selecting to use the word 'behoove', which contains 'hoove', which is a delicacy from cows in some cultures, as well.

Many can play at this game.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by jedberg on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:47PM (#21995029)
I chose that word on purpose.
Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:16PM (#21994149)
And can I choose my own culture? Like say "this is what I endorse and believe in" and that be my culture? Or does this only apply to policically registered "-ism" classes (race, religion etc)?

If so, I belong to the culture that considers it insensitive to shit on things for light-hearted naming themes as if they are of any relevance next to a million other adoption metrics that are more objective, assuming the author even cares to weigh adoption vs creative license in the first place.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by GavinMcG on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @12:52PM (#21993872)
No one needs to "flip their shit" in order for it to be a bad name. I just don't like the sound of the word, for example, and that unpleasant feeling ends up tainting my opinion of the product.

That's totally unfair, but it's how people work.

Re:Show HN: Beef, a new performance-oriented programming lan... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:06PM (#21994023)
Tainting your opinion such that you don't adopt?

If no, it has no effect,

If yes, then either you didn't care much in the first place, or you are indeed, flipping your shit.

And no one said it was a bad name, but that it could be considered culturally insensitive - two ambiguities away from actually being the thing it might considered to be.