News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by scotty79 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @03:19AM (#21989439)
> The problem is that the unprovable statements will include statements that are true, but that the system can't prove.

"5 contains itself" might also be true in some extended system where numbers are considered to also be sets. But in system where numbers are numbers and sets are something different this statement is unprovable because it's nonsensical.

What does even "true" mean if you are allowed to tangle things like "true" and "provable" in self referential paradox and draw conclusions from it?

I think Godel result comes from lax definition of "true". Like Russel's paradox comes from lax definition of how can you define a set.

Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by LudwigNagasena on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @03:39AM (#21989576)
In a system where numbers are not sets this statement is provably false.
Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by scotty79 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @05:28AM (#21990136)
No. It's nonsensical there. It not true or false.

Like "5 smells insanity" is nonsensical in natural language.

You can't even begin to consider if it's true or false because it's not a sentence (in sense of mathemathical logic).

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentence_(mathematical_logic...

Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by LudwigNagasena on Thursday January 09, 2020 @08:26AM (#22000967)
I can concede that it may depend on the precise formal system you are using, but I think you can easily imagine a logic where a predicate ∈ takes two variables (x, y) of any kind and returns "true" iff y is a set and x is in y. In a well-founded system where numbers are ur-elements ∈(5, 5) would be well-formed and equal to "false" as every other expression of the form ∈(x, x).

In this vein I would consider "5 smells insanity" nonsencial in the colloquial sense and at the same time false.