News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Trias11 on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:54PM (#21971260)
I want to explicitly opt-in, not to go through hassle to opt-out at every shitty website of every vendor.

You want to sell my purchase/demographics data? No problem. Just let me know how much or what i'll get for it and i'll decide if it worth to opt-in.

By default - no one should be able to share my data with anyone.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by ApolloFortyNine on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#21971516)
>You want to sell my purchase/demographics data? No problem. Just let me know how much or what i'll get for it and i'll decide if it worth to opt-in.

It should be allowed to be the cost of admission to the site. If you don't like that the advertising and your own metadata allows you to view the site for free, you could just not visit (or when you click no to consent, they would block you).

Websites shouldn't be required to provide you content for free.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by ppseafield on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:31PM (#21971656)
Maybe for some or even most sites this makes sense. But Walmart, Home Depot, etc., from the article are businesses open to the public, and as such operate under laws governing public businesses. Few would put up with Walmart making them sign a contract letting them sell their personal demographic information in order to enter a public store (except if every public business did this, removing the choice - currently how most of the internet works). Why should websites for public businesses be different?

You may say that credit and debit cards do this already (and they do), but you can still pay cash in public stores. Of course they can track you with your phone's bluetooth identifiers, facial recognition, etc., but why as a society should we allow public businesses to require this? Once we permit one place to do it, others will follow.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by fastest963 on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:54PM (#21971886)
> Few would put up with Walmart making them sign a contract letting them sell their personal demographic information in order to enter a public store

What about Costco, BJ's, etc who require a membership to enter the store and (probably) are selling the data they get from your membership?

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by jlgaddis on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#21972301)
In that case, you are making an informed decision by entering into a written contract -- you are free to do that, if you wish.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by droithomme on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:16PM (#21972126)
If something is members-only and you have to pay a fee to be a member is it, legally, public?
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by blackearl on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:10PM (#21972071)
You don't need a membership to enter. Specifically, the Costco near me has a liquor store inside but can't legally have it be part of the store. It's a separate store within Costco, and they won't stop you from walking in, buying liquor, and leaving. You can even grab a cheap hot dog on the way
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by ab_testing on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:31PM (#21972961)
Costco does not do that because of the goodness of their heart. They do that because state laws mandate liquor stores to allow anyone to buy liquor without being part of a club or membership. You can thank your state's liquor lobby for that.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by blackearl on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @03:42PM (#21984569)
I can still go enter without a membership. Liquor store or not.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Trias11 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @03:57PM (#21984735)
Sure, thats what paid membership websites are for.

But none of the websites should be allowed to pull the fast one on their visitors by stealing and sharing visitor data to other entities.

If you going to give me a free kiss, please ask my concent to be infected by personal-data-stealing disease. Of course if you like kissing and don't give a shit about others - government should step in to protect their citizens.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by briffle on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:30PM (#21972270)
Honestly, I would happily pay many websites if they allowed me to, instead of being ad-supported.. I bet Facebook makes less than $10/month selling me targeted ads, tracking info, etc. (much less considering my ad-blockers, etc) I would happily pay for the site, so I am no longer the product, and an actual customer.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by danShumway on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:42PM (#21971769)
Websites aren't required to provide you content for free, and (for the most part) shouldn't be. But they also shouldn't be able to claim that there's an implicit acceptance of TOS by visiting the site. If they want to make it a cost of accessing the site, they should put the equivalent of a paywall in front of the site for data.

If I make an unauthenticated HTTP GET request to a server, and it responds with a 200, it can't claim after the fact that receiving that request means I agreed to something.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by sgslo on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:48PM (#21971825)
There is an HTTP status code of '402' with message 'Payment Required'. Sounds like an appropriate use case for this scenario.

[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status/402

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by kick on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:25PM (#21971568)
By Clicking Here You Agree to Accept Cookies

    [yes] [leave]
Hi! The E.U. makes us put up warnings for cookies. These are silly things that every service on the WWW uses: don't worry, little user, we're just doing what everyone else does!

    [accept] [go away]
By Visiting This Website, You Agree to Have Cookies Placed on Your Device.

    [MORE INFORMATION]
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Trias11 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:02PM (#21984814)
Cookies, shmookies. Most visitors don't know what's cookies are and whats consequances of accepting cookies.

By Clicking Here you Agree to give us your personal information and we may share and monetise it with without compensating you in any way.

[yes, i'm sucker(or VPN user)] [no, GTFO]

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:34PM (#21971688)
Yes, this is the story the websites like to tell. Too bad it's a farce.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:03PM (#21971988)
I don't know I'd call it a "farce;" it pretty closely mirrors my experience browsing the World Wide Web these days.

EU added a hell of an inefficiency to the WWW by making user education the responsibility of every site with no way for a user to pre-emptively signal "Yeah, I get it, and I don't care."

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:33PM (#21972307)
The farce is saying that the popup is needed "because we use cookies". It's because you're using cookies to track users, their PII and sell information and ads.

The EU didn't add any inefficiencies, rather, it's forcing the data abuse by websites to come to light.

If you use cookies only for login/session tracking then guess what, no popup is needed.

Also if the user expressed their consent (or lack of) once, then the popup is not needed anymore (google/fb/etc do exactly that).

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:37PM (#21972351)
So, as a user, how can I signal "I don't care; stop showing me this popup on every site?"

Because if the answer is "per-site signaling," that's soft encouragement to keep using the same sites so I don't need to see that tedious notification and it rewards big players over small players (and defeats some of the benefit of the WWW as a hyperlinked network of data that's fairly location-agnostic).

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:46PM (#21972454)
> as a user, how can I signal "I don't care; stop showing me this popup on every site?"

That's on the website unfortunately

> that's soft encouragement to keep using the same sites so I don't need to see that tedious notification and it rewards big players over small players

I agree, I would want the same option (since I use privacy browser extensions I don't care), it's not the users fault the small sites are playing it dumb and using some generic annoying "we value your privacy" popup BS.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:49PM (#21972498)
... but it may be the fault of the law, since the penalties are significant if small sites don't play the issue conservatively.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:04PM (#21972672)
Fault of the law in which way?

The GDPR does not require continuous confirmation of consent, only that they're allowed to withdraw consent at any time

> The GDPR does not indicate a shelf life for consent. Theoretically, a person’s consent is indefinite,

https://gdpr.eu/gdpr-consent-requirements/

> since the penalties are significant if small sites

This is FUD, proportionality is used when calculating penalties

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:09PM (#21972722)
> This is FUD, proportionality is used when calculating penalties

Can you point to where in the law that guarantee is given? Furthermore, given the previous penalty was "none," any penalty can probably be considered significant for website operators who were previously assuming nearly zero risk in running their sites.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:20PM (#21972833)
https://gdpr.eu/article-83-conditions-for-imposing-administr...

Paragraph 1. > Each supervisory authority shall ensure... in each individual case be effective, proportionate and dissuasive.

Paragraph 2. a) > the nature, gravity and duration of the infringement... as well as the number of data subjects affected and the level of damage suffered by them

Also, as we are discussing this, a lot of this will now apply to CCPA and (in some cases) COPPA

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:23PM (#21972872)
> Also, as we are discussing this, a lot of this will now apply to CCPA and (in some cases) COPPA

Yes, and COPPA has terrified YouTube content creators.

Wiggle language like "proportionate" (especially when paired with "dissuasive") doesn't assuage the fears of website admins, because it isn't a dollars-and-cents (or, in this case, euros) amount. It's at the behest of a judge, which is not a risk space an admin (particularly one running a site as a secondary function, not as core to their business model) wants to take on. So the law, as structured, encourages those popups everywhere forever. Annoying, to say the least.

I don't think I'm spreading the FUD; I think the FUD comes from the ambiguity in the penalties described in the law itself.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by raverbashing on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:10AM (#21978591)
I'll just add that: if they're so worried about the "huge penalties" why are they taking the cheapest way out and using the first non-compliant popup they came across instead of trying to understand the law and come up with an actual solution?
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by shadowgovt on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @10:39AM (#21980950)
Probably because nobody's gotten sued for using the same banner yet. At the end of the day, this law has added a burden very few web site admins wanted; they don't want to understand a law to provide content on the Internet (especially when that was unnecessary only a few years ago, and especially when it isn't perceived as adding value to the user experience). I'm not surprised if people try and do the minimum legally necessary to comply with its ambiguity and pray they don't become the test case to resolve that ambiguity.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by kick on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#21971712)
"By moving your mouse on this website, you signal contentment with your data being processed according to our policies."

It's very easy to extend to whatever you'd like. Consent on the internet is a farce.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Despegar on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:55PM (#21971906)
CCPA is no doubt inferior to GDPR for that very reason. But to keep things in perspective, CCPA was only passed as a compromise because Alastair Mactaggart, a rich real estate developer, forced their hand by threatening to make it a ballot initiative. It's unlikely that California would have led on this issue without the threat of a referendum.

Fortunately he's back at it again with a new ballot initiative, which he's funding himself, to improve on CCPA [1]:

>Mr. Mactaggart said his 2020 state ballot initiative, among other things, would create a state enforcement agency, limit targeted advertisements based on geolocation and add items covered by the “negligent data breach” section, which would allow consumers to pursue legal action in more instances of a hack.

>Most significantly, Mr. Mactaggart said, his new effort would make it harder to adjust the current law any further. The initiative includes a “purpose and intent” section that requires any amendment to the law to be in the service of protecting consumers’ rights to privacy, a legally binding clause that Mr. Mactaggart said would prevent industry from chipping away at the measure.

...

>The lobbying against Mr. Mactaggart’s earlier initiative kept it from the ballot in 2018, and legislators instead passed the privacy law. “It was the right thing to do because there was no guarantee at the ballot box,” Mr. Mactaggart said of his agreement to drop his measure. “Now, it’s different because we have the law.”

>Mr. Mactaggart said he would do whatever it takes to pass his initiative next year, including spending millions of his own money. He bankrolled his last campaign almost entirely himself, spending more than $3 million. Mr. Mactaggart will have to collect more than 623,000 signatures for his new initiative to qualify for the ballot. A survey in October by Goodwin Simon Strategic Research of 777 registered voters in California found that most supported Mr. Mactaggart’s initiative.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/activist-behind-californias-new...

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:17PM (#21972153)
I'm skeptical MacTaggart is doing this out of the goodness of his heart. But I don't see how this benefits a Real Estate developer.

What's his motif for this?

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Despegar on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:46PM (#21972448)
Here's a profile of him.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/14/magazine/facebook-google-...

>What's his motif for this?

Making a dent in the universe.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by scrollaway on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:22PM (#21972192)
Being rich doesn't mean you no longer benefit from having privacy online.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by slig on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:12PM (#21971418)
Any reason why this could not be implemented right in the browser? If the browser sends the specific header, either allowing it or disabling it, the server doesn't need to show the opt-in/out nag.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by JonathonW on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:14PM (#21971454)
They tried that with Do Not Track. It just became another bit of potentially identifying data for browser fingerprinting (and tracking).
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by ceejayoz on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:38PM (#21971728)
Only because compliance with it was voluntary.

There's no reason a government like California couldn't require honoring DNT (within their jurisdiction, of course, as with the CCPA) and provide penalties for violations.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by rebelde on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:18PM (#21972814)
My phone has Google Fi VPN. This VPN doesn't do everything, but websites now think I'm in Mountain View. I am nowhere close. Is a VPN a better solution? I understand that Google might not be the best company to trust here, but they did give it to me for free and it is working fine.
Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by ljm on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:40PM (#21972381)
This is how it should be; it’s how GDPR defined it to.

Instead, the rules weren’t tight enough to stop the current shitshow we now have. Your explicit opt in is a nice single button click, on a modal that fills the entire screen. It tells you nothing about what happens, it’s just easy.

Meanwhile, the rest is hidden away. And you still don’t know if those changes have any effect, especially if the tracking is also done server side. You’ll still get opted into all the emails by default, the needy ones that have to remind you every day that you made an account, and make you log in to disable them (to update their active monthly user count I’m sure).

Of course, it’s working that way because companies share your data with so many random third parties that opting in for each one would scare you away. And most of them do similar things, it’s probably different teams or departments insisting on using their own tools.

I don’t blame advertising for this per-se, I blame growth hacking too.

Re:U.S. retailers rush to comply with CCPA by Despegar on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:00PM (#21972624)
>Instead, the rules weren’t tight enough to stop the current shitshow we now have. Your explicit opt in is a nice single button click, on a modal that fills the entire screen. It tells you nothing about what happens, it’s just easy.

I wouldn't blame GDPR for any company's deficient consent process. That's just what they believe to be in compliance with GDPR, it may not actually be. Many of these questions are being litigated by privacy activists like Max Schrems.