News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by lordnacho on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:51AM (#21962136)
There's one of these in North London as well. I know a fair number of Jewish people there, some more practicing than others. And this is indeed why they have the Eruv, it's to allow them to do some stuff that would otherwise be forbidden.

Another one of these sidesteps was that you can't turn on the TV on the sabbath, but there's nothing stopping you from visiting your friend who happens to have the Spurs game on.

I'll be a little bemused if I die and it turns out there's an afterlife, and in fact it was all a game of rules that you could play with like that.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by davemel37 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:15PM (#21962328)
The only thing an eruv makes permissible is carrying an item from one domain to another. (I.e. a personal house to the public street to a public synagogue.) It's not so much a hack as a way of making the boundry of the two separate domains part of the same domain. The same way, a row of houses can also be a block or a group of streets can also be a neighborhood...there were laws around moving things from one boundry to another, but all boundries are fictions, so its not really doing anything thats tricking anybody...its not really different than buying your neighbors house and putting a big fence around both properties... I think this is actually why an eruv needs permission from the city or mayor. Its actually a legal boundry in this context...

The point about watching the game...thats not really permissible according to many Rabbis, its just an excuse your friend made because its much worse to take an action that completes an electrical circuit (similar to biblical prohibition of lighting a fire) than to just look at something happening...but there is clear guidance about what you are allowed to even read or look at on Shabbos. This is just human nature...we all do the best we can with who we are at any given moment...the Eruv though is a very different mechanism.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by shliachtx on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:34AM (#21970457)
Another important point is that the eruv was instituted because of the rabbinic prohibition on carrying in a semi-public area.

According to Jewish law there are 4 categories of domains: 1) Public (Large area, heavy traffic), 2) Semi-public (most of what we would consider public), 3) Private, 4) Permitted (a small distinct area in the public domain). Carrying in the semi-public domain is biblically permitted, but rabbinically prohibited due to its similarity to a public domain. An allowance was made to carry in the semi-public domain if a symbolic eruv is put up to distinguish it from a public domain.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by jaclaz on Monday January 06, 2020 @05:44AM (#21968123)
>... its much worse to take an action that completes an electrical circuit (similar to biblical prohibition of lighting a fire) than to just look at something happening...but there is clear guidance about what you are allowed to even read or look at on Shabbos.

Knowing very little of the "rules" and on the way they are followed, I have always been intrigued by this thingy here (Halachic switch):

http://www.kosherswitch.com/live/

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by antsar on Monday January 06, 2020 @06:52AM (#21968431)
Excerpt for the lazy:

> When you slide the on/off button, you’re moving an isolated piece of plastic. It is purely mechanical, and is not attached to anything electrical (electro-mechanically isolated). This is done at a time when you see a green Status Light, which provides 100% assurance that the relevant components within the switch are inactive. Subsequently, after a random interval, the device will activate and determine the position of the plastic by flashing an internal light pulse. The attached light fixture will be triggered only after the switch overcomes two failure probability processes – one prior to this light pulse and one after it. Halachically, your action is simply the movement of an isolated piece of plastic with no implications of causation.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by shliachtx on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:17AM (#21970287)
This has been rejected by most rabbinic authorities. The designer is an engineer, not a an expert in Jewish law.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by benchaney on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:53PM (#21966534)
An Eruv isn’t really a loophole. The rule is that you are allowed to carry indoors, or in a walled city. In ancient times the walls of the city basically denoted the extent of the community. Cities aren’t walled anymore for practical reasons, but the principle that you ought to be able to carry within the community is still valid. Instead of getting rid of it, rabbis determined the smallest possible wall that still counts, and that is constructed in order to allow carrying. It’s purpose isn’t to undermine the spirit of the rule, but allow it to continue even as the world changed.

The TV hack is basically an urban legend. I’ve never met anyone who actually uses it, and it definitely violates several rules.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by LeifCarrotson on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:42PM (#21971140)
I'm curious about the city wall classification. If, in ancient times, a small section of the wall fell (analogous to an Eruv wire break), would the area typically contained by the wall no longer be considered a walled city/community? The article writes "When a group of rabbis in the ’80s took a boat around Manhattan to create a map, they realized that most of the wire was gone." and the other article [1] describes the condition of the wire as "intact on every Shabbat except one 2010 snowstorm" and worthy of a Twitter feed to check the weekly status.

I don't imagine that a chipped stone on top of Jerusalem's wall in 600 BC would have made the walled city not walled for the purposes of an Eruv. Manhattan is an island, wouldn't it be enough for the community to declare the shoreline the border of the city? (Or maybe I'm trying to apply logic in a place where it's superseded by authority...)

[1]: https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/eruv-manhattan-invisib...

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by shliachtx on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:48PM (#21972476)
Not to worry, this is all discussed. Technically, the string makes it a series of doorways which together make up a wall. An actual wall would not have this issue, as having a majority of the wall up would be enough to deem any opening a doorway/gap in the wall.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by monkeynotes on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#21971708)
Indeed, at what point do you consider an actual wall interrupted. How much of the rubble counts as a wall? Would a spider web spanning a gap count?
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by monkeynotes on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:34PM (#21971690)
When you start abstracting these ideas to their limits you realize how ridiculous life can be.

There is nothing that would physically prevent a 'wall' being put around the planet and deeming the planet a community.

Is the wall to show people where the boundaries are or to show God?

It all seems to meaninglessly arbitrary.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by xwowsersx on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:55PM (#21972556)
Incorrect. Study the laws of Eruv, which are quite complex, and you'll understand why. Certain areas (the exact definition of which is quite rigorous) simply cannot be turned into private domains for purposes of the laws of Eruv and the Earth falls into this category. No the boundaries are not to "show God".
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by monkeynotes on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:56PM (#21973210)
I just read this article: https://www.halachipedia.com/index.php?title=Introduction_to...

Bonkers if you ask me. There are three biblical areas

> ...reshut ha-yahid (a private domain) and reshut ha-rabbim (a public domain). Any other area is considered a makom patur (an exempt area)

Then Rabbis made up a fourth:

> To avoid inadvertent violations of Shabbat, however, the rabbis introduced a fourth type of domain called a karmelit. This category includes some areas that would be considered a reshut ha-yahid on a biblical level and some areas that would be considered a makom patur on a biblical level.

Which ends up with some oddities that seem to conflict with biblical dictate...

> while an open field is a biblical makom patur [an exempt area], on a rabbinic level it is a karmelit [treated like public domain].

Then the whole discourse degenerates into this...

> Rabbi Yosef Teomim, author of an important commentary on the Shulhan Arukh called the Pri Megadim, raised the possibility that the tzurat ha-petah is only effective in enclosing an area according to rabbinic law. According to biblical law, however, the tzurat ha-petah is ineffective. Subsequently, using a tzurat ha-petah to enclose an area that is considered to be a “public domain” on a biblical level would simply be an insufficient means to convert it into a “private domain.” A karmelit, however, is considered a makom patur on a biblical level and is only considered “public” by the rabbis; thus by erecting a rabbinically sanctioned enclosure, one successfully converts it into a “private domain.”[4]

Every input here just leads to more questions, ultimately I think little of it would make actual sense to me even I studied a lifetime's worth of doctrine.

To avoid a rabbit hole conversation I bow out and just chalk this up to humans being humans. Others are obviously free to think whatever they like, I have no problem with that.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by daveFNbuck on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:07PM (#21962258)
> but there's nothing stopping you from visiting your friend who happens to have the Spurs game on

Your friend doesn't have to just happen to have the game on. You can even invite your friend over to your house to watch the game. You just can't be the one to operate the TV, as using electric appliances is considered work.

It's amazing how much extra effort is required to consider yourself resting on Saturday. People will also take the stairs to avoid the work of elevators and walk to temple to avoid the work of driving.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by JasonFruit on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:20PM (#21962369)
Part of that's a translation problem. "Work" doesn't really express the same concept as melakha, which is more specifically human kinds of work than expenditure of brute force.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by davemel37 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:24PM (#21962407)
My understand of Melakha is creative effort not brute force.(i.e. six days G-d created and the seventh he rested (from that creative effort))
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by cik on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:19PM (#21970908)
Melacha is the 39 base categories of avodah (translated, but not literally work) that went into the construction of the temple. The talmud then expands upon how we learn about and understand these - including their sources and the discussions in Mesechet Shabbat (the Sabbath Tractate).

Over the years Rabbis have clarified and expand these definitions to understand how they relate to the current generation and modern world. This is a long conversation.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by davemel37 on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:15PM (#21971464)
This is sort of correct - its not the temple rather the Mishkan (tabernacle)... The commandment of Shabbos is six days you should "Taaseh Melacha" and rest on the seventh day... later by the building of the Tabernacle, it connects mentions shabbat out of place and is interpreted to mean, dont build the mishkan on shabbat...and to interpret work as related to creating a tabernacle...https://www.etzion.org.il/en/mishkan-and-shabbat

Ultimately, the general idea is "we create during the week and on sabbath, separate ourselves from that creative energy and just enjoy our handiwork, just as the creator of the world did... this is why even plucking a blade of grass would be forbidden..anything that creates either through adding or removing things is in the framework of how Shabbat laws are interpreted...

As I understand it in my lay background.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by JasonFruit on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:32PM (#21962473)
If I have said that God is essentially human in His creative work, then I'm certain you could line up rabbis on either side.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by davemel37 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:23PM (#21962387)
While all rules in Judaism are debated endlessly and have a multitude of opinions... My understanding is that most stringent Halacha followers would agree one SHOULD not watch a spurs game on Shabbos...and there are clearly several rules around separating the day from others that may even make it a prohibition(not that I havent watched my share of sports games on Shabbos.) I just think its worth pointing out that its rare youll find a rabbi that says you Should watch the game.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by monkeynotes on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:39PM (#21971740)
NYC has a bunch of these so that elevators are ok to use on Shabbat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbat_elevator
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by xwowsersx on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:51PM (#21972517)
That's not how it works. The law cannot legislate perfection. There is the substance of the law itself then there is the spirit of the law. For example, highway signs have a speed limit, e.g. "60 MPH". The purpose of the law is safety, but the signs don't say "drive safely". Same applies here, a person can technically not violate any of the rules of the Sabbath and still not be in line with the "spirit" of it. From the standpoint of what you call the "afterlife", there's no difference. This same idea applies to all the laws, as Nachmanides (1194–1270) explains, there is an idea of "someone who is digusting/perverse within the framework of the laws" (hard to translate from the Hebrew) - the idea being that it's possible to not violate any of the laws from a technical standpoint, but still be a terrible person. It's not a game in the way you describe it, it's simply the feature of legal systems, namely that perfection cannot itself be legislated even if it is the purpose of the law.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:15PM (#21962329)
> I'll be a little bemused if I die and it turns out there's an afterlife, and in fact it was all a game of rules that you could play with like that.

That’s the point. In a society, it’s advantageous for the few if most are busy following the rules. Once a critical mass of people break the rules, it’s chaos. But breaking the rules here and there, under the guise of plausible deniability, allows a small group to benefit greatly.

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by Wowfunhappy on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:18PM (#21972806)
Story: my father—a non-practicing jew—was staying in a ski lodge with his friend Steve, and orthodox jew. Steve couldn't go skiing on the sabbath, so he had to stay behind in the lodge that day.

Apparently, if someone is technically jewish, you can't tell them to break sabbath rules. So before my father left for the day, Steve kept telling him about all the great stuff playing on TV.

My father did not get the hint.