News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by LeifCarrotson on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:42PM (#21971140)
I'm curious about the city wall classification. If, in ancient times, a small section of the wall fell (analogous to an Eruv wire break), would the area typically contained by the wall no longer be considered a walled city/community? The article writes "When a group of rabbis in the ’80s took a boat around Manhattan to create a map, they realized that most of the wire was gone." and the other article [1] describes the condition of the wire as "intact on every Shabbat except one 2010 snowstorm" and worthy of a Twitter feed to check the weekly status.

I don't imagine that a chipped stone on top of Jerusalem's wall in 600 BC would have made the walled city not walled for the purposes of an Eruv. Manhattan is an island, wouldn't it be enough for the community to declare the shoreline the border of the city? (Or maybe I'm trying to apply logic in a place where it's superseded by authority...)

[1]: https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/eruv-manhattan-invisib...

Re:The Manhattan Eruv by shliachtx on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:48PM (#21972476)
Not to worry, this is all discussed. Technically, the string makes it a series of doorways which together make up a wall. An actual wall would not have this issue, as having a majority of the wall up would be enough to deem any opening a doorway/gap in the wall.
Re:The Manhattan Eruv by monkeynotes on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#21971708)
Indeed, at what point do you consider an actual wall interrupted. How much of the rubble counts as a wall? Would a spider web spanning a gap count?