From [1] it says: "Kevin and Denis have hand-selected a talented team of seasoned leaders in engineering, physics, and cryptography to build Qrypt’s patented solution." I guess they can add "patent pending", too.
[1] https://www.qrypt.com/about
[2] https://www.ornl.gov/news/qrypt-licenses-ornls-quantum-rando...
There's a difference between not asking for something, and asking for something not to happen.
Besides.. There are many cases where it's a he-said-she-said debate with no clear truth, or where the ethics aren't entirely clear to begin with. But sometimes you're just dealing with the identity killer[0].
I would call that claim first and foremost convoluted, more than specific and detailed, but that is a rather normal practice in patents (IFAIK).
From what I've read (so far), I didn't see anything particularly innovative; not within the field of crypto at least. I'm quite confident that this is nothing particularly new to a crypto expert. I'd say it's all rather well known. Maybe not to Joe next door, but that's irrelevant.
I'd say that this patent should never have been granted, but I can't say that I'm surprised that it did. However, those who filed for this patent must have known what they were doing. Unless my current view on this radically changes, I sincerely hope that it will (somehow, eventually) cost the people involved dearly. I have no sympathy for anyone who would game a broken system like that, as it so far appears they did. Even if not criminal, legally speaking, I still consider it moral corruption to a high degree.
I would think that an academic professor should know better than to try patent something that is already known publicly so well. I can't help but wonder if this is just pure cynicism at work: gaming a broken patent system (for profit), at the expense of (and to hell with) any academic/scientific authority/credibility/reputation. Or is there something I'm completely missing here?
Regardless of whether the patent is granted or not, and unless I'm misunderstanding the whole situation, this professor should probably be deeply ashamed of himself and maybe even be ousted from academia altogether.
EDIT: Not to even start the discussion of how mathematical algorithms shouldn't be patentible in the first place.
EDIT #2: Changed CEO to CTO (typo mistake)