That means poverty, bullying, abuse, anxiety, undiagnosed illnesses... all of that shows up in the classroom. Teachers know this, and continually deal with it when they recognize it and have the opportunity to deal with it. This simple fact informs everything about education, and no reform is possible without understanding and accounting for it.
And anything any disruptor attempts to do will be deeply, pervasively affected by this fact. And none of them seem to give a fuck, though they would if they spent 10 minutes talking to a teacher about it.
My personal opinion is that for some sort of meaningful disruption to happen, ed tech entrepreneurs will have to craft their tools such that they are focused on the end user being the student and what their ultimate needs are. I would also say that the company/idea would need some way to start attacking credentialism and challenge the status quo (university degrees) which also mean you have to factor in the needs of employers.
The truth is most people won't bother with learning much of anything unless they are monetarily incentivized by employment prospects or outright money of some sort.
I would also say it is probably better to craft your product/service on third world countries like India or China which might have easier barriers to crack and at the same time these countries might be responsive to a disruptive ed tech idea as these emerging powers seek to compete with the USA's education dominance.
The real problem to be solved is LEARNING. The goals of teaching and learning are not the same.
Focusing on efficient learning means getting away from outdated methodology like tests, long-winded lectures, and more.
Tests and lectures aren’t outdated, nor even particularly ineffective compared to anything else. I don’t know when it became popular to hate the way school is run, but it usually traces back to the mistaken belief that school should predict professional performance (which is not now—nor ever was—the primary purpose of school).
In both cases, my work with Ed tech has convinced me that the key problems are _social_, not technical.
In Rhode Island, for instance, about 34% of students meet or exceed the expectations of English language arts and 27% for math. These students have been set up for a very difficult future.
Rhode Island is about as nice, safe, and quiet as a large human settlement has ever been (obviously not without social problems).
We're not going to solve the human condition, and I just wonder how best to move forward given that (in RI specifically one might start by fixing the buildings, but that's another story: https://www.providencejournal.com/news/20191215/providence-s...)
RI education data, for the curious: https://lms.backpack.education/public/ride
I wouldn't invest in an ed-tech company whose product depends on learners changing their behavior (e.g., any of the platform companies like Udacity, Coursera, Pluralsight, etc.) unless it was a bet on their enterprise product.
I think efficient learning would need to be always in the sweet spot - not too difficult and not too easy. Most courses have accessible first few lessons and then suddenly ramp up the difficulty without proper support.
Imagine you want to climb down a building. If you take the stairs, it might take you a few minutes but you reliably get to the bottom. If you try to escalate the wall, or do it in a few large jumps, you might never make it. The next step should always be the size you can handle.
Online teaching should have more focus on analysis of student data, more direct student interaction, more customized tools to help students learn and so on.
Do you have any resource suggestions for moving the needle towards the goal of learning pedagogy and materials deeply and intimately?
... who are willing to attack their own profession.
The academic job market is absolutely brutal. Ever more administrators are being hired, and (in some disciplines anyway) fewer and fewer tenure-track professors.
As a result, there are tons of experts, with traditional academic training in spades, who are eager to work in their domain of expertise, and who might be well inclined to engage in some "disruption".
There were two overarching lessons I took from my experience.
The first is that a successful educational product needs to deeply and intimately understand pedagogy and materials -- teaching and learning techniques and how they vary between students, and what kinds of materials are suitable -- deeply, I mean like at a postdoc level.
I've seen so many products fail because the engineers and designers didn't have the slightest idea how students actually learn, think that algorithms could make up for crappy materials, or have zero understanding of what teachers actually do.
And creating good teaching materials with good pedagogy is very expensive. You have to hire educational+domain experts. They don't come cheap. There just aren't that many people who can clearly explain complex concepts gradually, relatably, and accurately in a simple manner.
For some reason, because we all went to school, so many of us think we understand teaching and learning. It's pretty humbling to discover you don't at all.
The second lesson is that education software isn't sold to the kind of market you're probably familiar with. It's not bought by consumers, or even the kinds of enterprises you might be familiar with. It's bought by school districts (or universities), each of whom have incredibly extensive needs for customization -- for interoperability, for the curriculum, for whatever -- and each of whom expect to be given lots of individual attention for a long time before they sign.
Your company will be primarily salespeople, not engineers.
But because there is a ton of money in EDU, you actually only need a handful of school districts or universities to sustain your company. Which then turns into a problem, because it means everyone is using different products, and so much is custom-built. So standards and interoperability don't emerge -- or when they do, they're just, well, really bad.
It's a complicated space. The only other space that feels similarly insanely complicated to me is healthcare.